<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>Conversations Archives - Rungh Cultural Society</title>
	<atom:link href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/category/conversations/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link></link>
	<description>Colour. Culture. Conversations.</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Thu, 21 Sep 2023 05:46:04 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-CA</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	

 
	<item>
		<title>Seeking Relation at the Speed of Trust</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/seeking-relation-speed-of-trust/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=seeking-relation-speed-of-trust</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 10 Sep 2023 23:48:37 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=23075</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>A Cultivating Kin Conversation.</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/seeking-relation-speed-of-trust/">Seeking Relation at the Speed of Trust</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e23075-e1 mhsz-0 mhsz-1 mhsz-2"><div class="x-row e23075-e2 mhsz-5 mhsz-6 mhsz-7 mhsz-8 mhsz-9 mhsz-e mhsz-f"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e23075-e3 mhsz-l"><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e4 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-o mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-10-number-3/">Vol. 10, No. 3</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e23075-e5 mhsz-z main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Seeking Relation at the Speed of Trust</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">A <em>Cultivating Kin</em> Conversation</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e6 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-u">By David Ng and Valerie Sing Turner</div></div><div class="x-col e23075-e7 mhsz-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e23075-e8 mhsz-0 mhsz-2 mhsz-3"><div class="x-row e23075-e9 mhsz-5 mhsz-6 mhsz-8 mhsz-9 mhsz-a mhsz-e mhsz-g"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e23075-e10 mhsz-l"></div><div class="x-col e23075-e11 mhsz-l"><span class="x-image e23075-e12 mhsz-10"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/TawatinaBridgeInstallation_FeatImage.jpg" width="1024" height="800" alt="Tawatina Bridge Installation. Artist David Garneau." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e13 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><p>Tawatina Bridge Installation. Artist David Garneau.</p></div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Seeking+Relation+at+the+Speed+of+Trust', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Seeking+Relation+at+the+Speed+of+Trust&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Seeking+Relation+at+the+Speed+of+Trust&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/seeking-relation-speed-of-trust/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e15 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x"><p><strong>Valerie Sing Turner (VST):</strong> Hi, David!</p>
<p>So…we’ve been tasked with coming up with some kind of chronology of Cultivating Kin’s history of how we got here, to this moment in time where the Cultivating Kin (CK) are preparing to welcome our second cohort of IBPOC artists in residency starting May 2023. But like any movement – and I believe CK is a movement, which, like all movements, takes lessons from and builds upon progressive movements that came before – identifying when exactly a movement starts can be challenging. I mean, people write books and make careers figuring this stuff out! While you and I can both agree on <em>who</em> started this chain of events, without whom CK would not even exist – namely, the indomitable dynamic duo, <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/france-trepanier/">France Trepanier</a> and <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/chris-creighton-kelly/">Chris Creighton-Kelly</a>, who were instrumental in introducing the core members of CK to each other through their extraordinary <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/initiatives/pccp/">Primary Colours/Couleurs primaires initiative</a> – when and how Primary Colours came into being is a whole history unto itself. And how do we pinpoint the exact moment when CK stopped being the “Vancouver chapter” of Primary Colours, and became its own thing? But maybe that’s the point? That the <em>when</em> and <em>how</em> is perhaps not as important or vital as the <em>who</em>? After all, movements are impossible without people, and CK has intentionally made relationality one of the fundamental values of what we do. So maybe we’ll start there – or rather here! Who did you come from, David, in terms of your involvement in Cultivating Kin?</p>
<p><strong>David Ng (DN):</strong> Thanks Valerie! This question of “who do I come from” really resonates with me, for a number of reasons, as I think our origin story, and the claiming of our origins and our roots, has particular significance for racialized people on these lands whose narratives of migration are often signified by our roots being “cut off” when we arrive. In other words, we are meant to assimilate into dominant culture and forget about our “past”; and so by asserting our origin stories, this is a way that I’ve been thinking through our conversations around decolonization at Cultivating Kin. I identify as a queer, second generation, Chinese Canadian. My family village is in the Toisan speaking region of Southern China, where most of my mother’s family is from. My father’s side are Chinese descendants from Indonesia that escaped genocide in the 1960s, fleeing to Malaysia, Singapore, Hong Kong, and eventually migrated to Canada in the 70s.</p>
<p>In 2014, I co-founded an organization named “Love Intersections”, a media arts collective of queer artists of colour, with a mandate to share intersectional and intergenerational stories of queer people of colour in our communities. Love Intersections was started out of a desire to make interventions on systemic racism that we were experiencing as queer people of colour. Through our short documentaries, presentations, exhibitions, writing, and community engaged projects, our intention is to use art to make social change. My art practice that was been developed through our grassroots work at Love Intersections has been deeply informed by genealogies of community engaged art and artists (such as the Downtown Eastside Heart of the City Festival, and Theatre for Living), and also through collaborations with many Indigenous artists and activists I’ve met throughout the years.</p>
<p>So, I think I “come to” Cultivating Kin with many aligned threads that flow through my arts practice: a desire to address systemic racism, an intention to transform inequity in the arts, and also to find ways to engage community shifts at a deeper level, beyond tokenistic gestures of representation. To value lived experience and diversity in a real way. How about you Valerie, who do you come from in terms of your involvement with Cultivating Kin?</p>
<p><strong>VST:</strong> Hey, we might be related – at least by marriage – as I’m sure I have cousins who are Toisan! I’m actually envious that you know so much of your family’s history. As a third-gen Chinese Canadian whose grandparents immigrated from southern China in the early 1900s to Victoria, BC, I came of age when the forces of assimilation were very strong. I realize now that despite my parents’ efforts, especially their attempts to get me and my siblings to learn Cantonese – from taped lessons and Chinese school (which only lasted a few days), to demands that we speak only Chinese at the dinner table (resulting in some very silent dinners!) – my internalized white supremacy made me very resistant to my Chinese heritage; more than that, I deeply regret that the shame I felt in not being white meant that I was never able to engage in conversation with my grandmothers, never able to ask them about the stories of their lives, and thereby losing a vital connection to my sense of self.</p>
<p>While my older brother seems to know more of our family history, I only know that my paternal grandparents were Hakka, and my maternal grandmother was from a village named Tip Sek. I never met my grandfathers, as they had passed before I was born. Any family history beyond that generation is a big black hole for me – which makes me feel even more fortunate to have forged such a strong connection with Cultivating Kin.</p>
<p>It was <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/diane-roberts/">Diane Roberts</a> who introduced me to Chris Creighton-Kelly when I was looking for a facilitator to devise some diversity training for the National Council of Canadian Actors’ Equity Association in 2008, when I was an elected member of Equity’s Western Advisory Committee. Then in 2016, I hired Chris to facilitate Redefining Normal, a weekend retreat for 13 IBPOC activist theatre makers (and one token white artist) in Harrison Hotsprings. Chris offered me an incredible deal I couldn’t refuse: both he and France would facilitate for the price of one! It was after that when Chris and France invited me to be a member of one of the roundtables at the Primary Colours “unconference”.</p>
<p>What about you, David? Who do you come from in our Cultivating Kin lineage?</p>
<p><strong>DN:</strong> In 2015/16 I was working for Theatre for Living (TfL), which had created šxʷʔam̓ət (home), an audience interactive play about reconciliation between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples that toured across BC and Alberta. Based on the premise of how we can “do” reconciliation, along with addressing questions such as “What does reconciliation look and feel like?”, the play was very well received, and I think its popularity was largely because the content and themes were still (at the time) on the fringes of dominant (non-Indigenous) society.</p>
<p><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/margo-kane/">Margo Kane</a> invited David Diamond (Artistic Director of TfL) to join a panel on reconciliation as a part of the Talking Stick Festival Industry series; but because he was unavailable, he sent me to represent TfL. A few days later, I received an invitation from Chris Creighton-Kelly to the Primary Colours gathering. To be honest, I actually ignored the email for a few days because I thought it was for David Diamond, and since we were in the middle of organizing a huge tour and David gets lots of requests, I didn’t respond to Chris. He even followed up, and I told him “David Diamond is not available”, to which he responded with something to the effect of, “No this email is not for David Diamond, it’s for you!”. So that’s how I ended up at the gathering. The gathering itself was an incredible experience for me.</p>
<p>Over the past 6 years I’ve also reflected on this “lineage” that I am a part of – of IBPOC artists that are invested in interrogating “diversity”, racism and inequity in the arts. Valerie, you have been doing that work in the theatre community in particular, but as well as the arts for a very long time; and so I also see my work through <a href="https://loveintersections.com" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Love Intersections</a> as having been foregrounded by the work of artists like yourself, Diane, <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zool-suleman/">Zool Suleman</a>, <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/haruko-okano/">Haruko Okano</a>, and Margo, amongst many others.</p>
<p><strong>VST:</strong> Ok, I’m a bit flustered being considered a member of such illustrious company! But you’ve reminded me that perhaps one of the take-aways from that 2017 gathering that I hadn’t fully appreciated till now is that lineage, like wisdom, isn’t unidirectional.</p>
<p>I remember Chris and France saying that they were calling it an unconference because there would be no expert panels speaking down to the rest of us from their pedestals; instead, everyone was invited because we were all experts in our own particular way – a rather ingenious intergenerational approach to dialogue and knowledge-sharing that honours the battle scars of those who came before us, while acknowledging the value of the perspectives and experiences of younger generations in this work we have chosen to do. I think the thing I loved most about Primary Colours was the opportunity to meet so many incredible and incredibly smart IBPOC artists from across the country and across disciplines – artists I would never have had the opportunity to meet otherwise, like <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/farheen-haq/">Farheen HaQ</a>, <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zab-maboungou/">Zab Maboungou</a>, and the beautiful soul who is no longer with us, Greg Younging. And it was there that I met you for the first time as well, even though we were both working in Vancouver theatre!</p>
<p>I also remember being impressed by the awesomely talented folx who did the simultaneous English-to-French and French-to-English interpretation for the three roundtables, which allowed complex and nuanced conversation in real time among Louis-Karl Picard-Sioui speaking French, Sylvia Hamilton and I responding in English, and Farheen outshining us all as fully bilingual. And of course, the smoked salmon and the fresh-baked BANNOCK at every meal – omg!</p>
<p><strong>DN:</strong> Yes! Everything at that “unconference” was thoughtfully put together: from challenging the power dynamics and hierarchy of “panels, plenaries and keynotes”, shifting the layout of the rooms to be concentric circles, to giving every attendee a role to share knowledge. It was a powerful way to do praxis of the themes of the gathering, which were to decolonize the Canadian art system by placing Indigenous arts practices at the centre of the system, led by Indigenous artists, in solidarity with artists of colour: a recognition that we all have a place in undoing white supremacy and colonialism, and transforming our communities towards just futures.</p></div><a class="x-image e23075-e16 mhsz-10" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/centering-indigenous-art-practices/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/primary-colours-1024x800-1.jpg" width="1024" height="800" alt="Primary Colours/ Coleurs primaires" loading="lazy"></a><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e17 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/centering-indigenous-art-practices/">Centering Indigenous Art Practices</a> - Chris Creighton-Kelly and France Trepanier in conversation with Zool Suleman.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e18 mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x mhsz-y"><p><strong>VST:</strong> Speaking of futures, Chris and France thought of that, too! They made space on the final day of the unconference for artists to gather by city, offering each regional group not only the opportunity to connect with each other, but a small budget to seed the development of local special projects. It turned out the Vancouver group was the largest, about 15 people. We had no idea what we were going to do, but of that 15, a dedicated group of 6-8 artists began to meet to figure it out. I remember Savannah Walling hosting one meeting, and Haruko hosting another. Of course, there was always good food, potluck style.</p>
<p><strong>DN:</strong> Another aspect of PC/Cp and the events and projects that unfolded afterwards was the synergies that led to the evolution of Cultivating Kin. After the 2017 Lekwungen Gathering, two cohorts of participants were invited to Banff for a 2-week residency to go deeper into the themes that we explored on decolonizing the arts.</p></div><a class="x-image e23075-e19 mhsz-10" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/authorization-for-the-fire-between-possession-and-embodiment/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/20180417_152924-16_9-1024x576-1.jpg" width="1024" height="576" alt="“Authorization for the fire: between possession and embodiment" loading="lazy"></a><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e20 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/authorization-for-the-fire-between-possession-and-embodiment/">Authorization for the fire: between possession and embodiment</a>. Reflection on a Primary Colours residency By Helena Martin Franco.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e21 mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x mhsz-y"><p><strong>VST:</strong> Yes! I feel very fortunate to have been one of the 17 artists invited to be a member of the second Banff cohort, because honestly, that experience was a revelation in so many ways. At the check-in on Day 2 following the daily smudging, I was super emotional, I couldn’t stop weeping, and I had no idea why!</p>
<p>It suddenly came to me that I had never been in a space that embraced the <em>entirety</em> of me, and my body was having a hard time coping with the novel feeling of no longer needing to constantly brace myself in anticipation of the unexpected attacks or micro-aggressions I’d become used to as a racialized woman. I recently discovered there’s a term for that constant stress caused by racialization or marginalization: “weathering”.</p>
<p>There were so many highlights: two glorious weeks in beautiful Banff with thought-leaders and artistic Elders such as Margo, Chris, France, Janet Lumb, and Lillian Allen; asking bemused housekeeping for a pair of old sheets we could cut up for a crazy performance art piece cooked up in an hour with Kablusiak; Margo energetically leading a hike around an ice-covered Lake Louise fringed with snow; a magical session in which Casimiro Nhussi and I found ourselves creating movement to the beat of <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/david-garneau/">David Garneau</a> and <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/larissa-lai/">Larissa Lai</a>’s voices as they traded off visceral verses of poetry; joking in our closing circle about feeling like I’d swallowed the red pill, and not wanting to head back into the Matrix – and everyone laughing because they felt exactly the same. This isn’t to say that the real world didn’t infringe upon us – there’s no escaping the institutions and systems of whiteness – but Chris and France had carved out a generous generative space in which we could dig deep into the systemic issues and ourselves, while finding joy in artful comradery and creativity.</p></div><a class="x-image e23075-e22 mhsz-10" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/hummingbirds-and-sleeping-buffalo/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/humming-birds-and-the-sleeping-buffalo-img3.jpg" width="960" height="720" alt="Primary colours / couleurs primaires - Banff reflection" loading="lazy"></a><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e23 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/hummingbirds-and-sleeping-buffalo/">Hummingbirds and Sleeping Buffalo</a>. Reflection on a Primary Colours residency By Charles Campbell.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e24 mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x mhsz-y"><p><strong>DN:</strong> A week before I left for Banff, the City of Vancouver had announced a new program of “Host Your Own Engagement” grants, which were meant for art organizations to conduct community-based consultations on issues of equity in the arts. At the end of my cohort at Banff, we recognized a desire and need to bring what we were exploring at PC/Cp back to community – and so Zool, Haruko, and I essentially wrote the majority of the grant during our last few days at Banff. Once we returned to Vancouver, we booked a meeting with the other Vancouver-based artists who were in the second cohort (which was your cohort!)…and a few months later, we got the news that the grant was successful!</p>
<p><strong>VST:</strong> I know for a fact that we drank the same water in Banff, but seriously: there was something about your cohort – particularly you, Haruko, and Zool – that seemed to have consolidated into this undeniable force that has driven our evolution from Primary Colours to Cultivating Kin on this forward momentum.</p>
<p><strong>DN:</strong> I love the fact that the two Banff cohorts from Vancouver shared a somewhat similar experience at the residency. The City of Vancouver grant, which <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/initiatives/rungh-readings/rungh-readings-full-circle-first-nations-performance/">Full Circle: First Nations Performance</a>, Love Intersections, Visceral Visions, and Rungh Cultural Society were a part of, allowed us to host two community gatherings, where we heard from participants how issues of systemic racism continue to persist in numerous forms in the art system. Someone from the Vancouver Foundation attended the second consultation, and suggested we apply for their systems change grant. About 30 people attended each session, a mix of Black, Indigenous, and racialized artists, arts administrators, curators and other art workers.</p></div><div style="padding:56.25% 0 0 0;position:relative;"><iframe src="https://player.vimeo.com/video/519612764?h=cdef5006da&title=0&byline=0" style="position:absolute;top:0;left:0;width:100%;height:100%;" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; fullscreen; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe></div><script src="https://player.vimeo.com/api/player.js"></script><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e26 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/initiatives/pccp/culture-shift-host-your-engagement/">Culture Shift – Host Your Own Engagement</a> documentation 2018.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e27 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x"><strong>VST:</strong> Once again, interrupting to give credit where it’s due: it was you, Haruko, and Zool who jumped through all the Vancouver Foundation application hoops – including a series of mandatory in-person workshops – and coming up with the brilliant idea of a social innovation “lab” to explore a decolonized granting system for IBPOC artists that landed us the 3-year “Test” grant – just before the world shut down in March 2020.</div><div style="padding:56.25% 0 0 0;position:relative;"><iframe src="https://player.vimeo.com/video/519630281?h=4210a3fb11&title=0&byline=0" style="position:absolute;top:0;left:0;width:100%;height:100%;" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; fullscreen; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe></div><script src="https://player.vimeo.com/api/player.js"></script><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e29 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption">IBPOC Social Innovation Lab – Vancouver Foundation. 2019.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e30 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x"><p><strong>DN:</strong> Oh yes and the pandemic…and the global reckoning of racial injustice that also resurfaced after the murder of George Floyd, the surge in anti-Asian racism, and Land Back movements that increased in mainstream discourse. This was a big moment that shifted the way that we started to do our work at Cultivating Kin. We spent a good year online in dialogue about how we would create a “decolonial” arts funding model, and we spent months debating how we could recalibrate a funding system that would intervene on systemic racism. How do we not replicate the foundations of systemic oppressions? It comes down to one of our core inquiries, which was to create an arts funding system that was built upon different values; using the analogy of the table, current “diversity and inclusion” approaches to addressing inequity are invitations for IBPOC artists to have a seat at the table – but it’s one seat, and it isn’t a table or space that we built.</p>
<p>The racial discourse that emerged during and after the pandemic pushed us towards truly imagining different possibilities. I think of all the dialogue that happened during the pandemic: numerous arts organizations in Canada being called to task on their history of entrenched racism, and even funders like the Vancouver Foundation, and the SEARA initiative in Vancouver, going through their own internal reckoning on issues of equity. The funders were now catching up to what we were trying to create (in terms of an anti-racist arts funding model), and so I think this really influenced our work, in trying to develop an arts funding system that was based upon the 5Rs of decolonization (Linda Tuhiwai-Smith): respect, responsibility, relevancy, reciprocity, and relationality.</p></div><a class="x-image e23075-e31 mhsz-10" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/the-great-welcome/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/primary-colours-great-welcome-featured-image.jpg" width="400" height="225" alt="Mozongi of Zab Maboungou with Elli Miller-Maboungou, Adama Daou, Aboubacar Mané, Gabriella Parson, Karla Etienne, Mithra Rabel, Jennifer Morse, Luis Cabanzo, Raphaëlle Perreault, Le Gesù, November 2015. Photo: Kevin Calixte." loading="lazy"></a><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e32 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/the-great-welcome/">The Great Welcome</a>. Reflection on a Primary Colours residency by Zab Mabougou.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e33 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x"><p><strong>VST:</strong> Relationality was really the key concept that gave us the most to chew on during those pandemic convos. We were trying to figure out what relationality meant not only for the funding system we were re-imagining, but for the <em>process of how</em> we developed this system – including how we related to one another as a disparate group of Indigenous, East Asian, and South Asian artists who were, simultaneously, highly conscious of who was missing at <em>our</em> digital table. A lot of those early pandemic meetings were spent inviting more diverse voices to the table, admittedly resulting in a bit of a revolving door as – speaking for myself – it was incredibly challenging to articulate what exactly we were trying to do! I think it also important to acknowledge that when the Vancouver Foundation’s response to the pandemic included not only increased flexibility as to the timeline of our deliverables, but the complete removal of the obligation to submit interim and final reports, there was this novel feeling that we could take all the time we needed to take a deep dive into process – a dive that may have been a bit bewildering for those of us used to focusing primarily on outcomes because of the current system’s scarcity mindset of limited time and resources. The concept of relationality had us deeply questioning the transactional and capitalistic nature of the current system, and how one of the (many) unintended results is the silo-ing and isolation of artists, which has a disproportionate impact on IBPOC artists.</p>
<p>So it’s somewhat ironic that during a time of worldwide enforced isolation, relationality evolved from concept to embodied state for the Cultivating Kin, as we settled into a core group of Margo, Haruko, Zool, <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/nicole-kelly-westman/">Nicole Kelly Westman</a>, Diane, David Garneau, and you and me. And I don’t know if it was a coincidence, but looking back, as the first wave of vaccinations rolled out, it seems to me that the structure of the funding system we ultimately decided to test with our first cohort began to finally take shape as the idea of gathering safely in person once again seemed possible. But then omicron happened…</p>
<p><strong>DN:</strong> I think the omicron wave also pushed us towards where we ended up in terms of the concentric mentorship model, where an “Art Cousin” would invite in another Cousin to mentor. I remember specifically a meeting where we were debating affirmative action vs decolonization vs Indigenization, and how we could intervene on systemic issues in the funding system without replicating colonial structures. David Garneau brought up how instead of being focused on the “critique” that underpins decolonization, how we could operate from a different perspective, based on and inspired by Indigenous worldviews. So, while we also work to decolonize and to think carefully through representation in our group and in the two cohorts that we’ve worked with, the approach of Cultivating Kin comes from a place of wanting to fund the artists’ full selves. Rather than funding for production, or creation, the focus is the relationship and serving what the artist needs – and if creative projects come out of it, we can offer resources for their work.</p>
<p>We have had some hard learnings as well through this project; putting together a group of racialized artists from a diversity of cultures means that we are bringing some of our own journey with systemic oppression into the work/space – and this has come to the surface a few times. Operating as an unofficial collective, without a formalized structure (i.e. we have no “director”, we aren’t a legal entity, we don’t have a board or hierarchy), has also offered numerous learnings. The work moves at the pace that the group is able to take the work, and moves at the speed of trust. The first year of organizing mostly over zoom was challenging, and also forced us to go through ebbs and flows of building our own internal capacity and relationships.</p></div><a class="x-image e23075-e34 mhsz-10" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/we-continue-to-walk/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Samaqani-Primary-Colours-Reflection-2017.png" width="262" height="200" alt="Art by Samaqani Cocahq. c. 2017" loading="lazy"></a><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e35 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/we-continue-to-walk/">We Continue to Walk</a>. Reflection on a Primary Colours residency by Samaqani Cocahq.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e36 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x"><p><strong>VST:</strong> You’ve reminded me that even within our certainty of what we were <em>not</em> – steering committee, taskforce, executive committee, working group, council – we had a devil of a time figuring out how to refer to ourselves when talking to other artists, and how to explain our positionality without replicating or resorting to the very colonial structures we were trying to subvert! I think at one point, we simply called ourselves the “core group” – though even that didn’t sit well with its implication of the privileged few inside, and everyone else outside. It’s so easy to say what one is not rather than fumble through the potentially fraught, sometimes humorous, and often vulnerable exploration of re-imagining what we <em>could</em> be.</p>
<p>I loved how we traded stories over Zoom about how relationality expressed itself within our respective cultural communities and diasporas – Indigenous, African, East Asian, South Asian, etc.; how the notion of family has traditionally been extended both figuratively and literally beyond bloodlines with the bestowment of Auntie, Uncle, Grandmother, and Grandfather as a status of respect as well as relationality; and how adopted relatives can often provide more meaning and support than blood relatives. We even dissected the concept of nepotism, and how it might be perceived or function (for good and ill) in the model we were developing of extending invitations to four established artists to mentor four younger artists – well before “nepo babies” were becoming a social media thing! I recall mentioning how buoyant I felt the day a Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish) Elder with whom I’d been collaborating greeted me as “Cousin”; and Nicole inspired us to consider the concept of organic growth or cultivation with her beautiful stories about the Indigenous youth she mentored and affectionately dubbed the “Pollinators”, which also surfaced the idea of reinforcing our connection with the natural world. And when we finally landed on “Cultivating Kin”, the word-nerds amongst us were delighted with its elegance of describing not only who we are, but the core of what we’re attempting to do with this initiative. As the great conceptual artist Yoko Ono said, “I thought art was a verb”.</p>
<p>All of this was happening in rapid conjunction with finalizing the structure and participants of our first cohort of eight artists who were to start their six-month residency in January 2022 with a two-day in-person gathering, reconnect at a one-day in-person gathering at the midpoint, and close out with two-day gathering in May. But omicron had other ideas…</p></div><a class="x-image e23075-e37 mhsz-10" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/an-uncertain-latitude/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/david-garneau-idle-no-more.jpg" width="400" height="384" alt="Idle No More II. Pastel on paper. 16 x 16 inches. 2013. Artist: David Garneau." loading="lazy"></a><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e38 mhsz-m mhsz-p mhsz-q mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-v mhsz-w image-caption"><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/an-uncertain-latitude/">An Uncertain Latitude</a>. Reflection on a Primary Colours by David Garneau.</div><div class="x-text x-content e23075-e39 mhsz-m mhsz-n mhsz-p mhsz-r mhsz-s mhsz-t mhsz-v mhsz-x"><p><strong>DN:</strong> Yes, omicron. And I know this has been said over and over again in many contexts regarding the pandemic and quarantine, but the in-person connections we wanted to nurture requires in-person connection. Valerie, as we complete this article, we have recently finished the opening gathering of Cohort Two, and I was reflecting on how powerful it was to be in the presence of artists with similar intentions, goals, and concerns about equity, justice, and decolonization in the arts. The energy and ceremony we were able to create in the circle together lays the foundation for the relationships that will hopefully unfold. I am also thinking about what Diane Roberts, who so generously facilitated most of the sessions, stressed to us that creating ceremony can also be done online, as well as in person. This is something that I am sitting with (and that we are in the middle of experiencing), as our mid cohort check-in is scheduled to be over Zoom…that perhaps expanding our imaginations beyond binary thinking of Zoom vs in person gatherings could open up possibilities of thinking about how we might build relationships through Cultivating Kin.</p>
<p>Another learning that I have been thinking about is how we are trying to build relationships away from transactional, performative, or capitalist underpinnings. How we structured introductions and getting to know each other was far, far removed from the “networking” or “get to know the people in the room to see how you can work together” type of implications that we often experience at art conferences. The best way I can describe how it felt, when we were introducing ourselves throughout the two days – because really, it was two full days of introducing ourselves – was how we could get to know each other's stories.</p>
<p>I don’t want to posture that Cultivating Kin has been some sort of glorious success – in fact, I feel we would interrogate “success” as a metric. But I do know, and feel, that what we are trying to create together is opening up new possibilities for addressing justice and equity in the arts.</p>
<p><strong>VST:</strong> I, too, have been reflecting a lot on the significant differences between the first cohort’s online opening, and Cohort Two’s start by gathering in person. I think it’s possible to have fulfilling and generative interactions online, as our Cultivating Kin meetings can attest. BUT…it seems to me that the success of online relationship building is entirely dependent upon a strong foundation of in-person grounding or ceremony, with enough space and time for fledgling introductory connections to organically grow camaraderie and trust over the sharing of food, stories, laughter, and vulnerability. I read somewhere that 80% of human communication is non-verbal, i.e. conveyed through body language; so it’s easy to understand how a screen that cuts off more than 90% of the human body is a poor substitute for building a relational foundation. Screen communication is also limited to only one person speaking at a time in order to be heard, while an in-person group can easily accommodate multiple simultaneous interactions that can spark that wondrous quality of joyful spontaneity, which in turn sparks a kind of snowball effect of excitement and intimate understanding. I mean, that moment of “Wait a sec, I think I know you?!” recognition on the first day of Cohort Two, when dancer Juolin Lee bounded up the outdoor deck stairs – those comical few seconds in which our animated faces, hands, and forward-leaning body postures struggled to communicate our friendly but mutual confusion, while our open mouths could only elicit gasps or befuddled uh’s until our racing minds could catch up and our tongues spill out the memories of our first encounter just the week before on an opera post-show talk-back panel – was the start of an emotionally rich connection that I’m sure could never happen on Zoom!</p>
<p>As we embark on this six-month journey with Cohort Two, I’m really excited to see how the learnings we took from Cohort One will enable us to create a stronger and more vital experience for our second group of IBPOC cousins. But more than that, I’m looking forward to seeing how everyone – the Cultivating Kin included – might individually and collectively manifest our goals and values of responsible, respectful, and reciprocal relationality on this journey together, according to the relevance of the here and now. Love and peace, David!</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e23075-e40 mhsz-0 mhsz-4"><div class="x-row e23075-e41 mhsz-5 mhsz-6 mhsz-7 mhsz-9 mhsz-b mhsz-e mhsz-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e23075-e42 mhsz-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10647 e23075-e43"><div class="x-section e10647-e1 m87r-0"><div class="x-row e10647-e2 m87r-1 m87r-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10647-e3 m87r-3 m87r-4"><a class="x-image e10647-e4 m87r-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/david-ng/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/david-ng-150x150.png" width="150" height="150" alt="David Ng" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e10647-e5 m87r-3 m87r-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10647-e6 m87r-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>David Ng</strong> is a queer, feminist, media artist, and co-founder of Love Intersections. His current artistic practices grapple with queer, racialized, and diasporic identity, and how intersectional identities can be expressed through media arts.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10647-e7 m87r-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/david-ng/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-23106 e23075-e44"><div class="x-section e23106-e2 mhtu-0"><div class="x-row e23106-e3 mhtu-1 mhtu-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e23106-e4 mhtu-3 mhtu-4"><a class="x-image e23106-e5 mhtu-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/valerie-sing-turner/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ValerieSingTurner-300x300.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Valerie Sing Turner" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e23106-e6 mhtu-3 mhtu-5"><div class="x-text x-content e23106-e7 mhtu-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Valerie Sing Turner</strong> is an award-winning multidisciplinary artist who performs, writes, directs, dramaturges, and produces.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e23106-e8 mhtu-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/valerie-sing-turner/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e23075-e45 mhsz-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e23075-e46 mhsz-0 mhsz-4"><div class="x-row e23075-e47 mhsz-5 mhsz-6 mhsz-7 mhsz-8 mhsz-c mhsz-i mhsz-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e23075-e48 mhsz-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e23075-e49"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e23075-e50 mhsz-0 mhsz-4"><div class="x-row e23075-e51 mhsz-5 mhsz-7 mhsz-8 mhsz-c mhsz-d mhsz-i mhsz-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e23075-e52 mhsz-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e23075-e53"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/seeking-relation-speed-of-trust/">Seeking Relation at the Speed of Trust</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Two Punjabs and More</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/two-punjabs-and-more/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=two-punjabs-and-more</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 15 Oct 2021 19:03:22 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=17122</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>A Conversation about Dūje Pāse Toñ.</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/two-punjabs-and-more/">Two Punjabs and More</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e17122-e1 md7m-0 md7m-1 md7m-2"><div class="x-row e17122-e2 md7m-5 md7m-6 md7m-7 md7m-8 md7m-9 md7m-e md7m-f"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17122-e3 md7m-l"><div class="x-text x-content e17122-e4 md7m-m md7m-n md7m-o md7m-p issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-9-number-1/">Vol. 9, No. 1</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e17122-e5 md7m-t main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Two Punjabs and More</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">A Conversation about <em>Dūje Pāse toñ</em></span></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e17122-e6 md7m-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e17122-e7 md7m-0 md7m-2 md7m-3"><div class="x-row e17122-e8 md7m-5 md7m-6 md7m-8 md7m-9 md7m-a md7m-e md7m-g"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17122-e9 md7m-l"></div><div class="x-col e17122-e10 md7m-l"><span class="x-image e17122-e11 md7m-u"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Jagdeep-Raina_2021_On-Sunday-I-Went-to-The-Kashmir-Gate-1024x800-1.jpg" width="512" height="400" alt="Jagdeep Raina, On Sunday I Went To The Kashmir Gate, 2021, mixed media on paper, sewn fabric quilt, 24.5 x 30 in.. Courtesy of the artist and Cooper Cole, Toronto." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e17122-e12 md7m-m md7m-p md7m-q md7m-r image-caption"><p>Jagdeep Raina, <em>On Sunday I Went To The Kashmir Gate</em>, 2021, mixed media on paper, sewn fabric quilt, 24.5 x 30 in.. Courtesy of the artist and Cooper Cole, Toronto.</p>
<p>Dūje Pāse Toñ (FROM THE OTHER SIDE): ARTS ACROSS THE BORDER, FROM THE TWO PUNJABS</p>
<p>May 27, 2021 – September 4, 2021</p>
<p>Artists in Exhibition: Atul Jith, Gavati Wad, Hifsa Farooq, Jagdeep Raina, Jason Baerg, Jawad Hussain, Kanza Fatima, Krishna Luchoomun, Manvi Bajaj, Nina Celada, Rachita Burjupati, Raghavendra Rao K.V., Ratika Singh, Risham Syed, Rohma Khan, Samia Singh, Sana Iqbal, Sayera Anwar, Shabnam Khan, Shashank Peshawaria, Sreshta Suresh, Taha Ahmad</p>
<p>Curated by Adrienne Fast, Dr. Anne Murphy, Raghavendra Rao K.V.</p>
<p>The Reach Gallery and Museum, Abbotsford, BC</p></div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Two+Punjabs+and+More', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Two+Punjabs+and+More&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Two+Punjabs+and+More&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/two-punjabs-and-more/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e17122-e14 md7m-n md7m-p md7m-q md7m-s"><span style="font-weight: 400;">Editor’s Note: </span>This article is one of two parts that form Rungh’s engagement with <a href="https://www.thereach.ca/exhibition/duje-pase-ton-from-the-other-side-arts-across-the-border-from-the-two-punjabs/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Dūje Pāse Toñ (From the Other Side): Art from the Two Punjabs</em></a>, we urge you to also <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/punjab-punjabi-punjabiyat/">read Anne Murphy’s article, Punjab, Punjabi, <em>Punjabiyat</em></a> in relation to the same exhibition.</div><div style="padding:56.25% 0 0 0;position:relative;"><iframe src="https://player.vimeo.com/video/633082990?h=de9753529f&title=0&byline=0" style="position:absolute;top:0;left:0;width:100%;height:100%;" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; fullscreen; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe></div><script src="https://player.vimeo.com/api/player.js"></script><div class="x-text x-content e17122-e16 md7m-n md7m-p md7m-q md7m-s"><p>Rungh partnered with The Reach Gallery and Museum to host a Conversation about Dūje Pāse Toñ (FROM THE OTHER SIDE): ARTS ACROSS THE BORDER, FROM THE TWO PUNJABS, on Saturday, August 24, 2021.</p>
<p>The conversation was hosted by Dr. Virinder Kalra, and included the three curators (Adrienne Fast, Dr. Anne Murphy, and Raghavendra Rao K. V.), as well as artists Risham Syed, Jagdeep Singh Raina, Ratika Singh and Krishna Luchoomun.</p>
<p>The conversation starts with the curators providing different views on the context for the exhibition, including a detailed virtual exhibition tour, followed by Dr. Kalra in dialogue with the participating artists.</p>
<p>As documentation, Rungh is also providing some of the exhibition images below.</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e17122-e18 md7m-0 md7m-4"><div class="x-row e17122-e19 md7m-5 md7m-6 md7m-7 md7m-9 md7m-b md7m-e md7m-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17122-e20 md7m-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-17155 e17122-e21"><div class="x-section e17155-e1 md8j-0"><div class="x-row e17155-e2 md8j-1 md8j-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17155-e3 md8j-3 md8j-4"><a class="x-image e17155-e4 md8j-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/adrienne-fast/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/adrienne-fast.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Adrienne Fast" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e17155-e5 md8j-3 md8j-5"><div class="x-text x-content e17155-e6 md8j-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>ADRIENNE FAST</strong> is a Curator of Art and Visual Culture at The Reach Gallery and Museum in Abbotsford, BC.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e17155-e7 md8j-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/adrienne-fast/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-17156 e17122-e22"><div class="x-section e17156-e1 md8k-0"><div class="x-row e17156-e2 md8k-1 md8k-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17156-e3 md8k-3 md8k-4"><a class="x-image e17156-e4 md8k-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/virinder-kalra/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/dr-virinder-kalra-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Dr. Virinder Kalra" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e17156-e5 md8k-3 md8k-5"><div class="x-text x-content e17156-e6 md8k-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Dr. Virinder Kalra</strong> is Head of the Sociology Department at the University of Warwick.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e17156-e7 md8k-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/virinder-kalra/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-17157 e17122-e23"><div class="x-section e17157-e1 md8l-0"><div class="x-row e17157-e2 md8l-1 md8l-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17157-e3 md8l-3 md8l-4"><a class="x-image e17157-e4 md8l-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/krishna-luchoomun/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/krishna-luchoomun.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Krishna Luchoomun" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e17157-e5 md8l-3 md8l-5"><div class="x-text x-content e17157-e6 md8l-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Krishna Luchoomun</strong> is a Mauritius based artist.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e17157-e7 md8l-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/krishna-luchoomun/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10560 e17122-e24"><div class="x-section e10560-e2 m85c-0"><div class="x-row e10560-e3 m85c-1 m85c-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10560-e4 m85c-3 m85c-4"><a class="x-image e10560-e5 m85c-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/anne-murphy/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/dr-anne-murphy-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Dr. Anne Murphy" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e10560-e6 m85c-3 m85c-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10560-e7 m85c-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Anne Murphy</strong> teaches in the Department of History at the University of British Columbia. Her research focuses on the Punjab region of India and Pakistan.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10560-e8 m85c-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/anne-murphy/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10749 e17122-e25"><div class="x-section e10749-e1 m8al-0"><div class="x-row e10749-e2 m8al-1 m8al-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10749-e3 m8al-3 m8al-4"><span class="x-image e10749-e4 m8al-6"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/bio-image-not-provided-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="No image provided" loading="lazy"></span></div><div class="x-col e10749-e5 m8al-3 m8al-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10749-e6 m8al-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Jagdeep Singh Raina</strong> is an artist who has studied at the Rhode Island School of Design and the Skowhegan School of Painting and Sculpture in Madison, Maine.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10749-e7 m8al-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/jagdeep-singh-raina/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11204 e17122-e26"><div class="x-section e11204-e1 m8n8-0"><div class="x-row e11204-e2 m8n8-1 m8n8-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11204-e3 m8n8-3 m8n8-4"><a class="x-image e11204-e4 m8n8-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/raghavendra-rao-kv/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/raghavendra-rao-karkala-vasudevaiah-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Raghavendra Rao K.V." loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11204-e5 m8n8-3 m8n8-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11204-e6 m8n8-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Raghavendra Rao K.V.</strong> is a multidisciplinary, practicing visual artist originally from Bangalore, India, and currently living and working in Vancouver, Canada. His practice integrates public art, multi-media work, painting and graphic design. He has taught at the Srishti Institute of Art, Design and Technology, in Bangalore, India for over 15 years and continues to teach and mentor at various institutions.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11204-e7 m8n8-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/raghavendra-rao-kv/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-17158 e17122-e27"><div class="x-section e17158-e1 md8m-0"><div class="x-row e17158-e2 md8m-1 md8m-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17158-e3 md8m-3 md8m-4"><a class="x-image e17158-e4 md8m-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/ratika-singh/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/ratika-singh.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Ratika Singh" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e17158-e5 md8m-3 md8m-5"><div class="x-text x-content e17158-e6 md8m-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Ratika Singh</strong> is an artist, filmmaker, and photographer who established the Preet nagar Residency in 2014.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e17158-e7 md8m-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/ratika-singh/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-17159 e17122-e28"><div class="x-section e17159-e1 md8n-0"><div class="x-row e17159-e2 md8n-1 md8n-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17159-e3 md8n-3 md8n-4"><a class="x-image e17159-e4 md8n-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/risham-syed/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/bio-image-not-provided-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="No image provided" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e17159-e5 md8n-3 md8n-5"><div class="x-text x-content e17159-e6 md8n-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Risham Syed</strong> is a Lahore-based artist.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e17159-e7 md8n-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/risham-syed/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e17122-e29 md7m-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e17122-e30 md7m-0 md7m-4"><div class="x-row e17122-e31 md7m-5 md7m-6 md7m-7 md7m-8 md7m-c md7m-i md7m-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17122-e32 md7m-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e17122-e33"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e17122-e34 md7m-0 md7m-4"><div class="x-row e17122-e35 md7m-5 md7m-7 md7m-8 md7m-c md7m-d md7m-i md7m-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e17122-e36 md7m-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e17122-e37"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/two-punjabs-and-more/">Two Punjabs and More</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>A Rush of Language</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/a-rush-of-language/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=a-rush-of-language</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 15 Apr 2021 16:16:45 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=16253</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 8, No. 3 / ConversationsA Rush of LanguageLarissa Lai reflects on Iron Goddess of MercyRebecca Peng in e-conversation with Larissa&#160;LaiSun Xun, Mythology or Rebellious Bone, 2020 (detail), ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper. Courtesy of the Artist and ShanghART Gallery. Images courtesy of the Vancouver Art Gallery exhibition "Sun Xun: Mythological Time" (February 20, 2021 – September 6, ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/a-rush-of-language/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/a-rush-of-language/">A Rush of Language</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e16253-e1 mcjh-0 mcjh-1 mcjh-2"><div class="x-row e16253-e2 mcjh-5 mcjh-6 mcjh-7 mcjh-8 mcjh-9 mcjh-e mcjh-f"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e16253-e3 mcjh-l"><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e4 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-p mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-8-number-3/">Vol. 8, No. 3</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e16253-e5 mcjh-14 mcjh-15 main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">A Rush of Language</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">Larissa Lai reflects on <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em></span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e6 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-y mcjh-z">Rebecca Peng in e-conversation with Larissa&nbsp;Lai</div></div><div class="x-col e16253-e7 mcjh-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e16253-e8 mcjh-0 mcjh-2 mcjh-3"><div class="x-row e16253-e9 mcjh-5 mcjh-6 mcjh-8 mcjh-9 mcjh-a mcjh-e mcjh-g"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e16253-e10 mcjh-l"></div><div class="x-col e16253-e11 mcjh-l mcjh-m"><span class="x-image e16253-e12 mcjh-17"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SUN-XUN-01.jpg" width="960" height="392" alt="Sun Xun, Mythology or Rebellious Bone, 2020 (detail), ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper, Courtesy of the Artist and ShanghART Gallery" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e13 mcjh-n mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u mcjh-v mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-11 image-caption"><p>Sun Xun, <em>Mythology or Rebellious Bone</em>, 2020 (detail), ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper. Courtesy of the Artist and ShanghART Gallery.</p>
<p>Images courtesy of the Vancouver Art Gallery exhibition "<a href="https://www.vanartgallery.bc.ca/exhibitions/sun-xun-mythological-time" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Sun Xun: Mythological Time</a>" (February 20, 2021 – September 6, 2021).</p></div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=A+Rush+of+Language', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=A+Rush+of+Language&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=A+Rush+of+Language&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/a-rush-of-language/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e15 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-t mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-12"><p><strong>You’ve mentioned before that "the best characters come to you through voice." <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em> has a distinctive voice, too. How do you find—or know when you’ve found—a poetic voice?</strong></p>

<p>A strong voice has a certain energy and a certain resonance. It's as though I can feel the speaker in my body. There's often a strong affect at work as well, as though the voice is moving something collective through me. In a sense, I become the voice, I feel myself to be the speaker, though often only for the duration of writing (I hope — since some of the voices are quite disturbing.) It is the closest experience I've had to being possessed! There's a certain kind of quiet required to receive the voices — but I'm looking for them too. In a sense, the voices are all "me", but "me" is multiple. By channelling the right ones, I hope I'm able to speak to the world out there in ways that will contribute to shifts for the better.</p>

<p><strong><em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em> takes structural cues from both the hexagrams of the I Ching and from haibun. How did these forms influence the creation of the poem?</strong></p>

<p>The poem came to me first in a rush of language. The first time I performed that early version of it, it so overwhelmed me that I broke down, and could barely continue. It needed a bit of structure in order to become human. Fred Wah works with the haibun, in the Mother/Father haibun that close out <em>Waiting For Saskatchewan</em>. Roy Kiyooka also uses the form in "Wheels". Kiyooka's use is not formally rigid, but he takes seriously the travel aspect of the haibun. Most correctly the haibun is a form of travel poem, in which the poet documents the sights seen and conversation had that day, and rounds it off with a haiku to clinch it. It's a form that's been in circulation in an Asian North American context for some time. I was on a panel with Timothy Yu recently where he talked about Fred's use of haibun as a North American pan-Asian usage.</p>

<p>My uptake of the form plays fast and loose with the travel aspect (though I suppose one could argue there's a form social, psychic and "poethical" travel that unfolds in <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em>), but it employs the formal structure quite properly. The revision of the first draft to haibun form helped slow the poem down, put the brakes on the runaway train so to speak. I hope the haiku function as resting places, each one crystallizing something of what went before. I'm aware of the dangers of appropriation and also of exoticization. However, because this poem is dealing in part with the Japanese occupation of Hong Kong, I thought it might be poethically interesting to make the engagement to illustrate the long-standing back and forth connection between Japan and China, themselves not nation states in the Westphalian sense until the late nineteenth century for Japan and the early 20th for China. This back and forth has been sometimes friendly and sometimes hostile. For sure the occupation was the height of the hostile mode.</p>

<p>In a Canadian context, I've had longstanding friendships with many Japanese Canadian writers and artists, some of whom I consider part of my chosen family. One of the things the poem does theoretically/ philosophically is muse on friendly and antagonistic relationships across racial locations, outside or on the margins of whiteness. Are the only possibilities friend or foe? I think not. I think we need way more complication and nuance when we talk about (and swim through) relationships. Another form that haunts my use of haibun is the kanbun, which was Japanese way of translating classical Chinese poetry for contemporary Japanese usage from the Nara period to the mid-20th century.</p>

<p>You rightly note that the I Ching is also important to the project. As there are sixty-four hexagrams in the I Ching, so there are sixty-four fragments in <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em>. The fragments do not correspond to the hexagrams, however. This wasn't the way the language came to me. Where the poem borrows from and learns from the I Ching is in its recognition that different times call for different modes of action/inaction, and also in that there are always layers of contradiction and confluence at work in any given situation. The I Ching teaches me that the world is more interesting and complicated than good vs. evil or left vs. right. Engaging with it has been helpful for me to see beyond the binary politics that seem to shape our lives, especially, though not only in BIPOC communities. It teaches me that a politics of "with or against" is an inheritance of Christian, and specifically protestant, tradition that can only accept or refuse things. This filters into other ways of thinking and acting — particularly Marxist dialectics which demand the constant opposition of forces.<sup class="modern-footnotes-footnote ">1</sup></p>

<p>What I like about the I Ching is that it is a system of binaries — it makes space for binary being, but it organizes the binaries in sets of three and six and places them on a wheel of sixty-four. It offers a system for understanding action/inaction in movement. Also, it doesn't judge. It seems like a way of knowing that could be helpful right now. It also puts me in conversation with Indigenous ways of knowing without appropriating them.</p></div><span class="x-image e16253-e16 mcjh-17"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SUN-XUN-02.jpg" width="960" height="78" alt="Sun Xun, Mythology or Rebellious Bone, 2020, ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper, Courtesy of the Artist and ShanghART Gallery" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e17 mcjh-n mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u mcjh-v mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-11 image-caption"><p>Sun Xun, <em>Mythology or Rebellious Bone</em>, 2020, ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper. Courtesy of the<br />
Artist and ShanghART Gallery.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e18 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-t mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-12"><p><strong><em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em> is an epistolary poem, with a number of addressees. What drew you to the form? What surprised you?</strong></p>

<p>The first time I was really struck by the power epistolary was reading Monika Kin Gagnon's "Letters from Calgary" to Jamelie Hassan during the conference "It's a Cultural Thing" in 1993.<sup class="modern-footnotes-footnote ">2</sup> This was a moment when BIPOC artists were trying to break into the artist-run centre system in Canada and were meeting all kinds of resistance from the mostly white gatekeepers. I was in the midst of the organizing of the conference Writing Thru Race with Roy Miki, Michelle LaFlamme, Peter Hudson, Scott Toguri McFarlane, C. Allyson Lee, Joy Hall and others, and so was facing a very similar set of dynamics to the ones that unfolded during "It's a Cultural Thing".</p>

<p>Monika's letters to Jamelie were powerful because they were public correspondence to an ally — one inhabiting a different subject position, but who fully understood the situation and was sympathetic. It was the first time I realized that, as an Asian person, I didn't always have to speak back to whiteness. I could talk to other Asians, other people of colour, Indigenous people or Black people. When you have an interlocutor, who is not your antagonist, you speak differently. In a sense you make your public differently, even if that public is a public of one. If there are readers or listeners in addition to the person you are speaking directly to, that public broadens out, and is also made differently.</p>

<p>That was the first moment I really saw that when one speaks or writes to another, one brings a world into being with that other. No wonder those BIPOC/white struggles were making for such an awful time. With every antagonistic struggle we were reinforcing one another's positions! Sometimes, of course, it's necessary to do that because one needs to hold the other to account. Or be held to account oneself. But these conditions are not habitable for any length of time. If such conditions are sustained for too long those involved can become unwell, even to the point of death. Of course, any discussion with another is a discussion across difference, but by speaking or writing across fields of difference that are seldom traversed, it is possible to co-produce other publics. The frame of address also matters.</p>

<p>In writing <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em>, I learned that fields of racial difference are only the beginning. How one names oneself and the other shapes who both become. Also, one can speak to plants, animals, concepts and phenomena and transform oneself and the other in so doing. It's temporary and short range of course, when only one person does it. (One person cannot single-handedly change the world — thank goodness!) But if more than one person were to do it? If we were all to do it all the time? The world would actually change. There is massive power then, in trying to see/hear/feel the other and make the world with them.</p>

<p><strong>I’d love to use this invocation of transformation to turn to a few figures of transformation in the work itself. One of the figures I kept an eye out for is the first addressee, the Maenad(s), who is introduced as someone with whom the speaker once "played touch footsie" and later as a "Martyr"; as a figure who balances "ferocious hope and loyalty, full of fear you / charge the door sword in one hand and a plate of chow mein / in the other"; as one who barters, rages, and sobs.</strong></p>

<p><strong>Her reference is in other classical company— for example, the wink to Pentheus and Actaeon—and these three, at least, all strike me as figures of transformation. Characters who in their original texts end up in between or outside of—or perceived, or arguably misrecognized, as being in between or outside of—their safe, "proper" human forms, transgressing or transforming or being transformed. I wonder if you might be able to speak more to the poem’s first, shifting figure of the Maenad or what drew you to these characters?</strong></p>

<p>Thanks so much for paying attention to the figure of Maenad Martyr. This was the original title for the book, but I thought it was too much in the end.</p>

<p>I chose "<em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em>" instead because I wanted the overall frame of the book to be one of compassion. The translation of Kuan Yin used to be "Goddess of Mercy", though in recent decades it's been translated as "Goddess of Compassion" which is probably more correct. I kept "Mercy" though because of the historical moment we are passing through, where it really does sometimes feel like it's mercy from above that we need! I grew up in Newfoundland, where the Catholic tradition is strong, and the cry for mercy is a popular one in times of trial, even among the nonreligious. This past decade or so I have been feeling that need for mercy in my gut. The call for mercy in this book is for me akin to a horrible game kids used to play when I was young, where a big kid would catch a little one, sit on them, and drool over their face or pinch their ear until the smaller one called "Uncle!" or "Mercy!" I have for some time been feeling like that smaller kid. It's not any worse than that, but it's not any better, so I stick around because I know how much worse things can get, and how much worse they already are for many people. But the sticking around, my own agency in it, is maddening — infuriating, so to speak.</p>

<p>"<em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em>" or Tie Kuan Yin, refers to the Buddhist/Taoist/chthonic goddess of compassion, but it is also a kind of oolong tea — a very delicious variety. And tea, of course, is a big reason why my life is the way it is — it's a big part of the reason why there are so many southern Chinese people in the Americas. Tea was a Chinese export good that the British couldn't get enough of through the eighteenth century. It created a massive trade deficit that was draining British silver. In order to balance that deficit, the British began to export massive quantities of opium to China, as a prestige product, but also a product that relieved pain and promoted rest. And addiction, of course. The trade balance shifted in the opposite direction, and the Emperor tried to put a stop to it. Two opium wars were fought as a consequence — it's how Hong Kong ended up becoming a British possession, and a major financial centre. It's how so many of us end up both Anglicized and colonized.</p>

<p>So what has this got to do with Maenad Martyr? In the wake of several major blowouts in the writing/activist/and intellectual communities I inhabit, and the push and pull I was feeling in terms of political commitments and relationships to people in different corners of connected communities, I began to feel both like both my mind and my heart would explode. People were at one another's throats. Everyone had a good point. Everyone was in pain, each in their own specific and incommensurate way. No one was 100% right. No one was 100% wrong either. In order to try to figure out who to side with and what to do to improve the unfolding situations, my rational mind went to work as hard as it could. But there were real contradictions at play that I could see no dialectical resolution to.</p>

<p>Because I'm quite a feeling person (and because of some physical/nerve injuries I have that heighten unpleasant sensations) it was becoming physically painful. This poem began at the height of what I could no longer bear. I surrendered reason and just let the language gush. That was what it seemed to need to do. I didn't know what it was when it first came — it wasn't necessarily for public consumption. It wasn't necessarily finished material. It was just what I needed to do.</p>

<p>But then I heard an interview of Colm Toibin by Eleanor Wachtel on Writers and Company about his book <em>House of Names</em>. He said, "You can't write about the furies." And I thought, that's right. You can't write about them. But they can write themselves into being <em>through you</em>. And that was what they were doing. The voices I was hearing were maenad voices. And I temporarily became one as I spoke/wrote to and through them. I think part of what brings them into being is the deployment of trauma into the political/cultural sphere, where, of course, it belongs because we inherit histories of so much systemic violence. I think, however, that there's a fundamental break between prescribed social action and what it feels like to carry traumatic experience. I'm not saying there's nothing that can be done to respond to trauma, but only that rules and prescriptions are not it. So this is what my Maenad is railing about, and willing to die for. Her truth is rooted, but her speech is high melodrama, full of rage and contradiction.</p>

<p>Of course, Maenads are tied to the story of Actaeon. When I realized who was speaking, I was brought to mind quickly of a poem about Actaeon by John Pass, one that I had quite disliked because it was so sorry for the white men who couldn't help seeing the "naked truth" about women, and didn't deserved to get shredded for it. It wasn't that the feelings expressed in that poem were wrong or bad (though the poem did profoundly misapprehend women's experiences IMHO), but only that the poem re-centred men's experience at a time when women didn't really have a place at the table. (We still hardly do. There is a long way to go on basic sexism in our culture.) I had been carrying my irritation all these years, and now finally, the Maenads were on my doorstep and out for blood.</p></div><span class="x-image e16253-e19 mcjh-17"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SUN-XUN-03.jpg" width="960" height="400" alt="Sun Xun, Mythology or Rebellious Bone, 2020 (detail), ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper, Courtesy of the Artist and ShanghART Gallery" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e20 mcjh-n mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u mcjh-v mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-11 image-caption">Sun Xun, <em>Mythology or Rebellious Bone</em>, 2020 (detail), ink, gold leaf, natural colour pigment on paper. Courtesy of the Artist and ShanghART Gallery</div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e21 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-t mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-12"><p>What Pass did get right, and what I understand too, is that in order for the maenads to do their work, we all have to enter the realm of the collective nonhuman. This work happens at the limit of the human, or at least the limit of the humanist. For those of us who inherit both Western and non-Western traditions, there is room for this. I go to the Tao, which I've already talked about. Other poets might go elsewhere. For Actaeon, this is, as you suggest, a kind of human to animal transformation. In some versions of the story, it's his own dogs who tear him to pieces. In others it's maenads. If we read the myths, as Robert Graves suggests we ought to, as political cartoons, then Actaeon gets his comeuppance for disrespecting women, but only once he ceases to be a man and becomes a stag. ("Dear Deer" has many resonances.) The film theorist Kaja Silverman says that, psychically speaking, fantasies of the body in bits and pieces might be a relief to that form of masculine subjectivity that has been straining so hard for all these centuries to uphold the myth of patriarchal (cis-het) coherence. The maenadic shredding of Actaeon then, becomes a kind of gift.</p>

<p>The story of Pentheus, however, suggests that male looking is ambivalent. (What I like about working with classical figures is that classical ethics are a lot less binary than the Christian ethics that we still live in the thick of. Actaeon's looking was not categorically bad as such, it just went against the virginal dictates of Artemis/Diana.) But if, in contemporary terms, Actaeon is a smarmy, gross cis-het dude who peeks at women and gets punished for it, Pentheus is a different figure altogether. And I must express great gratitude to Trish Salah who was the "poethics/sensitivity reader" for this book for getting me to think about Pentheus.</p>

<p>(Also, I'm not saying that cis-het dudes are gross — to the contrary, there are my dear people in my life including family members, teachers, friends and students who are cis-het dudes, and whom I love. But rather, Actaeon is the archetypical figure of how cis-het dudes can be when the veer into grossness/imbalance, particularly in relation to Artemis. Or to think about it differently, she is the figure that draws them into imbalance. Other archetypes have other ways of being gross! With apologies for the mixed registers!)</p>

<p>King Pentheus is complicated because he imprisons Dionysus, the god of wine, for not permitting women in his rites. Dionysus escapes prison, drives the women of Pentheus's family into a frenzy, and convinces Pentheus to cross-dress, and go spy on them. The women, as maenads, do not recognize Pentheus. They tear him out of his hiding place in a tree, and it's his own mother who rips him to shreds.</p>

<p>Different tellings emphasize different elements of the story, omitting some altogether. Pentheus is a very liminal, and ambivalent figure — the political cartoon is harder to read. Or rather, the events of his story lend themselves to a range of political cartoons. Is Pentheus a pro-feminist trans MTF? Or a lewd hypocrite who bans wine, song, and bodily joy, while secretly spying on death-and-sex frenzied women? Or both? Or neither? A gap opens in the field of metaphor. And, in both the Actaeon and the Pentheus stories, the feminine maenad figures have long since left the realm of reason. One might argue that they are caught in the impossible contradictions of incommensurate political cartoons that depict the same story but from very different points of view. Unable to hold a single position, they lose their sh*t and shred whatever lies in their path, even at their own expense. They have left the realm of the human(ist) rational to enter the realm of the frenzied natural/animal/collective/literary.</p>

<p>In a sense, this what the poem itself does, hence Maenad Martyr, as one potential title. The poem is a symptom of the impossibility of justice in a rational field. The work of transformation is powerful, but it's not necessarily very nice. The poem is a full on rager.<sup class="modern-footnotes-footnote ">3</sup></p>

<p>As for my uptake of classical figures, I can only say that I inherit them along with a lot of the baggage of Western culture. I carry them in much the same way that I carry Christian cultural knowledge, as part of a literature that I inherited through the project of assimilation. Assimilation took away my mother tongue, but it gave me the Western classics. I find wisdom there — a fraught and partial wisdom, but a wisdom nonetheless.</p>

<p><strong>I also will wholeheartedly admit I also kept an eye out for, and was delighted by, every reference to Shrek, and welcome anything you’d like to share about how he found his way into <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em>.</strong></p>

<p>I love Shrek because he's such an outsider figure. I've only seen the first movie — I should watch the others! But I like the way it takes all the old (Western) fairytales and turns them upside-down and backwards so that it's not always the beautiful who win. It's far from perfect, obviously. It valorizes some pretty questionable ideals. But I really appreciate its drive to do otherwise.</p>

<p>Shrek gets in there partially because of this, but what actually instigates his arrival is the work of internal rhyme. If this poem has a method it is, on the one hand trying to write as fast as possible in order enter a heightened, "maenadic" state so that the contents of the unconscious can spill out, without too much conscious control. Internal rhyme, listing, the repeated epistolary invocation "Dear" seemed to be the mechanism to make this happen. "Shrek" rhymes with "Chiang Kai-shek". For some reason, my poetic imagination connects him to the Distant Early Warning (DEW) Line the first time he appears in fragment #1.</p>

<p>Consciously, I guess I was trying to deal with Chiang Kai-shek, the militaristic, murdering head of the Kuomintang in republican China. As you're probably aware, early 20th century Chinese politics were very fraught, brutal and complicated. The KMT, the Communists and the imperialist Japanese are responsible for the horrific deaths of millions of Chinese and Indigenous people throughout Asia, in ways many of us, including me, cannot fully face because it is so horrible and so unresolved. Culpabilities are tangled. Ideological narratives are shifting and contradictory. History is working through bodies in complicated and unresolved ways. No one's hands are clean, and none of the stories are tidy.</p>

<p>Shrek's story, on the other hand, while it valorizes positions of alterity, is very tidy — Shrek gets a classic fairy tale ending. His story is a Disney story after all!<sup class="modern-footnotes-footnote ">4</sup> And the DEW Line was an early warning system built in northern Canada during the Cold War by the US, meant to sound the alarm should the Soviet Union send a missile over our northern border. Might the militaristic Chiang Kai-Shek's uptake of the Chinese republican cause after the death of Sun Yat-Sen have been an early warning to us of how the pure, Shrek-like ideals of modern statehood could go so badly wrong? The DEW Line was way too late (and at the wrong border) to prevent the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Whose lives count and how they count are hopelessly entangled in the exigencies of history and political geography. The ever-shifting entanglement is so hard to hold that maenads have to lose their minds to do it.</p></div><span class="x-image e16253-e22 mcjh-17"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SUN-XUN-04.jpg" width="960" height="270" alt="Sun Xun, Mythological Time, 2016, 2-channel colour video animation with sound, Collection of the Vancouver Art Gallery, Gift of The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in connection with The Robert H. N. Ho Family Foundation Chinese Art Initiative" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e23 mcjh-n mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u mcjh-v mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-11 image-caption">Sun Xun, <em>Mythological Time</em>, 2016, 2-channel colour video animation with sound, Collection of the Vancouver Art Gallery, Gift of The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in connection with The Robert H. N. Ho Family Foundation Chinese Art Initiative.</div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e24 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-t mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-12"><p><strong>In a previous interview, you mentioned that you’re invested in "those moments when the body breaks". The physicality in <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em> is so striking, and I think it’s safe to say you continue to test "the body". For me, the blurring between "body" and "food" seemed especially constant. So many of the poem’s verbs are actions of devouring, consuming, eating as a mode of interacting with the world or others (and not necessarily with substances or subjects one might initially assume to be edible!). Do you see your language around food and its consumption as connected to the multi-faceted desire to explore alternatives to binary (re)action? Or were there other interests or motivations that inspired you to play with this language throughout?</strong></p>

<p>Thanks for asking this question! I don't think I was so fully aware of the work with food and the body while writing. <em>The Tiger Flu</em> very consciously addresses these questions. Perhaps, in writing <em>Iron Goddess of Mercy</em> the food-body connection has just become part of my internal terrain.</p>

<p>I see that there's a lot of meat and fruit in this poem! Especially apples, pork and fish. I realize, as a body of work is beginning to accumulate, I seem to have certain preoccupations — a kind of personal metaphysics. I'm interested in apples as beautiful, delicious, juicy fruits that figure biblically as a sign of women's perfidy (and so instigate feminist conversations, and also conversations about sex and sexuality); as signs of knowledge (also biblical, but connected to our contemporary lives through a giant tech corporation of that name); as a sign of Westernness (no apples except by import in SE Asia); and as full of reproductive possibility.  Apples for me are kind of like eggs. They contain the germ of something that can grow into something else.</p>

<p>As for pork, I'm sure you know that the Chinese character for "home" is an ideogram of a pig under a roof. The pig is a sign of wealth and happiness. Pigs are easier to raise than beef because they will eat anything, and you don't need a lot of space. So archetypically speaking, pigs belong to the axis of wealth and poverty — a very Chinese obsession given the extreme ups and downs of our fortunes. A lot of other cultures think of pigs as dirty and disdain us for eating pork. As someone who eats pork, but gets where it comes from, I'm conscious of my fundamental culpability — not just for pork-eating, but for a lot of things. And fish is obviously a staple for anyone with south Chinese roots, curiously, except my sister, who is allergic. For taoists, to trap a fish means to glean a moment of fleeting knowledge before it slips away again.</p>

<p>The body and food, of course, are connected — it's through food that the outside world gets inside. I suppose there are many sites of exchange — through the breath, air gets in; through the pores, small particles are involuntarily absorbed; through the ears we receive sounds, language, thought; through the eyes the visual world, images, text, ideas; through the skin, feeling. But of all these, eating is the most physical. Well, that and sex, I guess, through which other people go into us or we go into other people.</p>

<p>There's pleasure and violence in food. But to eat is also, in a sense, to both become and absorb the thing eaten. There's that old saying "You are what you eat" — this is true, though in eating, we transform the plants and animals we eat. Eating too much of the wrong thing can cause disease — we can be punished for eating poorly. There's an Chinese expression too — to eat bitterness. The last few centuries have been so rich with the eating of bitterness. My father tells the story of a man who has nothing to eat all his life but gall. He lies under the gall bladder, bound, as it slowly drips into his mouth. In our eating lies our pain, our culpability, our weakness (for delicious things), our strength (because our food nourishes us). We grow into what we will become because we eat. If we eat badly, we grow monstrous. If we eat well, we might grow into good humans, but we are still responsible for what we have taken.</p>

<p>The body then, is not an enclosed entity — for me it is absolutely porous. It takes in everything thrown at it, and becomes a combination of what it is given and what it puts out. It is what befalls it and what it does to others. We are our bodies, and our bodies are porous entities in continuous exchange with the world. For me, the body is as much a vessel of thought as the mind is — they are not separate. I don't embrace the body/mind split. The body is material, but is also social.</p>

<p>Eating is an inherently violent act, which I suspect is why we have so many rituals around it. We are at our most brutal and our most communal when we eat — everyone has to do it, and everyone is responsible for taking life when they do so. That life may be plant life or animal life, but no one escapes the taking. Already as animals that farm, we have betrayed our kinship to other animals. We nurture them, then murder them. The relationship used to be more personal. For some it still is — one of my relatives farms chickens and does all the processing himself. He, unlike most of us, is honest about his relationship to meat. For the rest of us, our relationship to meat is mediated by industrial practices. We are communal and yet detached from the killing. We are communal in our shopping. I hope we are also sometimes communal in our eating — I do think to eat with others is a good thing.</p>

<p>Because I embrace the Tao, I don't embrace the work of refusal. Or at least, I do so sparingly because refusal is its own violence, one that sets the refuser apart from everyone else in an extreme and often destructive way. I think it is possible to acknowledge difference and injustice while staying in relationship. I don't think our lives together are very often improved by refusal. (I won't say never — Indigenous and Black refusal of the rest of us in the current moment, given the long, shoddily addressed and ongoing histories of land theft and anti-Black violence is understandable and demands response. But if there's a gift to be offered from Asian locations, it's that Asian people who survived the 19th and 20th centuries know only too well that revolutions of refusal produce extremes of injustice, torture, and rape, not to mention dictators. The revolution remains important as an ideal, but if you don't have concrete plans for what to do if you win, you end up under the thumb of a cleric, an emperor, or a great leader.)</p>

<p>So, if I don't refuse meat, then I must confront my relationship with it. The same for any form of consumption I engage. In confronting the relationship, which is also confronting my own porous, thinking body, maybe I can make the relationship a bit better. To confront myself and my consumption can often be quite horrifying — hence the eating of strange things in poem, which you note so astutely. I know a lot of people have other ways of doing the work, but this is the practice I engage as my contribution towards getting to a better place from where we are.</p></div><span class="x-image e16253-e25 mcjh-17"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SUN-XUN-05.jpg" width="960" height="270" alt="Sun Xun, Mythological Time, 2016, 2-channel colour video animation with sound, Collection of the Vancouver Art Gallery, Gift of The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in connection with The Robert H. N. Ho Family Foundation Chinese Art Initiative" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e26 mcjh-n mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u mcjh-v mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-11 image-caption">Sun Xun, <em>Mythological Time</em>, 2016, 2-channel colour video animation with sound, Collection of the Vancouver Art Gallery, Gift of The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in connection with The Robert H. N. Ho Family Foundation Chinese Art Initiative</div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e27 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-t mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-12"><p><strong>Perhaps in that spirit of "getting to a better place from where we are": you've spoken about some of the structure and figures in this poem as emerging from a sense of restriction or pain. But this forthright engagement with pain  — and dense histories and violence and chaos  — leads to growth, transformation, and hope. Are there questions you ask yourself or your work to guide it from that initial gush of language towards greater possibility? Do you have any questions you might encourage other writers or readers to ask of the texts they consume?</strong></p>

<p>What I hope this book does structurally is "re-orient" (so to speak) the moments of pain and violence that it carries. That the surrender to chaos, making itself present through internal rhyme, parataxis, and speed brings the traumatic elements the poem carries into the temporality of the furies and releases them. In a sense it's a surrender to the elements of movement — air, water, fire — so that the Iron Goddess doesn't need to carry them as such a burden.</p>

<p>But not completely. It's important to stay grounded in earth, in other words, to be present on the land, remember the past, stay grounded in respect and responsibility. Iron of course, is the metal element — in Chinese cosmology we have five elements rather than four. She's got to be able to wield a complex sword that sweeps through a range of affective modes, including rage and hurt, but also love and hope. And of course, literature must also be able to do these things — perhaps it too belongs to the metal element — the pen and sword as cousin instruments, ha! — though one is more subtle than the other.</p>

<p>I'm feeling quite excited about the form of these poems — as letters, as rants, as prayers, as curses. The form is light, yet it carries a lot of freight — it moves heavy, interrelated things around. If I've done my job well, I hope it moves them around with a certain grace and speed. I think we need that right now. Our struggles have been so heavy. The trolls have been so heavy.</p>

<p>Though the fragments are angry, they are also, I think, quite funny. It's an unusual pairing of affects, that could perhaps break us into another way of being. I'm driving for the ruptures of unexpected, and the universe seems to have granted a cornucopia of surprise to the Iron Goddess. I think a big reason why we are in so much trouble in our contemporary moment is that everyone wants control. The drive to control, IMHO, inevitably produces fascisms with their attendant companions:  fear, cruelty, oppression, repression and charismatic rule. This is happening on both the left and the right — differently and unequally to be sure, but none of us are immune.</p>

<p>So if I've done my job right, the poem contains possibility too. The initial gush is also ongoing gush. The sixty-four fragments mirror the I Ching and in so doing embrace a certain circularity. Or better, a spiral. Its movement is not progressive because it's not linear. What this means, I hope, is that it contains both unbidden impulse and wise/open possibility.</p>

<p>In terms of questions for readers about the texts they consume, I would say: What might it mean to think of books as something other than objects of consumption? I know commodity culture encourages us to treat them that way. It's really hard to find life outside of capital right now. But there are certain entities that do belong outside — governments understood this when I was a child. Books are such entities. So are the elements: earth, water, air, fire, metal. When we consume, we instrumentalize. When we instrumentalize, we sign our own death warrants, IMHO. For the record, I'm not suggesting that it's possible to live outside capitalism. What I am saying is that it is possible to hold and practice values that exceed it.</p></div><span class="x-image e16253-e28 mcjh-17"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SUN-XUN-06.jpg" width="960" height="270" alt="Sun Xun, Mythological Time, 2016, 2-channel colour video animation with sound, Collection of the Vancouver Art Gallery, Gift of The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in connection with The Robert H. N. Ho Family Foundation Chinese Art Initiative" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e29 mcjh-n mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-u mcjh-v mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-11 image-caption">Sun Xun, <em>Mythological Time</em>, 2016, 2-channel colour video animation with sound, Collection of the Vancouver Art Gallery, Gift of The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in connection with The Robert H. N. Ho Family Foundation Chinese Art Initiative.</div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e30 mcjh-n mcjh-o mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-t mcjh-v mcjh-w mcjh-x mcjh-z mcjh-10 mcjh-12"><p><strong>And finally, there's a wonderful scavenger hunt of recommendations embedded in your answers, but what are you reading now that excites you?</strong></p>

<p>I just read Amanda Leduc's <em>The Centaur's Wife</em> and thought it was brilliant. I'm halfway through Jordy Rosenberg's Confessions of the Fox which is clever, and sexy and hilarious. I just read Anahita Jamali Rad's <em>Still</em> in order blurb it and thought it was great. I'm looking forward to reading Junie Desil's >em>eat salt/ gaze at the ocean</p> and Tenille Campbell's <em>nedi nezu (Good Medicine)</em>. I'm also prepping a spring course of cultural organizing in the 1980s and 1990s, and going back to books like Carol Tator's <em>Challenging Racism in the Arts</em> and <em>Telling It: Women Across Languages and Cultures</em>, edited by Lee Maracle, SKY Lee, Daphne Marlatt and Betsy Warland. We need to hang onto our histories, including the messy and complicated parts!</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e16253-e31 mcjh-14 mcjh-16"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Notes</h1></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e16253-e32 mcjh-q mcjh-r mcjh-s mcjh-t mcjh-w mcjh-z mcjh-12 mcjh-13"><ol>
 	<li>I know that Christian tradition is more complex than this, but the way that its tendencies have been received, secularized and diffused through the culture, especially activist culture, both troubles and intrigues me.</li>
 	<li>These appear in her book <em>Other Conundrums</em> for readers who are interested.</li>
 	<li>Wouldn't that make an interesting project for someone — to connect rage to the field of the natural/animal/collective and reconnect all that to the field of justice?</li>
 	<li>See Ariel Dorfman's <em>How to Read Donald Duck</em>, for the problem with Disney.</li>
</ol></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e16253-e33 mcjh-0 mcjh-4"><div class="x-row e16253-e34 mcjh-5 mcjh-6 mcjh-7 mcjh-9 mcjh-b mcjh-e mcjh-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e16253-e35 mcjh-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11027 e16253-e36"><div class="x-section e11027-e1 m8ib-0"><div class="x-row e11027-e2 m8ib-1 m8ib-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11027-e3 m8ib-3 m8ib-4"><a class="x-image e11027-e4 m8ib-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/larissa-lai/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/larissa-lai-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Larissa Lai" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11027-e5 m8ib-3 m8ib-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11027-e6 m8ib-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Larissa Lai</strong> is a writer, poet, and educator.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11027-e7 m8ib-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/larissa-lai/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11412 e16253-e37"><div class="x-section e11412-e1 m8t0-0"><div class="x-row e11412-e2 m8t0-1 m8t0-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11412-e3 m8t0-3 m8t0-4"><a class="x-image e11412-e4 m8t0-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/rebecca-peng/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/rebecca-peng-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Rebecca Peng" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11412-e5 m8t0-3 m8t0-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11412-e6 m8t0-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Rebecca Peng</strong> is a writer, currently living on the traditional, ancestral, and unceded territory of Musqueam, Squamish, and Tsleil-Waututh Nations.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11412-e7 m8t0-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/rebecca-peng/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e16253-e38 mcjh-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e16253-e39 mcjh-0 mcjh-4"><div class="x-row e16253-e40 mcjh-5 mcjh-6 mcjh-7 mcjh-8 mcjh-c mcjh-i mcjh-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e16253-e41 mcjh-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e16253-e42"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e16253-e43 mcjh-0 mcjh-4"><div class="x-row e16253-e44 mcjh-5 mcjh-7 mcjh-8 mcjh-c mcjh-d mcjh-i mcjh-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e16253-e45 mcjh-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e16253-e46"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/a-rush-of-language/">A Rush of Language</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Movements and Practices of Land Back/ land back</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/movements-and-practices-of-land-back/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=movements-and-practices-of-land-back</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 26 Feb 2021 21:52:43 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=15416</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 8, No. 2 / ConversationsMovements and Practices of Land Back/ land backConversations which reflectBy Zoe-Blue Coates and Joy NgendaLand Back October 9, 2020 to January 16, 2021 Open Space Songhees and Esquimalt Nations/ Victoria, BC Featuring Artists: Nicole Neidhardt, Lacie Burning, Chandra Melting Tallow, and Whess Harmon. Curated by Eli Hirtle.Share ArticleIntroductionIn this review/ conversations/ transcript, we wish to ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/movements-and-practices-of-land-back/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/movements-and-practices-of-land-back/">Movements and Practices of Land Back/ land back</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e15416-e1 mbw8-0 mbw8-1 mbw8-2"><div class="x-row e15416-e2 mbw8-5 mbw8-6 mbw8-7 mbw8-8 mbw8-9 mbw8-a mbw8-b mbw8-h mbw8-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e3 mbw8-r mbw8-s"><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e4 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-z mbw8-10 mbw8-11 issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-8-number-2/">Vol. 8, No. 2</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e5 mbw8-1f mbw8-1g main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Movements and Practices of Land Back/ land back</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">Conversations which reflect</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e6 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-14 mbw8-15">By Zoe-Blue Coates and Joy Ngenda</div></div><div class="x-col e15416-e7 mbw8-s mbw8-t"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e15416-e8 mbw8-0 mbw8-2 mbw8-3"><div class="x-row e15416-e9 mbw8-5 mbw8-6 mbw8-7 mbw8-9 mbw8-a mbw8-c mbw8-h mbw8-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e10 mbw8-r mbw8-s"></div><div class="x-col e15416-e11 mbw8-r mbw8-s mbw8-u mbw8-v"><span class="x-image e15416-e12 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-32.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e13 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption"><p>Land Back<br />
October 9, 2020 to January 16, 2021<br />
Open Space<br />
Songhees and Esquimalt Nations/ Victoria, BC<br />
Featuring Artists: Nicole Neidhardt, Lacie Burning,<br />
Chandra Melting Tallow, and Whess Harmon.<br />
Curated by Eli Hirtle.</p></div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Movements+and+Practices+of+Land+Back%2F+land+back', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Movements+and+Practices+of+Land+Back%2F+land+back&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Movements+and+Practices+of+Land+Back%2F+land+back&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/movements-and-practices-of-land-back/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e15 mbw8-1f mbw8-1h"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Introduction</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e16 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p>In this review/ conversations/ transcript, we wish to speak to both the show and the moment in history that it represents. Each of us has had experiences as a supporter on the front lines of the movement, whether that be at one of the many rallies or occupations that sprang up in the Spring of 2020, as response to the raids that took place on Wet’suwet’en land, or by journeying to those lands ourselves during the Summer of 2020, to deepen both personal relationships and our understanding of our place in relationship to the Indigenous people on whose lands we live; unceded, unasked, and so often disrespected. The piece we’ve created is less of a formal review and more of a reflection, brought to life as conversations between us and Eli Hirtle, Indigenous curator at Open Space, and the person responsible for bringing together the artists who created Land Back.</p>
<p>It is accompanied by two audio tracks of our full conversations, offering an opportunity to engage with this work on a different level, and in the original, dialogue-based format.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e17 mbw8-1i mbw8-1k"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-38.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e18 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e19 mbw8-1f mbw8-1h"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">In Conversation: Zoe-Blue Coates and Joy Ngenda (November&nbsp;17,&nbsp;2020)</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e20 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong> ZB:</strong> What is Land back?</p>
<p><strong>JN:</strong> I think before you can define something like Land Back [the show], you have to have an understanding of who you are. Right? And I think that identity is such a hot topic word right now. How you identify has become such an important factor in the way that you move through the world and the jobs that you get, in the politics that you espouse, and all of these things are really intertwined. But I think that it comes out of a deeper sense of identity than just the common social ones, like, your roots, and your heritage, and the knowledge that you have, of the place that you were born, but also the places that your ancestors came from. And the relationship that you have, to the land that you were living on and the land that you came from, and then also the relationships of Indigenous peoples on the lands that you live on, and the lands that you are indigenous to.</p>
<p><strong>ZBC:</strong> I think land back [the movement] definitely goes with identity, as you were saying, and fits in with this idea of justice. And justice with identity is so deeply rooted in our histories and our responsibilities to our ancestors that were wronged. No matter where you are from, I think that land back is something that definitely has a connotation of being used, in so called Canada, with what we saw in Wet’suwet’en, Mi’kma’ki, and Six Nations territories. But that brings about the question: can you only want land back if you are on Turtle Island? Or can you want land back anywhere in the world? And is this you know, a shift towards a global fight against imperialism and colonization, and the sort of capitalism that has come along with those systems? And if so, what does that look like?</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e21 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-10.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e22 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e23 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong>JN:</strong> Yeah, I think part of it is just introducing a complex narrative to accept that we can't all claim the same history and accept that we haven't all experienced the same struggle. It means pushing back against that social narrative that we're corralled into.</p>
<p><strong>ZBC:</strong> Yeah. So, with that, I guess one way that we can push back against that narrative for me, at least is to support the land back movement as an individual, and not necessarily as a black person, but as a black person who has a very specific history on Turtle Island. And as someone who's upholding my family’s values.</p>
<p><strong>JN:</strong> Yeah.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e24 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-41.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e25 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e26 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong>ZBC:</strong> The more that people do that as individuals, the more we can start to form coalitions based on common experiences, right? The two of us have had a chance to support the land back movement in February 2020 at the British Columbia legislative occupation. And now we’re speaking to the artwork that was developed in response to the land back movement that we've seen this year.</p>
<p><strong>JN:</strong> Yeah, the ongoing land back movement, you know, because this isn't just a thing that's going to be done in 2020. I think that land back is such a reimagining of reconciliation. I mean, I really don’t want to say that, but we really grew up in the era of reconciliation. What I mean by that is the Canadian government talked about reconciling with Indigenous people, and building good relationships and honoring treaties, or building new treaties, and agency, you know, and respecting decisions that were made by Indigenous nations. But land back has come along as a reinvigoration of Indigenous politics in Canada or a new way of engagement. Not just by Indigenous peoples, but by the Canadian imagination. By a new generation of people who are coming into their own identities as individuals and citizens of this country, who have a more complex understanding of the ethical implications of our relationship to Indigenous peoples. And what it means for us to live on land that in so many places, was never ceded to Canada. And even in places where it was ceded, it was done through trickery.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e27 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-22.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e28 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e29 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong>ZBC:</strong> Totally, let’s look at the lands that we’re on as an example. We're here on Lekwungen territories. If we look at the example of the Douglas treaties, or the Vancouver Island treaties, there have been legal scholars who have said that they were never treaties to begin with. They are a contract. It was supposed to lay the groundwork for relationship building. Not just something that is signed, left, and forgotten. So that ongoing relationship, I think, is a piece that land back touches on, or at least, like, for me, as a black settler, land back brings up the importance of having an ongoing relationship and honoring that relationship and understanding what your responsibilities are. Whereas truth and reconciliation is about making up for a relationship, saying you're sorry, and moving on.</p>
<p><strong>JN:</strong> Yeah, or not even moving on just stuffing it in a drawer and pretending it didn't happen.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e30 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-13.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e31 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e32 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a mbw8-1b"><p><strong>ZBC:</strong> I think that land back is our wildest imaginations of how we can protect ourselves and look after one another.</p>
<p><strong>JN:</strong> How we can live in a good way.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e33 mbw8-1f mbw8-1h"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Full Audio Conversation:</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-audio x-audio-player e15416-e34 mbw8-1l mbw8-1m" data-x-element-mejs=""><audio class="x-mejs advanced-controls" preload="metadata"><source src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/media/audio/landback/joy-and-zoe-blue-land-back-conversation-nov-17.mp3" type="audio/mpeg"></audio></div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e35 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a">Due to COVID-19 restrictions, each artist in the Land Back show installed their work one at a time over a two-month period. When the final install period was completed, we met curator Eli Hirtle at the Open Space gallery to view the full show. The diversity in mediums and subject matter reflected the different interactions of contributing artists with land back as a movement and ideology, and their visions of its continuation through past, present, and future, through storytelling, prayer, collaborative art, and direct action. This culmination of artwork was hope filled, an archival collection of what each artist had witnessed and the lessons that they wished to pass along to the viewer.</div><div class="x-row e15416-e36 mbw8-6 mbw8-7 mbw8-8 mbw8-9 mbw8-d mbw8-e mbw8-k mbw8-l"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e37 mbw8-s mbw8-t mbw8-u mbw8-w"><span class="x-image e15416-e38 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-23-768x1024.jpg" width="384" height="512" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e39 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 mbw8-1c image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div></div><div class="x-col e15416-e40 mbw8-s mbw8-t mbw8-u mbw8-w"><span class="x-image e15416-e41 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-5-585x1024.jpg" width="292" height="512" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e42 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-19 mbw8-1d mbw8-1e image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e43 mbw8-1f mbw8-1h"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">In Conversation: Zoe-Blue Coates, Eli Hirtle, Joy Ngenda (November 27th at Open&nbsp;Space)</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e44 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong>Eli Hirtle:</strong> Something that we're doing as a part of this exhibition is each of the artists were commissioned to design a risograph print. We're putting those up in the shop. This isn’t just about their art careers and having a show on their CV, They’ve worked together to produce something that's going to generate funds. Nicole’s [funds are] going to the K’é infoshop in Alberquerque, which has been doing a ton of mutual aid during COVID for Navajo Nation, getting water to elders, and PPE (personal protective equipment) to people. Chandra's [funds are] going to Tiny House Warriors. [Funds from] Whess’s poster and patches are going to Unist’ot’en. And Lacy's [are] going to 1492 Land Back Lane legal funds. That’s a way to work with each of the artists about what Land Back means to them, and where they want the money, what they want to support through this exhibit.</p>
<p><strong>Zoe-Blue Coates:</strong> I think something that's really interesting, is the ways that artists often respond to social movements with their creations. Within BIPOC spaces everything that we do always goes back to liberation. At least in my mind, it does within the artist community that I grew up in, it always goes back to liberation. It always goes back to: how is this going to educate people? How is this going to support our communities? So, it's really cool to see that happening.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e45 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-21.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e46 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e47 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong>EH:</strong> Yeah, I often get disillusioned with the contemporary art world, and the trappings of that. How the systems that are in place, [… ] public galleries and museums and artists run centers, and art schools and the whole system. There's a competitive nature to it. It's all about like excellence and outperforming one another and how much recognition you get, winning awards. There's all of that stuff. And it's completely at odds in a lot of ways, from activist communities that I was a part of, before coming into this world. That's why I often feel this tension, this push and pull.</p>
<p>Nicole and I were at a beadwork symposium in Winnipeg, when the first occupation was happening. And so, we were like, “What the fuck are we doing here?” And no one's talking about it. It's about beadwork, these designs that come from the land, and no one is talking about what's going on. That's when all the blockades were happening everywhere. And it was just like, fuck, this is the only thing that I'm thinking about.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e48 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-17.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e49 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e50 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p>And this, [Land Back the show] continues that momentum, I hope. I hope it's also in some ways, challenging some of the conventions of how we may do exhibitions. The staggered install was a very deliberate decision. Outside of it being more safe to have each artist come in one at a time, instead of having all of the work, or all of the artists here at the same time. And in my mind as I was thinking it through, not even knowing if we're gonna be able to do it in the fall, in the summer, in the spring. And this way, in my mind we would more authentically replicate the energy and the ebb and flow of bodies and resources in an action like a protest, a blockade, or an occupation. This would also give an opportunity for each artist's work to be showcased individually. To build into something bigger than the individuals and kind of, you know, reflect these communities that we come from and that we represent and that we're a part of.</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e51 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-25.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e52 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e53 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p>It was a lot of work. We're trying to organize everything, keep ourselves going for eight weeks. I'm like, what was I thinking? I kind of wish we just did it in an intense week or two weeks? Yeah. But then it would have just been the same.</p>
<p><strong>Joy Ngenda:</strong> How do we sustain that forward motion of Land Back? And not just put up one vertical front that never moves? I feel like land back is such a baby movement. You know what I mean? There's so many things that have been going on, like fronts for so long, and land back kind of just shot out of nowhere, earlier this year. And now here we all are. It's become such a rallying cry for so many people in the last ten months. How did it feel to be working with a concept that is still in its infancy and is still becoming itself?</p></div><span class="x-image e15416-e54 mbw8-1i mbw8-1j"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/LAND-BACK-Kara-Stanton-14.jpg" width="960" height="540" alt="Land Back (Kara Stanton)" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e55 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-18 mbw8-19 image-caption">Land Back. Photo credit: Kara&nbsp;Stanton.</div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e56 mbw8-x mbw8-y mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-13 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-1a"><p><strong>EH:</strong> Well, I have been keeping in mind, this is a continuation of hundreds of years of labor in different communities and people, some known, some unknown, some celebrated […], some not at all. Our Elder-In-Residence, Gerry Ambers, has been doing this work for 50 years. And she told me a story about how her and some friends at Sechelt in the late 60s were liberating kids from a residential school. They were asked by the community; they were part of the Red Power movement in Vancouver. And they went and got kids out of school. And she was a part of actions down in Washington State to help get fishing rights, and got that fight going. There's the occupation of Alcatraz Island, there's Wounded Knee, there are dozens and dozens, and this is just thinking of North America, movements, and pivot points where things have happened. And so, I think in the more recent history of Idle No More and Standing Rock [movements]. And how the folks who started Standing Rock, were inspired by what Frida and folks were doing in Wet’suwet’en territory. And then these things feed each other and the energy builds, and we learn from each other. We shared skills when I went to Unistot’en, and there were folks from back east and folks from down south. That action camp was all about skill sharing and teaching one another. And I think that's the context that I place it within as a continuation and the newest iteration of these previous movements. It's totally correct, that land back is still figuring out what it means. How it’s going to mobilize people. And I think within that there's so much possibility in it being reflexive and site specific to whatever community things are happening within. I think maybe Idle No More, it was a little bit more constrained. And also, maybe centralized in a certain way with the four or five founders of Idle No More and this [land back] has such a decentralized feeling to me.</p>
<p><strong>JN:</strong> That’s beautiful.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e57 mbw8-1f mbw8-1h"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Full Audio Conversation:</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-audio x-audio-player e15416-e58 mbw8-1l mbw8-1m" data-x-element-mejs=""><audio class="x-mejs advanced-controls" preload="metadata"><source src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/media/audio/landback/eli-land-back-conversation-nov-27.mp3" type="audio/mpeg"></audio></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e15416-e59 mbw8-1f mbw8-1h"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Risograph Prints for Land Back at Open Space</h2></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e15416-e60 mbw8-5 mbw8-6 mbw8-7 mbw8-8 mbw8-b mbw8-f mbw8-m mbw8-n"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e61 mbw8-r mbw8-s"><div class="x-content-area e15416-e62 mbw8-1n"></div><div class="x-text x-content e15416-e63 mbw8-x mbw8-10 mbw8-11 mbw8-12 mbw8-15 mbw8-16 mbw8-17 mbw8-19 mbw8-1e image-caption">Risograph Prints for Land Back at Open&nbsp;Space.</div></div><div class="x-col e15416-e64 mbw8-r mbw8-s"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e15416-e65 mbw8-0 mbw8-4"><div class="x-row e15416-e66 mbw8-5 mbw8-6 mbw8-7 mbw8-8 mbw8-b mbw8-f mbw8-m mbw8-o"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e67 mbw8-r mbw8-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-15449 e15416-e68"><div class="x-section e15449-e1 mbx5-0"><div class="x-row e15449-e2 mbx5-1 mbx5-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15449-e3 mbx5-3 mbx5-4"><a class="x-image e15449-e4 mbx5-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zoe-blue-coates/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/zoe-blue-coates-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Zoë-Blue Coates" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e15449-e5 mbx5-3 mbx5-5"><div class="x-text x-content e15449-e6 mbx5-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Zoë-Blue Coates</strong> is an artist and historian of Afro-Caribbean and African American descent. She is the founder and editor of BioDiversity zine, a project aimed at teaching people of all ages about the histories of ecological stewards of colour.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e15449-e7 mbx5-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zoe-blue-coates/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-15451 e15416-e69"><div class="x-section e15451-e1 mbx7-0"><div class="x-row e15451-e2 mbx7-1 mbx7-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15451-e3 mbx7-3 mbx7-4"><a class="x-image e15451-e4 mbx7-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/eli-hirtle/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/eli-hirtle-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Eli Hirtle" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e15451-e5 mbx7-3 mbx7-5"><div class="x-text x-content e15451-e6 mbx7-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Eli Hirtle</strong> is a nêhiyaw(Cree)/British/German filmmaker, beadworker, youth mentor and curator based on Lekwungen Territory in Victoria, BC, Canada. His practice involves making films about Indigenous cultural resurgence and language revitalization, as well as investigating his nêhiyaw identity through beadwork.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e15451-e7 mbx7-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/eli-hirtle/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-15450 e15416-e70"><div class="x-section e15450-e1 mbx6-0"><div class="x-row e15450-e2 mbx6-1 mbx6-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15450-e3 mbx6-3 mbx6-4"><a class="x-image e15450-e4 mbx6-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/joy-ngenda/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/joy-ngenda-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Joy Ngenda" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e15450-e5 mbx6-3 mbx6-5"><div class="x-text x-content e15450-e6 mbx6-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Joy Ngenda</strong> is a queer, mixed West African transplant who has been living on unceded Lekwungen lands for the last 4 years. They are a multi-disciplinary artist and sometimes student, with a passion for ethical organizing and community justice.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e15450-e7 mbx6-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/joy-ngenda/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e15416-e71 mbw8-r mbw8-s"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e15416-e72 mbw8-0 mbw8-4"><div class="x-row e15416-e73 mbw8-5 mbw8-6 mbw8-7 mbw8-8 mbw8-9 mbw8-b mbw8-e mbw8-k mbw8-p"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e74 mbw8-r mbw8-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e15416-e75"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e15416-e76 mbw8-0 mbw8-4"><div class="x-row e15416-e77 mbw8-5 mbw8-6 mbw8-8 mbw8-9 mbw8-b mbw8-e mbw8-g mbw8-k mbw8-q"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e15416-e78 mbw8-r mbw8-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e15416-e79"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/movements-and-practices-of-land-back/">Movements and Practices of Land Back/ land back</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Solidaridad</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/solidaridad/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=solidaridad</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 01 Feb 2021 19:35:13 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/solidaridad/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 8, No. 2 / ConversationsSolidaridadReflections on Repair, Reassemble, and Reunite.By Carmen AguirreShare ArticleEditor's Note: This text is being published as an accompaniment to Carmen Aguirre’s recorded performance which was commissioned for the 2021 PuSh Rally in January 2021. The rally was cancelled. Carmen Aguirre released her video recording publicly. Rungh is now printing the full text of her performance.I’d ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/solidaridad/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/solidaridad/">Solidaridad</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e13845-e1 maol-0 maol-1 maol-2"><div class="x-row e13845-e2 maol-5 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-a maol-b maol-g maol-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e3 maol-r maol-s"><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e4 maol-v maol-w maol-x maol-y maol-z issue-category-btn"><a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/volume-8-number-2/">Vol. 8, No. 2</a> / <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e13845-e5 maol-18 main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Solidaridad</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">Reflections on Repair, Reassemble, and Reunite.</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e6 maol-v maol-w maol-10 maol-11 maol-12">By Carmen Aguirre</div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e7 maol-s maol-t"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e13845-e8 maol-0 maol-2 maol-3"><div class="x-row e13845-e9 maol-5 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-a maol-g maol-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e10 maol-r maol-s maol-u"><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Solidaridad', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Solidaridad&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Solidaridad&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/solidaridad/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e12 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14"><strong>Editor's Note:</strong> <em>This text is being published as an accompaniment to Carmen Aguirre’s recorded performance which was commissioned for the 2021 PuSh Rally in January 2021. The rally was cancelled. Carmen Aguirre released her video recording publicly. Rungh is now printing the full text of her performance.</em></div><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e13 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14">I’d like to express gratitude to the Musqueam, Squamish, and Tsleil-Waututh Nations for letting me grow, heal, work, live, and raise my son on these unceded territories. I am from Chile, in Latin America. The Indigenous name for Latin America is Abya Yala. My relationship to my land is that I was exiled, my relationship to this land is that I was raised in exile here. I never chose to leave my land and I still dream that I will return to live there someday. My relationship to these lands is not about displacing others, colonizing others, or exploiting others. I am not a settler. I am a visitor here. I’d like to acknowledge that this country was built with the exploited labour of working people from Europe and the Global South. The violent extraction of land, resources, bodies, and surplus value are the conditions for the possibility of what we today know as Canada.</div><div class="x-frame x-frame-video-embed e13845-e14 maol-19 maol-1a"><div class="x-frame-inner"><div class="x-video x-video-embed"><div style="padding:56.25% 0 0 0;position:relative;"><iframe src="https://player.vimeo.com/video/505999875?title=0&byline=0" style="position:absolute;top:0;left:0;width:100%;height:100%;" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; fullscreen; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe></div><script src="https://player.vimeo.com/api/player.js"></script></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e15 maol-v maol-y maol-z maol-10 maol-13 maol-15 maol-16 image-caption">Carmen Aguirre Video Essay Commissioned for the PuSh International Performing Arts Festival's&nbsp;Rally.</div><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e16 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14"><p>La historia es nuestra y la hacen los pueblos. History is ours and it is made by the People.</p>
<p>Se abrirán las grandes alamedas por donde pase el hombre libre, para construir una sociedad mejor. The great avenues will open once again, where the free man will walk, in order to build a better society.</p>
<p>El pueblo unido jamas sera vencido. El pueblo unido jamas sera vencido.</p>
<p>Venceremos, venceremos, mil cadenas abra que romper, venceremos, venceremos, al fascismo sabremos vencer.</p>
<p>Solidaridad.</p>
<p>Resistencia.</p>
<p>Revolucion.</p>
<p>Hasta la Victoria siempre.</p>
<p>Companera. Companero, que hermoso canto me ha tocado interpretar...</p></div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e17 maol-r maol-s"></div></div></div><div class="x-row e13845-e18 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-a maol-c maol-g maol-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e19 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><span class="x-image e13845-e20 maol-1b"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/que-pasa-image-839x1024.jpg" width="415" height="506" alt="Que Pasa" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e21 maol-v maol-y maol-z maol-10 maol-13 maol-16 maol-17 image-caption">?QUE PASA with LA RAZA, eh?<br>
Image credit: Alex Waterhouse-Hayward.</div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e22 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e23 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14"><p>I grew up with all these words. They have deep roots within me. They are part of my DNA. Wherever I go, whatever space I enter, these words carry me, I bring them with me, like I do my ancestors.</p>
<p>These words do not represent hypotheses to me. They are not abstract or theoretical in any way. They describe a struggle, a life, a people, a shared history, a goal, a way of life, a memory. They are written in blood, spoken in hushed tones, sung from the rooftops, chanted arm in arm, waving banners, tears streaming, voices hoarse. They are forbidden words, banned, censored, and blacklisted. Often laughed at, ridiculed, dismissed. They are words that once spoken change the particles in the air. They are electric. A call to arms.</p>
<p>There are few things in life that I would stand behind as absolute truths. Almost none, really. As a wordsmith who has spent thirty-one years at the service of language and its power to define, describe, challenge, invite, recount, remember, name, pulverize, and recruit, I can say with certainty that language is a powerful tool. I can say that that statement is an absolute truth.</p>
<p>Solidaridad.</p>
<p>What does solidarity look like in our cultural community? It looks like building coalitions. El pueblo unido jamas sera vencido. Coming together is much harder than separatism based on reductive and essentialist notions of identity. A sweeping vision that embraces all members of our workplace cannot and should not be easy to accomplish. Conflict should not be seen as a deterrent, but rather as a sign that we are getting somewhere.</p>
<p>Revolucion.</p>
<p>Art and activism for me cannot be disentangled. However, my goal is to create art that poses questions that I do not have the answers to, not to make definitive statements. Artistic and political risk lies in creating work that lives in the grey area and reaches towards a universal truth, not in asserting an absolute truth. So, the tension for me lies between putting my skill set at the service of a cause and a community and my commitment to my own artistic vision. The struggle for balance between the collective and the individual, when both hold equal weight for me. Struggle is a fertile ground for continued learning. Struggle is equal to change, which is the only constant in life, in society, and in our work. I have spent my life in the theatre fighting for the right of racialized people to bring our whole selves into all spaces: the theatre school, the workshop, the reading, the audition, the rehearsal hall, and, finally, the stage. The play itself. I have fought for us to be in the theatre without cutting off entire parts of who we are in order to survive there. In order to get work. I have fought in the face of often being the only racialized person in the room. In the face of being told that what I brought was not wanted, that my stories would limit audiences as opposed to expanding them because poor, racialized, migrant audiences do not count, that who I AM, with all my words and the meanings they carry, were to be left at the door. I have fought in the face of mostly not being able to get into the room because the door has remained shut.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e13845-e24 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-a maol-c maol-g maol-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e25 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><span class="x-image e13845-e26 maol-1b"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Dona-Flor-and-Her-Two-Husbands-2001.-The-Cast.-Photo-by-Tim-Matheson-3.jpg" width="600" height="881" alt="Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e27 maol-v maol-y maol-z maol-10 maol-13 maol-16 maol-17 image-caption"><p>Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands<br>
Photo credit: Tim Matheson.</p></div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e28 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e29 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14"><p>My vision for the theatre is about desegregating. I want a theatre where we all play together. A commons, not separatism. How do we achieve that? How do we achieve it in a way where racialized people, and all equity seeking communities, can bring our entire selves, with all our cultural codes, into the room?</p>
<p>Well, we change the room of course. We change the structures. We change the systems. I do not want to call this decolonizing our spaces because that word is not specific enough for me. I don’t know what it actually means, but to me it smacks a little bit of diversifying imperialism, of inclusion into capitalism, of recognition as opposed to redistribution. I would like to propose, though, that, if we are to use that word, decolonizing begins with the self. With decolonizing the mythologies of class, race, gender, that exist within each of us. Our own internalized classism, misogyny, racism, sexism, cisnormativity, heteronormativity, ablism, ageism, and so on. It’s an ongoing process. When we refer to decolonizing our spaces, I’d rather call it anti-colonialism, because that word has meaning to me.</p>
<p>Anti-colonial means anti-capitalist, anti-imperialist, and therefore anti-racist. What excites me? A theatre that tackles the tension between the dominant, colonial lens and structure and the marginalized cultures of resistance, with our own cosmologies and words. A true diversity of perspective and voices. A diversity that INTEGRATES the dominant culture, as opposed to banishing it. Yes, we overthrow the current system, ALONGSIDE the dominant culture, and, together, we create a new system. But how do we come together? And how do we do it so that we are stronger together, putting our collective skill sets and visions at the service of theatre?</p>
<p>We must all speak our truths, we must accept that we will not always get along, we must understand that generative conflict is not only necessary, but also welcome when we are working towards a common vision. And the vision I propose is a commons. And what our common looks like is for all of us to dream together. Dreaming as a strategy, not a fantasy. Right here. Right now. A commons as public space where public discourse takes place. We cannot be united without public discourse, which is not the same as agreement. Without public discourse, without a public space where we can disagree, there is no democracy. Public discourse as a public service to society, in pursuit of the public good. How do we get there, companeras and companeros?</p>
<p>That word. That word. With no translation into English, but which encapsulates friend, comrade, companion, colleague, collaborator, lover, confidante, sister, brother, fellow revolutionary.</p>
<p>I have always walked in two worlds, codeswitching linguistically and culturally. What is being asked, in fact demanded in our current historical conjuncture, is that those of the dominant culture start to learn to do the same, so that we can occupy the commons side by side, so that when someone like me walks into a rehearsal hall, I can bring all my worlds and words that describe them, so that I have agency, the way the dominant culture always has. So that our commons is not only diverse in identity, but also in perspective.</p>
<p>A commons where the sovereignty that does exist is sovereignty of thought.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e13845-e30 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-a maol-c maol-g maol-l"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e31 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><span class="x-image e13845-e32 maol-1b"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Dona-Flor-and-Her-Two-Husbands-2001.-Carmen-Aguirre-and-Ty-Olsson.-Photo-by-Tim-Matheson.jpg" width="600" height="914" alt="Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e33 maol-v maol-y maol-z maol-10 maol-13 maol-16 maol-17 image-caption"><p>Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands<br>
Photo credit: Tim Matheson.</p></div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e34 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e35 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14"><p>Currently what is being discussed in our theatre community is the opposite. What is desired is a diversity of identities.</p>
<p>Tellingly, social class rarely enters the discussion, because theatre in our country is of a fundamentally middle class and liberal sensibility. And identity politics is a middle-class politic that espouses self-identification. You can self-identify as pretty much anything, except class. Because social class is about class relations, a social relationship that exists independently of individual self-identification and self-segregation. In the neoliberal, middle-class identity politics of the theatre, I can self-identify as Latinx but not as middle class. I simply AM middle class. The point I was trying to make is that it is fashionable in our theatre world to be diverse in identity and spiritual cosmology but not in perspective and thought.</p>
<p>Decolonizing as a form of dismantling our own internalized mythologies could start with rejecting the mythology that if other people don’t think like me, they must be bad and therefore purged from the commons. I’d like to call the last few years in our theatre community the time of the great purge. A shameful time. A time to learn a great deal from. Because it has been a time of cruelty and psychological violence. The opposite of empathy and solidarity. I want to be part of a theatre community where there is a great range of thought, of perspectives, of political positions. If I am to argue with someone because I oppose their views or even find their views harmful, then I’d like the argument to state why I think that person is wrong, not why I think they’re evil. Arguing with someone about why I think they’re wrong requires reasoned discourse. It demands that I back up my argument. Arguing why I think they’re evil usually just requires me to talk about my hurt feelings, and to state that I feel triggered and unsafe and therefore need a segregated space where I won’t encounter any contrary views. It requires no actual content. The time of the great purge has been led by the notion that there is an absolute truth. And that that absolute truth is my opinion on any given subject. And usually, these absolute truths are tied to my identity. That, for example, as a Latinx woman of colour, I have the absolute truth on any number of things connected to my culture. And people who don’t adhere to my absolute truth need to be cancelled. Fired. Disposed of. Mobbed, publicly humiliated, shamed, and, essentially, sent to the far right. Because that’s what we’re risking. Sending those who don’t agree with us to the far right. Is this what we want?</p>
<p>The time of the great purge, led by the identarian left, has included the cancellation of a veteran queer theatre artist’s play reading which was to have taken place at the publicly-funded theatre he had co-founded and run for over a decade, at great personal cost. He faced credible death threats from the Christian right in the eighties and nineties for the programming of his seasons. He famously met his enemies in the theatre lobby in full drag. New generations of queer theatre artists stand on his shoulders. His crime was to write two provocative and controversial postings on his own blog page criticizing the title and content of a book written by a trans woman. This was not an isolated event, but part of a greater climate of fear, censorship, and self-censorship involving the privatization of tyranny. For this great purge is not being ordered or overseen by the state, but rather by members of our own community who engage in an impenetrable wall of elitist language games. We are all constantly being called upon to be accountable for our use or misuse of language by the purgers, who demand it from their victims. And yet, the purgers are accountable to nobody. They have no leader, mission statement, board, membership, constitution, or governing body. They have not been democratically elected by anybody nor have they participated in a revolution. Their defense for purging is usually around offended sensibilities and hurt feelings. None of the colleagues they have cancelled have ever come close to breaking Canadian hate speech laws, which begs the question: who in our community decides what is acceptable and unacceptable speech? When and by whom was it decided that there are good and bad people as opposed to good and bad ideas?</p>
<p>People are not static entities; they are capable of change. Until recently, when someone was accused by the community of holding hurtful and offensive views, you got rid of the offending view, not the person. In other words, your aim was systemic change, not individual persecution. You held the person to account and then reformed them through education. And even then, if they chose to keep their views, they still stayed in the community. If we believe that someone is seriously wrong, rational debate exposing the person to what we think are better ideas is helpful to the entire community, as opposed to just saying that person is evil and must be removed. Now don’t get me wrong, this kind discourse does still happen in other sectors, but all it takes is a handful of members of our community who hold unpopular views to be purged for the Great Purge to have the desired effect: fear. Self-censorship. The death of democracy and creativity. I do not consent to that. I do not consent.</p>
<p>And so, it is that I find myself in 2021, a year into the great plague, talking yet again about the great purge – yes, I’ve done this before – and about my absolute belief in freedom of speech.</p>
<p>Because I am a wordsmith. Because I believe in solidarity, revolution, and unity. And I believe in a greater vision, something we are striving towards, the commons. The commons includes everybody. Especially those I am in disagreement with.</p>
<p>This summer a co-Artistic Director of a respected independent Vancouver theatre company was purged because he posted a Jordan Peterson video on his own Facebook page and questioned the concept of white supremacy. A debate broke out on his page. That’s super healthy, as far as I’m concerned. And although I knew with a sinking feeling where this would all end – with him effectively cancelled from our community, which is, indeed, what happened – I wondered what it would look like if we were in a commons, a space for public discourse, not agreement.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e13845-e36 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-a maol-c maol-g maol-m"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e37 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><span class="x-image e13845-e38 maol-1b maol-1c"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/random-house-cover.jpg" width="1024" height="1574" alt="Something Fierce book cover" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e39 maol-v maol-y maol-z maol-10 maol-13 maol-16 maol-17 image-caption">Carmen Aguirre, <em>Something Fierce: Memoirs of a Revolutionary Daughter</em>.</div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e40 maol-s maol-t maol-u"><div class="x-text x-content e13845-e41 maol-v maol-w maol-z maol-10 maol-11 maol-13 maol-14"><p>And this is what I imagined: a respected member of our Vancouver theatre community, a person with no complaints of bullying or harassment against him, who has behaved professionally at work, feels safe enough to put forth a political view that is contrary to what most people in the community are publicly standing behind. He does it in the middle of a historical moment, in which systemic racism in our community is at the forefront of the discussion like never before. Seeing as this is all that is being discussed for weeks on end on social media, it makes sense that this person would jump into the discussion. But with an opposing view. One could argue it’s an offensive view, a disrespectful view, an insensitive view, a racist view, a very ill-timed view. But a view nonetheless.</p>
<p>In a commons, we would have it out, argue, debate, tell him why we think he’s wrong, which did happen. He would argue back, tell us why he holds the position that he holds, and, if we can’t convince him of our views and he can’t convince us of his, we now know where everyone stands, including him, and we keep him in the community. And he doesn’t have to leave or be purged because he knows and we know that although we disagree with each other, we can still work together. Because he’s a good person to work with. And friends and colleagues who may want to defend him can do so without fear of they too being cancelled. Because his views may be opposed to mine, but, as long as he’s not actually treating people badly in the workplace through bullying and harassment and assault, and as long as he’s not engaging in hate speech or organizing a white supremacist death squad, he’s allowed to stay.</p>
<p>Why do we expect everybody in our theatre to have the same ideology? When we work at a factory or at a restaurant, do we expect our co-workers to have the same political views as ours? The theatre is, at the end of the day, not a social movement but a workplace. If we want uniformity of thought in our theatre world, as opposed to sovereignty of thought, we have no right to claim that we strive to be inclusive and diverse. We have no right to be making art. As an aside, this man took the Jordan Peterson video down and asked for the community to educate him. He was eventually accused of extracting free emotional labour.</p>
<p>Language is a powerful tool. I can say that with absolute certainty. What does it mean to cancel someone? Where do the cancelled go? What does it mean to cancel a life? What does it mean to erase years of good work? How do we work in a community where many wonder if they will be next? How can we call this a free and healthy workplace?</p>
<p>What is revolutionary is keeping all members of our community in. So that we are strengthening as opposed to purging. So that we are growing. So that we are learning how to argue, how to accept others as they are, how to work with those whose views we do not hold. So that we are not sending people to the far right.</p>
<p>La historia es nuestra y la hacen los pueblos. History is ours and it is made by the people. Salvador Allende spoke those words on the day he died defending Chile from a far-right coup. What followed was fascism. Books were burned. Murals were covered with black paint. Leftist artists were imprisoned, tortured, murdered, disappeared, exiled. I heard his speech as he was giving it, as bombs were dropping around him. His words live within me. I made a vow to always follow them.</p>
<p>La historia es nuestra y la hacen los pueblos.</p>
<p>I do not consent to being part of an arts community that engages in witch hunts of people who don’t think like me. I want the time that follows the great plague and the great purge to look like this: we keep people in, we educate people who we believe have views that are wrong and hurtful, we are okay working with people whose views we oppose. We accept and welcome productive conflict. We are radically democratic and free. Some are of course already doing that. I invite us all to follow their lead.</p>
<p>How do we come together? History is ours and it is made by us. So, we decide. Together, companeras, companero, que hermoso canto me ha tocado interpretar, que clara aurora cada dia veo brillar… a ti, a mi, a nosotros…</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e13845-e42 maol-0 maol-4"><div class="x-row e13845-e43 maol-5 maol-6 maol-7 maol-8 maol-b maol-d maol-n"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e44 maol-r maol-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-13850 e13845-e45"><div class="x-section e13850-e1 maoq-0"><div class="x-row e13850-e2 maoq-1 maoq-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13850-e3 maoq-3 maoq-4"><a class="x-image e13850-e4 maoq-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/carmen-aguirre/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/carmen-aguirre-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Carmen Aguirre" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e13850-e5 maoq-3 maoq-5"><div class="x-text x-content e13850-e6 maoq-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Carmen Aguirre</strong>  is a Chilean-Canadian, award-winning theatre artist and author who has written and co-written over twenty-five plays.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e13850-e7 maoq-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/carmen-aguirre/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e13845-e46 maol-r maol-s"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e13845-e47 maol-0 maol-4"><div class="x-row e13845-e48 maol-5 maol-7 maol-8 maol-9 maol-b maol-e maol-o maol-p"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e49 maol-r maol-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e13845-e50"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e13845-e51 maol-0 maol-4"><div class="x-row e13845-e52 maol-5 maol-7 maol-9 maol-b maol-e maol-f maol-o maol-q"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e13845-e53 maol-r maol-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e13845-e54"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/solidaridad/">Solidaridad</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Archival Bricolage</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/archival-bricolage/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=archival-bricolage</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 23 Oct 2020 05:21:53 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/archival-bricolage/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 7, No. 4 / ConversationsArchival BricolageMadhur Anand reflects on This Red Line Goes Straight to Your HeartSimranpreet Anand in e-conversation with Madhur AnandSimranpreet Anand: I want to begin by asking you about the partition. In your book you use the partition as a starting point (depending on how you begin reading the book), as a metaphor, and as a ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archival-bricolage/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archival-bricolage/">Archival Bricolage</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e9521-e1 m7ch-0 m7ch-1 m7ch-2"><div class="x-row e9521-e2 m7ch-5 m7ch-6 m7ch-7 m7ch-8 m7ch-9 m7ch-a m7ch-e m7ch-f"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e9521-e3 m7ch-k m7ch-l"><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e4 m7ch-o m7ch-p m7ch-q m7ch-r m7ch-s issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-7-number-4/">Vol. 7, No. 4</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e9521-e5 m7ch-z main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Archival Bricolage</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">Madhur Anand reflects on <em>This Red Line Goes Straight to Your Heart</em></span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e6 m7ch-o m7ch-p m7ch-t m7ch-u m7ch-v">Simranpreet Anand in e-conversation with Madhur Anand</div></div><div class="x-col e9521-e7 m7ch-l m7ch-m"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e9521-e8 m7ch-0 m7ch-2 m7ch-3"><div class="x-row e9521-e9 m7ch-5 m7ch-6 m7ch-7 m7ch-8 m7ch-b m7ch-g"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e9521-e10 m7ch-k m7ch-l m7ch-n"><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e11 m7ch-o m7ch-p m7ch-s m7ch-t m7ch-u m7ch-w m7ch-x"><p><strong>Simranpreet Anand:</strong> I want to begin by asking you about the partition. In your book you use the partition as a starting point (depending on how you begin reading the book), as a metaphor, and as a structure for the narrative. How did you decide on the documents that mark the partition within the book?</p>
<p><strong>Madhur Anand:</strong> The partition of India in 1947 is a starting point, but there are many directions the book takes and while the roads travelled are quite far in space and time (across several continents and across many decades) and disciplines (science, poetry, history), and personal transformations, there are no end points. I decided to add some copies of real documents because these documents supported my writing of the book as points of reference at least. My parents are not the kind of people who took or even kept a lot of photos or had things written about them. They had fairly simple, quiet lives from that point of view. I think I have only a handful of photos from their early lives in Canada and almost none from their lives in India, and zero from their lives as children or their birthplaces in pre-Partition Punjab. My parents did not even have birth certificates. Some of these are documents that confirm my parents’ training, education, and work experience. These documents are proof of identity for immigrants to new countries, and these pieces of paper are carried around in their original forever, because an immigrant’s identity is always under question.</p>
<p>But the word “document” itself is interesting. It comes from the Latin word "<em>docere</em>" which means "to teach." I felt these documents could also elicit emotions because of the way they look now. Some of them contain errors in my parents’ names or genders. Some of them are entirely in Hindi and I cannot even read them fully, but I still consider them proof of something. This is what it feels like to translate stories across language and across generations, there is always a loss. But I hope my book is now also a new kind of document. So, I sought to overcome that loss.</p>
<p>One of the documents has a large ink spill on it which happened one day when my mother went to get it copied. The clerk spilled the ink on it and my mother feared that would invalidate the document. The ink spill has the shape of some kind of new island or country showing up on an unchartered map. It could also be the shape of a blood stain. So, every document contains many backstories and so they can become objects of beauty and portals to other worlds themselves in that regard.</p>
<p>Now, because the book is in two parts, one telling my parent’s stories, and one telling some of mine, I wanted to add some documents from my life as well. But for me it was not as important to add things like my PhD degree etc., because I have less to prove on that side of things now that I’ve been a professor for 20 years, and also I am not a first-generation immigrant. But looking back, I saved many documents from my former life, when my identity was still undetermined, documents that could in retrospect be mined perhaps for evidence of my destiny (as my mother might say) to become a writer: one is my report card from Grade 1 which claims that is when I was ‘beginning to spell words for myself’ or that I ‘write interesting stories’ and one is some kind of writing exercise I did in Grade 6 in which I learn the definition of "metaphor." I don’t remember those lessons, but metaphor is a big part of my writing life now.</p>
<p><strong>SA:</strong> I am really interested in the process of interviewing your parents for the book. You’ve recorded their oral histories and published them in a textual form. Can you tell us more about your choice of medium?</p>
<p><strong>MA:</strong> Only that I am a writer, and so it came very naturally to me to want to record their stories through text. The challenge was to find a way to translate their oral histories (even when they were sometimes being told in English!) to another literary form, creative non-fiction. This ‘translation’ also allowed me to insert my perspective, because I wanted to somehow gift the stories with even more poetry and science, with everything that I had gained in the second generation, an idea that I think they certain felt was the case, that their children enriched their lives. I used an experimental and fragmented approach partly because that is how I often feel (as a poet and a scientist and a mother and a wife etc.) but also to honour the various ruptures of their own oral telling—that process and its shape and texture, the different languages, accents, tones, emotions —like one might imagine what painting the stories might do.</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e9521-e12 m7ch-10 rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr>
<p>I used an experimental and fragmented approach partly because that is how I often feel (as a poet and a scientist and a mother and a wife etc.) but also to honour the various ruptures of their own oral telling</p>
<hr></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e13 m7ch-o m7ch-p m7ch-t m7ch-u m7ch-v"><p><strong>SA:</strong> Throughout the book you weave in poems, quotes, mentions of songs, tweets, things you stumbled upon. You also write about your work as a scientist, the research you work on, and the people you encounter. Do you feel there is a relationship between the non-linear presentation of your own narrative and the archival bricolage from which you would have constructed your parents’ narrative?</p>
<p><strong>MA:</strong> This is such an astute observation. I think we are always challenged by the discreteness of time and space and memory when we try to tell stories or create narratives. One thing is to just acknowledge that discreteness which can indeed make things discontinuous and nonlinear, but also can also leave room for those cracks, for imagination, and even for greater understanding. The juxtaposition of different narratives and different pathways of knowledge and emotion can also be strangely illuminating. It’s funny now to write that word “discrete” and realize that it shouldn’t be confused with “discreet.” The reality is, all our lives are fractured by multiple identities and histories, and I think it’s useful to explore that idea in the form of fractured and asymmetrical texts.</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e9521-e14 m7ch-10 rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr>
<p>The juxtaposition of different narratives and different pathways of knowledge and emotion can also be strangely illuminating.</p>
<hr></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e15 m7ch-o m7ch-p m7ch-s m7ch-t m7ch-u m7ch-w m7ch-x"><p><strong>SA:</strong> When writing your parents’ narrative, you contextualize the space and time with happenings around the world in science and culture. What was the process of learning those pieces of information like, how did you decide on what to include?</p>
<p><strong>MA:</strong> Some of the pieces of information, like for example the quote from Darwin’s On the Origin of Species, or from restoration ecology textbooks, or even from my own PhD thesis <em>Towards a Theory of Vegetation Dynamics</em>, were already in my head somewhere, and I just recalled them, at least the reference to them, in certain contexts. But for others, I really did explore the world of physics, both in the disciplines that examine symmetry-breaking and in the history of the development of theoretical physics. I learned a lot writing this book. I read many books and the contextualization came very naturally, and coincidentally. There were many instances when I would be thinking something about my parents’ histories and then finding some exact reference in a textbook or even in a novel I decided to read (often because I suspected it would inform the work) that spoke to it directly. I also actively sought out Indian writers from the places and times of my parents’ youth (Bedi, Manto, Bond, Mehrotra), because I knew I would find in poems and novels that which was missing from history and science textbooks. In my scientific research, I work in many disciplines and with complex systems theory, and I think a certain kind of interdisciplinary thinking can help identify these connections and universalities among what might seem to be disparate things.</p>
<p><strong>SA:</strong> When reading your work something that really struck me was the openness and detail with which you’ve told your family narratives. There are multiple instances in your personal narrative where we you note that you are choosing what to tell and what to hold back.</p>
<p>As an artist, I’ve debated how much of myself to share or filter in my work. I resonated with how you write about your interview with your mother. At one point in the book, you ask yourself a series of YES/NO questions, flipping a coin to decide if you should care about what your family thinks, if you should write about domestic violence, and if you should write about eating disorders. How do you feel about these questions now that the book is published?</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e9521-e16 m7ch-10 rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr>
<p>I think when we accept that at some point all our stories are just one collective story of humanity, we become less sensitive to the fact that they are personal or secret.</p>
<hr></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e17 m7ch-o m7ch-p m7ch-s m7ch-t m7ch-u m7ch-w m7ch-x"><strong>MA:</strong> At this point, I think I made the right choices about what to tell and not tell. The YES/NO thing was from a very small part of a 3-hour workshop I took with the writer Sheila Heti in 2018. It was just an experiment, but it seemed to be useful. This idea of what to tell/not tell for me amounted more to the question of <em>how</em> to tell these stories, which took a lot longer to figure out. Once I figured that out though, it became clearer what would inform the overall project and what wouldn’t. We actually ended up cutting several thousand words and entire stories from the book in the end. On the other hand, there are entire parts of my life I haven’t yet written a single word about which involve very significant things both personally and professionally. I just think those stories would have detracted from the first impulse of this book, which was to write my parents’ stories from my perspective as an established poet and scientist. It’s not that I actively filter myself when writing, I don’t feel I do, but maybe at some point one needs someone else (children? friends? strangers?) to write some of one’s own stories. Maybe they are already being written by other writers, maybe even in fictional form. It is often sufficient to find ourselves in stories written by others. I certainly hope many will find something of themselves in my book. I think when we accept that at some point all our stories are just one collective story of humanity, we become less sensitive to the fact that they are personal or secret. Maybe not all our stories need to be put into books, some can just remain in the ether, as all stories, both told and untold, ultimately have an effect on us collectively. Every writer needs to figure out where that point lies for themselves.</div></div><div class="x-col e9521-e18 m7ch-k m7ch-l m7ch-n"><span class="x-image e9521-e19 m7ch-11"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/this-red-line-goes-straight-to-your-heart-book-cover.jpg" width="300" height="450" alt="Book Cover of This Read Line Goes Straight To Your Heart" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e9521-e20 m7ch-o m7ch-r m7ch-s m7ch-t m7ch-w m7ch-y image-caption"><p><em>This Red Line Goes Straight to Your Heart: A Memoir in Halves</em><br />
Penguin Random House Canada (2020)</p></div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Archival+Bricolage', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Archival+Bricolage&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Archival+Bricolage&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/archival-bricolage/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e9521-e22 m7ch-0 m7ch-4"><div class="x-row e9521-e23 m7ch-5 m7ch-6 m7ch-7 m7ch-a m7ch-c m7ch-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e9521-e24 m7ch-k m7ch-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11862 e9521-e25"><div class="x-section e11862-e1 m95i-0"><div class="x-row e11862-e2 m95i-1 m95i-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11862-e3 m95i-3 m95i-4"><a class="x-image e11862-e4 m95i-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/simranpreet-anand/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/simranpreet-anand-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Simranpreet Anand" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11862-e5 m95i-3 m95i-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11862-e6 m95i-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Simranpreet Anand</strong> is an interdisciplinary artist and is committed to a community engaged practice. She is currently working as an Engagement Facilitator at the Surrey Art Gallery and Curatorial Assistant at Western Front.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11862-e7 m95i-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/simranpreet-anand/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11040 e9521-e26"><div class="x-section e11040-e1 m8io-0"><div class="x-row e11040-e2 m8io-1 m8io-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11040-e3 m8io-3 m8io-4"><a class="x-image e11040-e4 m8io-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/madhur-anand/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/madhur-anand-bio-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Madhur Anand" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11040-e5 m8io-3 m8io-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11040-e6 m8io-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Madhur Anand</strong> is a full professor of Ecology and Sustainability Science at the University of Guelph. Her award-winning prose has appeared in a number of magazines including <em>The Puritan</em>, <em>Brick</em>, and <em>The New Quarterly</em>.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11040-e7 m8io-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/madhur-anand/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e9521-e27 m7ch-k m7ch-l"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e9521-e28 m7ch-0 m7ch-4"><div class="x-row e9521-e29 m7ch-5 m7ch-7 m7ch-8 m7ch-9 m7ch-a m7ch-e m7ch-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e9521-e30 m7ch-k m7ch-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e9521-e31"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e9521-e32 m7ch-0 m7ch-4"><div class="x-row e9521-e33 m7ch-5 m7ch-8 m7ch-9 m7ch-a m7ch-d m7ch-e m7ch-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e9521-e34 m7ch-k m7ch-l"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e9521-e35"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archival-bricolage/">Archival Bricolage</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Shifting Genres, Shifting Lands</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/shifting-genres-shifting-lands/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=shifting-genres-shifting-lands</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 21 Mar 2020 01:09:39 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=6685</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 7, No. 1 / ConversationsShifting Genres, Shifting LandsA conversation with Anosh&#160;IraniBy Anosh Irani and Zool SulemanAnosh Irani Image Credit: Nimal&#160;Shah.Share ArticleSeptember 2018, Vancouver, BCWith Editorial Assistance by Rusaba Alam.Zool Suleman: It's a pleasure to finally meet with you and interview you for Rungh. What are some of the projects you're up to?Forms, Adaptations, and MentorsAnosh Irani: So, I write ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/shifting-genres-shifting-lands/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/shifting-genres-shifting-lands/">Shifting Genres, Shifting Lands</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e6685-e1 m55p-0 m55p-1 m55p-2"><div class="x-row e6685-e2 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-7 m55p-8 m55p-9 m55p-a m55p-b m55p-g m55p-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e3 m55p-r m55p-s"><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e4 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-x m55p-y m55p-z issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-7-number-1/">Vol. 7, No. 1</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6685-e5 m55p-19 m55p-1a"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Shifting Genres, Shifting Lands</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">A conversation with Anosh&nbsp;Irani</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e6 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-12">By Anosh Irani and Zool Suleman</div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e7 m55p-s m55p-t"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6685-e8 m55p-0 m55p-2 m55p-3"><div class="x-row e6685-e9 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-8 m55p-a m55p-b m55p-c m55p-g m55p-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e10 m55p-r m55p-s"><span class="x-image e6685-e11 m55p-1c"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/anosh-irani-author-picture3.jpg" width="450" height="300" alt="Image" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e12 m55p-v m55p-y m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-13 m55p-14 m55p-15 image-caption">Anosh Irani Image Credit: Nimal&nbsp;Shah.</div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Shifting+Genres%2C+Shifting+Lands', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Shifting+Genres%2C+Shifting+Lands&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Shifting+Genres%2C+Shifting+Lands&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/shifting-genres-shifting-lands/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e14 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e15 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16">September 2018, Vancouver, BC</div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e16 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16">With Editorial Assistance by <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/rusaba-alam/">Rusaba Alam</a>.</div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e17 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><strong>Zool Suleman:</strong> It's a pleasure to finally meet with you and interview you for Rungh. What are some of the projects you're up to?</div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6685-e18 m55p-19 m55p-1b"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Forms, Adaptations, and Mentors</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e19 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>Anosh Irani:</strong> So, I write plays, I write fiction, and I've just finished an adaptation of my novel, <em>The Parcel</em>, for the screen.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> So, it's – I've been doing a lot, sort of immersing myself in different forms, but it's mainly between theater, fiction, and screenwriting.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> I noticed in the work that you do, there are clearly two genre shifts that happened: you're involved in the novel form and the theater form. Tell me a bit about how you approach your theatre work and how that differs from how you approach your novel writing.</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e6685-e20 m55p-1d rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr>
<p>I think that the story comes with a particular form. So I instantly know in its original state, whether it's &ndash; whether it's a novel, whether it's a short story, or whether it's a play</p>
<hr></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e21 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>AI:</strong> I think that the story comes with a particular form. So I instantly know in its original state, whether it's – whether it's a novel, whether it's a short story, or whether it's a play. So for example, my first novel, [<em>The Cripple and his Talismans</em>], that came to me as a single image, the image of this very dark, claustrophobic, underground sort of dungeon-esque place, and they would have amputated limbs hanging from the ceiling, and they were in alphabetical order. Named according to the people from whom they were taken. And that image sort of stayed with me and refused to leave, which is really a gift for a writer when that happens, but I knew instantly that that was fiction, that was a novel, it wasn’t a scene from a movie, and it wasn’t a play.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> And what is it about? How do you know that? Is it just an instinctual thing?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> It's completely instinctual. Let's say that it's theater, I almost see them on stage, and I detect the presence of an audience very quickly. If it's fiction, there is no reader, there is no audience.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> When you adapt <em>The Parcel</em>, you're trying to turn it into a screenplay, what kind of process do you go through. If you’d envisioned it as a novel, and now you must turn it into something that can work as a film script?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> You go back to the original character. So I don't think of it as an adaptation. For me, I had stayed with this story for almost over a decade. So I knew the characters really well, and I just went back to what the character wants, to what the character feels, what the character’s trying to achieve, and I started the screenplay from the ground up, rather than looking at transferring what I had created as a novelist to something that was more catered to film. And it helped, because there were things that I had not discovered or explored enough in the novel that I ended up discovering in the screenplay. Now, I know that a lot of novelists feel that when I do an adaptation, that I lose quite a bit. I didn't feel that way. In fact, I gained as well, precisely because of what I just said, that there were things that I could not explore or did not explore in the novel, or I didn't realize somehow when it came to film these things reveal themselves.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> When you're writing a play, do you have a sense of the audience and its reaction to it? Is that something you take into account?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Not initially. So, when I'm creating the first draft, when the idea is just sort of forming itself, I never think of the audience. I almost write a couple of draft of the play, and then I think about an audience when it comes to theater. When I write novels, I almost never think of the reader at all.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> For [<em>Bombay Black</em>], which has had several remounts, and in several locations, and has had different kinds of casting in terms of the male and female casting, tell me a bit about how audiences have received the play in the different locales.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> So one of the things that happened is when we did [<em>Bombay Black</em>] in India, in both Bombay and Delhi, the play was translated. We did not do an English production it was translated from English into Hindi. And what was incredible was when I heard it in a different language. Now, mind you, when I write dialogue, a lot of the dialogue I hear in Hindi.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Yes. Particularly in [<em>Bombay Black</em>], the relationship between the mother and the daughter, the kind of whip-snap dialogue between the two of them, I heard it in Hindi and I could tell the intonation you were getting at. So, was that more liberating when you did it in Hindi? Did those meanings come through more clearly?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> I don't think it's more liberating. I think what it did for me was– it helped me hear the play again, and I made a major change after the English production. So, in the premiere production in Toronto, Absera, who was the dancer, she goes blind as well, and when I ran to India to reopen the play with the same script, on opening night, I sort of just asked myself well, what if she doesn't go blind? And there was no need for me to make changes because the play had received a fantastic review, but it wasn't about that. It was just about hearing the play again in a different way, and it simplified things for me. And so, in the Indian production, even though we opened it, a couple of weeks later when we did it again, I had a new script, and I stayed with it. And so that was a huge change, but it happened only because I heard the play in Hindi. I don't think it would have happened if it had just been produced in English one more time. So, that was an unusual sort of discovery for me.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Does that happen with your other theater work, that a major shift happens on a future remount of the production?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> I think a production will always give you an insight, because that's what I'm hoping it does. Now you have to be open as a writer, if you're afraid to make changes. And the change doesn't necessarily mean that the premiere production wasn't good. Theater is a living, breathing thing, and it continues to change shape. And, again, with [<em>The Men in White</em>], which is my latest play, which was being premiered at the Arts Club, I think last year, now it's being done at the Factory Theater in Toronto in October. One of the changes I made was, there was one character, and I realized that he is not required in the play. It didn't weaken the original production, at all, but I think it's just made this script even stronger. And that's not something you realize until you see it again, and again, and again on stage. Not just during workshops, but as an actual production. Somehow the audience being there, somehow your being there – and it's not about listening to the audience, it's a broad alignment. I think it’s one of those things where everything has to be in alignment: the performances, the writing, the sound, the sets, the lighting, all of that. And once that happens, anything that's out of place can easily be detected.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> In terms of you being open as a playwright, and being open to different sorts of responses…, what is the role of reviews and criticism for your work in the playwriting arena?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> I think the writer must sort of remain outside of reviews and criticism. It's not something I look at when I'm trying to write another play, it's not something I'd really listen to. Now, having said that, I appreciate a sort of deep exploration of the work. The fact that people are exploring my work, I think that's a huge compliment. Whether it's in – let's say, it's an academic essay on my novel, or it's a really well written, thoughtful review, or as you say it's an essay about a play like [<em>Bombay Black</em>], or my other work, and how it fits into a certain type of theater, whether it doesn't. I enjoyed reading that, because it puts things into context in a thoughtful, intelligent way, and I think that's extremely valuable. But I don't really go looking for suggestions based on what other people write. I think a writer has inner voice, and you know when you've created something, and you've put it out there into the world, whether it rings true or not. And that element of truthfulness is what I keep going for.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> So then, as a playwright, what is your set of markers for what we call "success"? If audience is not what drives you, what is it that drives you around the work?</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e6685-e22 m55p-1d rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr>
<p>But what I'm really looking for is, am I doing something new? Am I creating a dent in consciousness? By putting this story out there, by putting this play out there in the world, how am I causing a shift?</p>
<hr></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e23 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>AI:</strong> I'm not saying that reviews don't matter. I think they do matter because they make a dent in the box office. And I have to be honest and say that I do get affected by reviews. I wouldn’t say that if I get a bad review, that I'm sort of impervious to it. No, it does affect you. And an audience responds when you get a standing ovation on opening night, that's fantastic too. It's, of course, it's what I live for, in the sense of when I'm writing plays. But what I'm really looking for is, am I doing something new? Am I creating a dent in consciousness? By putting this story out there, by putting this play out there in the world, how am I causing a shift? And it can be in a very subtle way, sometimes if it's this dark humor in your work, just that change of perspective of having the ability to make an audience laugh at something that might be a bit taboo. That itself, in a way it can be healing, it can also be political, it can be subversive. So those are the things I'm looking for. Of course, I love the feeling when a play is sold out, absolutely. Do I want commercial success? Of course. Is that my sole reason for creating? Not at all. Because nobody really knows what's going to work. It's not possible to tell. What I really aim for is what I said earlier: is this moving, is it truthful? Is it powerful? Am I doing something – if I'm spending two or three years working on a play, it has to be worth my time, as a human being, not as a businessman.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Do you find that audiences that are more South Asian in orientation, or who come from the kinds of locations that you're writing about, have a broader or deeper understanding of your work than say audiences that are born here or not South Asian, more mainstream audiences, do you see any kind of differentiation in the audience in terms of the receptivity of your work?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Not necessarily. I’ll give you an example: a lot of the people that I've worked with, whether it's – I've worked with three outstanding dramaturges in my time as a playwright so far. One is Rachel Ditor [dramaturg at Arts Club Theatre]. Also, Brian Quirt [Artistic Director, NIghtswimming Theatre] who helped me sort of create [<em>Bombay Black</em>], he commissioned for Nightswimming, and Iris Tucker who was very close, too, she passed away last year - none of these people has been to India. And yet, they had an incredible understanding of my work, in the sense that they knew exactly what I was trying to do. In some cases, they helped me get there. And that's what a really good dramaturge does. For example, if you're talking about a director or someone like Peter Hinton, I don't think he's ever been to India, but the way he took [<em>Bombay Black</em>] and sort of put a spin on it by casting a man in the role of a woman, you know, that was incredibly satisfying to see, a completely different kind of production.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e6685-e24 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-8 m55p-a m55p-b m55p-c m55p-g m55p-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e25 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><span class="x-image e6685-e26 m55p-1c"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/anosh-irani-photo-4.jpg" width="450" height="300" alt="Image" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e27 m55p-v m55p-y m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-13 m55p-14 m55p-15 image-caption">The Men in White (2017), Arts Club Theatre Image Credit: Emily&nbsp;Cooper.</div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e28 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e29 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p>So, you're really looking at a level of sophistication in the audience, and they can be South Asian, they might not have ever been to India, it doesn't matter. Yes, in some cases, let's say, I'm writing about Bombay, the detailing, they might recognize it. So, they might recognize a joke or a reference that someone else might not recognize, or they might understand the reality of the place that you are writing about. Sometimes an actor might not understand a very small move or very small shift by a character in a very dangerous locality. So, for example, if it's [<em>The Men in White</em>], there's only one woman in the entire cast, the character of Haseena. She lives in Dongri, which is a predominantly Muslim neighborhood. It can be also quite conservative and strict in that sense when it comes to a sort of interaction with men. And, so for her to make even a very small advance towards a man is a huge thing, but someone who doesn't know that might not understand the significance of that small movement. So, in that sense, yes, it does matter when they have &ndash;</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> So when you're workshopping a play or you're preparing a production, do you find yourself sort of culturally coding and decoding things for people?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> At times, yes, and good directors and good dramaturges will always be open and they will ask the playwright, so what does this mean, why is she doing that, or why is she saying that, or why is someone not being offended when that happens? So, in that sense, you sort of present the reality to them. And then it must make theatrical sense, right? Everything must make sense on stage, I mean, there's a reality that happens in a city like Bombay, but then there is a presentation of that reality on a stage. And it has to ring true on stage, it doesn't matter if it happened or didn't happen in real life, facts are very different from truth. And like I said, you're going for truth on stage or on the page.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> You've now been writing plays for quite a while. What have you noticed over the timeframe in which you've been doing this work in terms of how your work is presented, how the audiences are reacting? Are you noticing any change or trajectory in the kind of work that you're doing? Some of it, clearly, is you're more recognizable as a playwright, and so people will go because it's your production, or your script. But are you noticing any general trends around work that, for lack of a better term, we'll call South Asian located or based, over the last decade or so? Are you noticing any shifts in the production and presentation of this work?</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e6685-e30 m55p-1d rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr />
<p>I've never really considered myself from an identity point of view, because I guess it's so embedded within me that I don't need to think about it.</p>
<hr /></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e31 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><strong>AI:</strong> I think that there is a shift in the sense that when I first wrote [<em>The Matka King</em>], which was my first play, and this was way back in 2001, Bill Millerd, who was the artistic director of the Arts Club Theatre, read the play. He took a huge risk by saying, okay, I'd like to program this, because there were hardly any South Asian playwrights –there was Rahul Varma – there was no record of South Asian plays in Canada in that sense, apart from Rahul’s work. And plus, my play was set in a brothel, it wasn't your living room reality play. This was set in a brothel, you had a transgender person as the main character, you had a cage and there was a 10-year-old girl in that cage. He obviously saw the strength in the writing, which enabled him to program it, and take the risk. What I'm seeing is that more artistic directors are taking those risks with South Asian content, with South Asian playwrights. So, but it's taking time, and it also has to do with the quality of the writing as well, so there might be a desire to do South Asian work, but again, I don’t like being termed as only a "South Asian" playwright, because I find it very limiting. I've never really considered myself from an identity point of view, because I guess it's so embedded within me that I don't need to think about it. What I'm interested in doing is creating work that is sort of very specific in the sense that it's set in India, and now some of it in Canada as well, but through my lens, through my perspective. But stories that resonate with every audience that are universal. So, I think things are shifting, but it's still slow.</div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6685-e32 m55p-19 m55p-1b"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Taking Risks</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e33 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><strong>ZS:</strong> You used the word earlier on, risks, the risks the producers are taking, theater companies are taking, directors are taking. Tell me a bit more about what you think those risks are.</div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e34 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>AI:</strong> The risk is that, if I do a play, that's thankfully not about one more wedding in India, you know? Or let's take the Arts Club and what they did with [<em>The Matka King</em>], there was no reference point for the audience. They had not seen anything like this. They were wondering, is this true, is this magic realism, does that mean it is fantasy? And magic realism is very different from fantasy. So in a way, you're trying to not educate the audience, but you're trying not to displace them so much that they aren’t invested in the work anymore. And plus, Bill Millerd [former Artistic Managing Director of Arts Club Theatre Company], put it on the main stage, it wasn't in a small theater, it wasn’t a 400-seat theater, and it ran for a month. So, you're investing a lot of money in that, and you're sort of standing behind a writer, and you're standing behind work that did not have any previous track record. So, I admire that. And there are certain plays that I find are safe bets. They might have South Asian content, but they don't really push boundaries, they don't challenge anyone, there's no new perspective. It's a perspective that already exists that makes the audience feel comfortable. I'm not interested in writing those plays.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e6685-e35 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-8 m55p-a m55p-b m55p-c m55p-g m55p-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e36 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><span class="x-image e6685-e37 m55p-1c"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/anosh-irani-photo-5.jpg" width="400" height="560" alt="The Matka King, Arts Club Theatre (2003) Image Credit: David Cooper Photography." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e38 m55p-v m55p-y m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-13 m55p-15 m55p-17 image-caption">The Matka King, Arts Club Theatre (2003) Image Credit: David Cooper&nbsp;Photography.</div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e39 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e40 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> In a play like [<em>Bombay Black</em>], what I found interesting in terms of the relationship to the audience, it's a story that takes place in a city and harks back to a village life. Also, of course, it is very sensory, because one of the main characters is blind. So, it's a play that's about fragrance, and it's a play a that's about sound, when you have a dancer involved. It's a play that's about light and dark. But what I found intriguing between all those kinds of crosscurrents is the role of myth. You named the dancer Apsara, and the blind man is named Kamal. And as becomes apparent through the play, Kamal is a mythical lotus name and Apsara is a water-figure. There is this deep mythical connection between the water that nourishes the lotus, and how the lotus brings beauty on the surface of the water. This theme of beauty, reflection, nourishment, you can find it in all kinds of Indian mythology, poetry, classical dance. Tell me about the role of classical Indian motifs and mythology, particularly in this play and perhaps the other work you do?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Sure. So, I like the idea of beauty, and what you said about, poetry and how beauty is reflected through this mythology, and that's precisely why it's there, because in the present day, it's all ugliness, right? There's beauty and there's ugliness – I love the idea of how mythology can affect us in the present day. I don't like period pieces, because I don't find a connection to them.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> So you're not a big fan of historical drama?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> No. Not really, now, I mean, if it's in film, maybe I'll be interested in a mythical film show, but that's the movies. On stage, even something that is set many years ago can ring through in present day, but it has to have that resonance. With [<em>Bombay Black</em>] – there's all this beauty, but then there's this underbelly, this ugliness. And it's a love story, but it's really a revenge story. So, there’s two sides of the same coin, love and hate, love and revenge, love and then once you get through the range, you touch forgiveness. So all of these things I discovered, that's what I was using the mythology for, to make sense of all of these. And India is so mythological, it's so superstitious, even today. So, it's part of the reality. And the thing is that might make the place seem exotic, but it's not. Exotic is a word that people who might not understand that particular culture and will use what it. Is it exotic to someone else? Sure, and I'm okay if they see it through that lens, that's fine. That's their entry point. But once you get through that, you're touching a very ugly, hard reality, and that's what I wanted to do with [<em>Bombay Black</em>].</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> What's interesting about [<em>Bombay Black</em>] also is the way you deal with the urban fabric. Bombay is also a character in your play. There's a sense of the cityscape as being threatening, especially to a young woman, or to a blind man. There's a sense of privacy and no privacy. I noticed that in an interview you referred to [<em>Maximum City</em>], the book by –</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Right, Suketu Mehta. Yes.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Yes. And you speak quite rhapsodically about that book. And I agree with you, it's an amazing book. What is the role of that city, and your location coming out of that city, in your work? Do you have some kind of love relationship with Bombay, and is that still with you?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Absolutely. I think Bombay doesn't allow you to have a choice.</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e6685-e41 m55p-1d rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr />
<p>In a sense [Bombay} exerts a kind of pressure on you, the city itself exerts this tremendous pressure on you as a human being, and it shapes you. You can leave, but by then the damage has been done, I think.</p>
<hr /></div></div></blockquote></div></div></div><div class="x-row e6685-e42 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-8 m55p-a m55p-b m55p-c m55p-g m55p-l"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e43 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><span class="x-image e6685-e44 m55p-1c"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/anosh-irani-photo-3.jpg" width="217" height="300" alt="Image" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e45 m55p-v m55p-y m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-13 m55p-15 m55p-18 image-caption">Bombay Black (2006), Cahoots Theatre Image Credit: John&nbsp;Lauener.</div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e46 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e47 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> What do you mean by that?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> In a sense [Bombay] exerts a kind of pressure on you, the city itself exerts this tremendous pressure on you as a human being, and it shapes you. You can leave, but by then the damage has been done, I think.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> So in that sense, you’re an expatriate who has been damaged but also perhaps healed by the city?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Yes. I don't know if it's healed me in any way, but it's given me a lot of perspective, and for that I'm grateful. I don't think it's healing, but it's definitely helped me sort of realize things; it's also given me my stories. I don't think I would have been a writer. Who knows? But I'm definitely a writer because of Bombay, for sure.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6685-e48 m55p-19 m55p-1b"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Home as Mythical Space</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e49 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> You speak about how when you came to Canada, you'd set these goals for yourself, that you wanted to be published before you went back. But also that you had not read a great deal before you came here. So, tell us about the education of Anosh Irani., How do you traverse through the canon to come up with the stuff that starts to influence you?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Well, that was the fun part of my being here, in the sense that I did not really have anyone to tell me read Camus, he's a brilliant writer, or read Nabokov, or read Rohinton Mistry, although I had read Mistry when I was in India, so I absolutely loved his work. But there were certainly ones like Hampson and Charles Bukowski, or the plays of Tennessee Williams, or Arthur Miller, of course, now you look at them and say, well, obviously. But I had no one to tell me that. I would just go to a secondhand bookstore, when it came to novels, I would just read opening lines, you know, so one of my favorite novels is Camus’s [<em>The Stranger</em>]: "Mother died today, or maybe it was yesterday, I don't know." And when I read that, I thought that is incredible. Just the simplicity of the language, but such a terrifying displacing perspective, and I immediately bought that book. And, of course then, once you read it, you sort of stay within its power, and you let that work on you.</p>
<p>You know, I feel books– literature has this incredible ability to work on you long after you've read it. It is the same with watching a play or watching a movie that's really well made, it gets deep inside your DNA, and it sort of makes a change without you really knowing, which is why I love – that's the power of art. So, my education really was reading novels, it was when I worked at the Arts Club as an intern, I had Bill who sort of, you know, introduced me to a playwright named Morris Panych who was one of Canada’s – in my opinion – best playwrights. I love his work. At the same time I started reading [Eugene] Ionesco and Harold Pinter, Pinter’s one of my favorites. So, I just discovered these writers on my own without really, I mean, I had Bill to guide me in that sense when it came to theater, but not in a – in a very directional way, it just happened by accident. And something either resonated with me, it either made sense for me to read it, or I just didn't find it interesting at all.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> That’s a fascinating journey, because you've said previously that you thought your ideas come out of Bombay, but Vancouver, or Canada, is the canvas. Tell me more about that.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Just the space, I think, the ability to reflect, the distance, the fact that you can hear, it's so quiet that you can hear several voices in your head all at once, which is quite disturbing in the beginning, because in Bombay you can’t really hear yourself. You're just – you're going, going, going and it's a – it has a great push. Vancouver, you find stillness, but when you become still, there's all this – there's the past, there’s present, there’s the future, there's all this noise, these questions, these images, and as time went by things started settling down. And I was left with the images of Bombay, the stories that I wanted to tell I realized were already inside my body, I just hadn't realized that. And being still and being in Canada help me sort of understand, become more and more aware of what kinds of stories I wanted to tell as a writer. And, of course, this was in a very early stage, I was still adjusting to a new country, a new city, new continent, it was all very difficult and isolating, and yet I found a perspective.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e6685-e50 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-8 m55p-a m55p-b m55p-c m55p-g m55p-m"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e51 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><span class="x-image e6685-e52 m55p-1c"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/anosh-irani-author-picture3.jpg" width="450" height="300" alt="Anosh Irani Image Credit: Nimal Shah." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e53 m55p-v m55p-y m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-13 m55p-14 m55p-15 image-caption">Anosh Irani Image Credit:&nbsp;Nimal&nbsp;Shah</div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e54 m55p-r m55p-s m55p-u"><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e55 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> And as you grow into your identity in Canada, do you find it gives you certain freedoms that you might not have had initially?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> People always ask me, or I sometimes find I was freer in India.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> How so?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> I don't know, I can't explain it.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> But you felt freer there?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> In certain ways, I felt freer in India.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Is it that there were no expectations of you to perform in a certain manner, or you were younger then and therefore the journey was different?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Maybe, I don't think there's any expectations now, and if they are, I ignore them. I don't really buy into if you're a writer, then you have to be a particular way. I resist that anyway naturally. But it's hard to say, I mean, here there’s a different kind of freedom, but it's very difficult to put it into words, I am unable to – even after 20 years, now I've been in Canada for 20 years. I'm unable to completely express what this place, it's all mixed, and so is Bombay. I think existence is like that, no matter where you go you have mixed feelings about a place, unless you go to a beach for three days in which case you absolutely love it.</p></div><blockquote class="x-quote e6685-e56 m55p-1d rungh-article-pull-quote"><div class="x-quote-content"><div class="x-quote-text"><hr>
<p>Well, for me, I've realized that the problem is that I'm constantly trying to find home. That's the problem. And if I just stopped finding it, the question would disappear, you know?</p>
<hr></div></div></blockquote><div class="x-text x-content e6685-e57 m55p-v m55p-w m55p-z m55p-10 m55p-11 m55p-13 m55p-16"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> This reminds me of a roundtable conversation that was held in the first issue of Rungh when we first published [in 1992]. I think the title of the piece was [<em>Home as Mythical Space</em>]. And the idea of where is home? Home is a geography, home is a psychology, home is a heritage. So, I ask that same age-old question of you: what does home evoke for you?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Well, for me, I've realized that the problem is that I'm constantly trying to find home. That's the problem. And if I just stopped finding it, the question would disappear, you know?</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> But it seems to be the challenge for all immigrants. Immigrants or migrants.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Absolutely. Absolutely. And it's a sense of – it's a deep sense of loss, even though I've been successful in Canada, I'm grateful to be here and all of that, but I can’t help but think of that better life that I might have had when I go back. I look at my family, my cousins, I always think of those things, and it's not healthy, but it's not the same place, I'm not going back to the same place. The place that I left does not exist, and I can never touch it again. And that’s the problem.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> A bit of an echo, to reference V. S. Naipaul, who recent passed away.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Right.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> There's this idea of those who left home, wherever home was, in the diaspora, and largely of empires, whether they’re British, French, German, or Portuguese - they became deeply Anglophile or Francophile. Is some of your sense of home and displacement tied to that– you can't go back, and you can’t stay?</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Yes, it is. And the thing is, do I want to go back? Some days I want to go back, some days I don't. And it's, again, a push and pull. It's like the theatre, and I always say that in a play, as a writer, you're inviting the audience in, and you make them feel at home in the first 10 minutes of the play, and then when they're comfortable you punch them in the stomach. And then they're out of it again. And they catch their breath and then you say, no, no, it's okay, I'm sorry, just come back in again. And then you repeat. And that's what seems to be happening, when I go back to Bombay I'm comfortable until I sort of feel this punch or I feel this pain, and it's – I don't think it will ever go and maybe it's not meant too. The idea should be that one needs to be comfortable whoever one is, especially if you're a writer, you have – I feel the best position to be in is both as insider and outsider. That's the ideal position, and that's where I'm placed. I keep going back to India every year, and yet I don't fit in there, I come to Canada, I don't fit in here, but it's a great position to be in.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> The insider/ outsider space, and the tension and the effort it takes to hold, if one can even ever hold that space, it's quite fatiguing. It can be invigorating, in that, there's the possibility for discovery in that kind of middle space. But it seems to me that when I speak to writers who are defined as "multicultural," or "ethnic," or "from different geographies," that holding the space is a constant tension that they face, and you seem to be echoing that.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Yeah, absolutely. It is – fatigue is the right word. And every novel or play that I've written, I feel has taken something out of me.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> And so, is there more left of you? [laughing]
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Yes, because you keep discovering, right? So, it takes something away and then it gives you something as well. And I think the idea is to not get drained out, and to somehow get recharged, but I haven't figured that out yet, so.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Well, I think it's a constant quest for all writers.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Absolutely. Absolutely.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> And it's a part of the journey as you’ve said. I thank you very much for sharing your thoughts with Rungh and some of your journey. I look forward to more conversations.</p>
<p><strong>AI:</strong> Thank you so much.</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6685-e58 m55p-0 m55p-4"><div class="x-row e6685-e59 m55p-5 m55p-6 m55p-7 m55p-8 m55p-9 m55p-d m55p-n"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e60 m55p-r m55p-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10561 e6685-e61"><div class="x-section e10561-e1 m85d-0"><div class="x-row e10561-e2 m85d-1 m85d-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10561-e3 m85d-3 m85d-4"><a class="x-image e10561-e4 m85d-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/anosh-irani/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/anosh-irani-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Anosh Irani" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e10561-e5 m85d-3 m85d-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10561-e6 m85d-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Anosh Irani</strong> was born and brought up in Bombay and moved to Vancouver in 1998. He is a critically acclaimed novelist and playwright. His work has been translated into eleven languages, and he teaches Creative Writing in the World Literature Program at Simon Fraser University, Vancouver. He recently published <em>Translated from the Gibberish</em> (2019), a collection of short stories.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10561-e7 m85d-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/anosh-irani/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11336 e6685-e62"><div class="x-section e11336-e2 m8qw-0"><div class="x-row e11336-e3 m8qw-1 m8qw-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11336-e4 m8qw-3 m8qw-4"><a class="x-image e11336-e5 m8qw-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zool-suleman/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ZoolSulemanAugust2023-300x300.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Zool Suleman" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11336-e6 m8qw-3 m8qw-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11336-e7 m8qw-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Zool Suleman</strong> is an advocate, writer, journalist, and cultural collaborator.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11336-e8 m8qw-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zool-suleman/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e6685-e63 m55p-r m55p-s"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6685-e64 m55p-0 m55p-4"><div class="x-row e6685-e65 m55p-5 m55p-8 m55p-9 m55p-a m55p-e m55p-o m55p-p"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e66 m55p-r m55p-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e6685-e67"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6685-e68 m55p-0 m55p-4"><div class="x-row e6685-e69 m55p-5 m55p-9 m55p-a m55p-e m55p-f m55p-o m55p-q"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6685-e70 m55p-r m55p-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e6685-e71"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/shifting-genres-shifting-lands/">Shifting Genres, Shifting Lands</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Does the World Need This Line?</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/does-the-world-need-this-line/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=does-the-world-need-this-line</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 11 Mar 2020 19:23:55 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=6479</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 7, No. 1 / ConversationsDoes the World Need This Line?A Conversation with Dionne&#160;BrandBy Dionne Brand and Chelene KnightDionne Brand. Photo credit: Jason&#160;Chow.Share ArticleDionne Brand in conversation with Chelene Knight on October 19, 2018 in&#160;Vancouver.Editor's note: thank you to Tom Cho for editorial&#160;assistance.Matter Over MarketChelene Knight (CK): When I have conversations with other writers and students, I'm usually asked who ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/does-the-world-need-this-line/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/does-the-world-need-this-line/">Does the World Need This Line?</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e6479-e1 m4zz-0 m4zz-1 m4zz-2"><div class="x-row e6479-e2 m4zz-5 m4zz-6 m4zz-7 m4zz-8 m4zz-9 m4zz-a m4zz-f m4zz-g"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6479-e3 m4zz-m m4zz-n"><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e4 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-s m4zz-t m4zz-u issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-7-number-1/">Vol. 7, No. 1</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6479-e5 m4zz-11 m4zz-12 main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Does the World Need This Line?</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">A Conversation with Dionne&nbsp;Brand</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e6 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-x">By Dionne Brand and Chelene Knight</div></div><div class="x-col e6479-e7 m4zz-n m4zz-o"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6479-e8 m4zz-0 m4zz-2 m4zz-3"><div class="x-row e6479-e9 m4zz-5 m4zz-6 m4zz-7 m4zz-9 m4zz-a m4zz-b m4zz-f m4zz-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6479-e10 m4zz-m m4zz-n m4zz-p"><span class="x-image e6479-e11 m4zz-14"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/dionne-brand-600x600-1.jpg" width="600" height="601" alt="Image" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e12 m4zz-q m4zz-t m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-y m4zz-z image-caption">Dionne Brand. Photo credit: Jason&nbsp;Chow.</div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Does+the+World+Need+This+Line%3F', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Does+the+World+Need+This+Line%3F&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Does+the+World+Need+This+Line%3F&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/does-the-world-need-this-line/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div></div><div class="x-col e6479-e14 m4zz-m m4zz-n m4zz-p"><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e15 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p>Dionne Brand in conversation with Chelene Knight on October 19, 2018 in&nbsp;Vancouver.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e16 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p><em><strong>Editor's note:</strong> thank you to <a href="//rungh.thedev.ca/artists/tom-cho/">Tom Cho</a> for editorial&nbsp;assistance.</em></p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6479-e17 m4zz-11 m4zz-13"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Matter Over Market</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e18 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p><strong>Chelene Knight (CK):</strong> When I have conversations with other writers and students, I'm usually asked who I am writing for, but I don't really like this question. I prefer to think about the reader experience and the reader engagement. How do I want someone—anyone—to <em>feel</em> after they read it. How are they changed? Are they changed? Did any part of what I wrote embed itself in their brain? What do you think about that?</p>
<p><strong>Dionne Brand (DB):</strong> Well, I don't think of a reader when I write, in that direct relation, so I'm not writing <em>for</em> anyone. Maybe I'm writing <em>to</em>, but not for because "for" would seem to me too prescriptive or something. Or too …generous [<em>laughs</em>]. So I don't think of the reader or the audience. I think of the <em>matter</em>, yeah, the matter, the set of ideas that I'm trying to think about. And then work those ideas to their best qualities…. Otherwise, it's an unfair pressure, in a sense, to think about [who the reader is]. And also, that is about market. That is not about writing.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> I don't write <em>to</em> someone or even <em>for</em> someone. I think about, once it's out there, how folks will engage with it, and what pieces of what I wrote will stick.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> What I try to do is trust the material. To trust the idea that I am trying to do and trust that I have worked that idea up to a kind of pitch or up to its best thing that it can be. If you find it, the audience will find that. If you start to think about things like who the reader is, to appeal to the reader, you start to make some really bad decisions for the material that you're dealing with. You start to cut corners. You start to assume that you know such a reader that well. You start to be patronizing about the reader or your lines. So, really, it is the material that you have to work, not the audience. Or not the potential audience or not the assumed audience.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6479-e19 m4zz-11 m4zz-13"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Writing to Answer Questions</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e20 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p><strong>CK:</strong> Writing to answer questions, writing to fill in the gaps. This is how I address that desire to write a specific story or piece. I can hardly imagine what it would be like to write in another way. Are you writing because you already have all of the answers? What can you say about this desire to answer questions with writing?</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Oh, I don't have the answers. Thank god.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Yeah. That's what I say. If I had all the answers, I don't want anyone reading what I'm going to write.</p>
[<em>Both laugh.</em>]
<p><strong>DB:</strong> I think writing is a kind of act of coming to; of constant interrogation, of constant thinking. I wish I did have the answers. I have some.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> That's all you need, right?</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Right. To have the questions is good, right? Ultimately, to have the questions, to continually probe, to probe the taken for granted, to probe the given. And also, I'm not alone in the world, so other people give me questions too that I have to address and other writers that I admire, past and present, give me those questions too. And I think through those questions. I think I'm sitting in a room with a set of people who are thinking about how to be in the world in an ethical way. Because there's so much of the unethical around us. So much of the horrible. And that doesn't make us any more precious. It just makes us—I don't know, open to possibility. So I don't know anything. [<em>Laughs.</em>]
<p><strong>CK:</strong> That's what I'm getting on a T-shirt: "I don't know anything but I'm going to write about it."</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> "But I know a whole bunch," right? [<em>Laughs.</em>]
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Yeah, exactly. It's that idea of questions and how they exist and that's why I'm really drawn to that. [And] what questions am I not answering and why, and is that okay, and do I have to? I think about that in terms of privilege and just what I put on the page. Does it have to answer these questions? And is it okay that it doesn't answer these questions?</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> And it doesn't have to answer everything at once and all the time. It can answer a small thing, right? The other thing about saying "I don't know anything"—I'm not innocent, however. I'm not innocent at all. I'm <em>culpable</em>. I'm here too and I'm living through now and here too. So I'm not the writer who's innocent and who comes at the world innocently. I know some things deeply, historically, politically, do you know what I mean? I know things and I'm trying to think my way through them. I'm trying to figure out how to live in the world given those things that I do know, right? So, I'm not starting from innocence. I'm starting from knowledge. And then I'm trying to work my way to innocence! [<em>Laughs.</em>]</div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6479-e21 m4zz-11 m4zz-13"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">&quot;Because You Have No Power, Your Now is Never Represented&quot;</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e22 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p><strong>CK:</strong> I recently read David Chariandy's <em>Brother</em>, which stole my heart. This is one of those books where I felt the city was just as much a character as the characters were. I've spoken to him about writing and shared bits of my novel with him. I have a novel where the city is a character as well…. What do you think about books that do this? When I read [your book] <em>Thirsty</em> I thought about the city doing many things; I pictured the city speaking up. What do you think about books that take the city or a place as character and kind of elevate that a bit more?</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Yeah. I think that's a way to go. I do that in the poetry in <em>Thirsty</em>, but maybe also in <em>What We All Long For</em>, [my] novel, where it is a sort of "becoming city." It is Toronto but it's a becoming city because the characters in the novel are young and unrepresented so far, as citizens of that city, but are living a life and actually creating the city. Not living a life on the margins of the city because they were in the center of their life.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> That's right.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Right? And they come from various families and with various histories, but they were all born in that city. And how they voice the city or how they see it is one of the important things in that novel…. I mean, I think more people live in cities now than ever did and cities have become these incredibly—and I use this word tentatively—cosmopolitan places, right? I really mean that they are conflicted spaces with conflicting desires, with conflicting politics, with old regimes that still govern them [and] refuse to admit what is in front of their eyes and continue to kind of disenfranchise people. There's all that. People are very agile in that space and move around that space in really interesting ways. I am often interested in that movement, that agility, that futurity—like, what does that mean in, like, ten years and how do people imagine themselves in those cities. And people are always ahead of the conventional or administrative, or people are always ahead of how they are represented—like you're living ahead of that anyway.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> To me, that's exhausting. I kind of want to live in the now for just a bit, if that's possible.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Well, because you have no power, your "now" is never represented, so it's up to writers like you and I to represent that "now," which may seem "future" to someone else who wants to hold that down, right?</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6479-e23 m4zz-11 m4zz-13"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">The Marginalized Writer as Under Pressure to Offer Up Pain in Their Work</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e24 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p><strong>CK:</strong> Last year, I was on a panel with Vivek Shraya and she said something that had us all shouting "Yes!" She said, "I just want to write about a lawn mower"—so, that idea of just writing something simple without worrying that we as marginalized writers are expected to write a "Black experience," the "people of color experience," or offer up trauma and pain on a platter.</p>
<p>And I wondered, too, is that an emerging writer problem? Is it anything that you experienced when you first started out many, many, many years ago?</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Oh, don't say "many, many . . ." like that. How many "manys" do you want to add to that? [<em>Laughs.</em>] Hmm. I'm not writing from a place of pain. I don't think so. But I might write <em>about</em> pain.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> It's a different mindset for sure to feel that pressure to do that, so I wonder have you ever felt the pressure to explain the pain.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> I think the pressure is there. One has to make a choice about whether one attends to that pressure. I just did a talk in Toronto about the spectacularization of Black peoples in media, in narrative in particular, and so on—and whether one attends to that spectacularization. How one does that is really important…. It used to be a question in the ‘60s and the ‘70s, how does it free us? Whatever you're doing, whatever you're writing, how does it free you? The fact that it can is what you need to focus on, not the responses from the traditionally oppressive regimes. I don't really care about that, right. I care about putting together the life that I see and the life that I see being lived and how delicately I have to put that together, right? What I want that to be—like, I have to speak into my imagination, not into other people's deficit.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> I think that's a powerful thing to say and also a really tough thing to do. When I think about just sitting down to write, I think, why don't I just share my story the way I want to share it, and whether or not that's pain or pleasure or hopes and dreams or whatever it is, I think it's important to weave that into your story, into your narrative.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> The thing is, how do you represent fully what it is?</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> And that's exactly the problem.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> I think it's only impossible if you allow those regimes, those oppressive regimes, to militate that, yeah? In a sense, you have to say, who are you speaking to?</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Yes, yes.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Who are you speaking to—people like you or people unlike you whose plans are to kind of keep you in the situation—</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Or to keep you always in that mindset of worrying about it. I just want to step back from that and just do the work that needs to be done and say what has to be said.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Yeah. And how do you come into being? Basically, it's like, it's something about coming into full being, right? If that is where you are, then you don't have to answer sociological questions, which remain sociological questions, which remain questions of classification, and so on. If you're speaking into how to come into full being, right? I know it's difficult but maybe not so, if you just leave certain questions aside?</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Yeah.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> It's—oh, God. Writing is so complicated. I mean, even when your question is extremely complicated. Give me the question again.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> She wanted to write about a lawn mower, so just that idea of—</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> That may not be possible—</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> For example, writing about the Canadian landscape. Can't you just have a poetry book about the mountains or something? But do you feel that pressure to—</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> But all of that is complicated. The mountains are complicated by the oppressive regimes that took over the mountains and we named them …that's just the world we live in. We've got to talk about it, right? The colonization that took over these places and renamed those mountains. I can't walk into the mountain and not ask the real name of the mountain.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> I love that. I love that everyday things can be complex anyway.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Yeah, but maybe we are complex. There's nothing wrong with complexity, you know. We've never lived an un-complex life. History is what we have, and we have to kind of think about it and contend with it.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e6479-e25 m4zz-11 m4zz-13"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Advice from Some Mentors</h2></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e6479-e26 m4zz-q m4zz-r m4zz-u m4zz-v m4zz-w m4zz-y m4zz-10"><p><strong>DB:</strong> I had an early mentor, a man named Roger McTair, who is a writer. He just published a book called <em>My Trouble with Books</em>. I was really close with him for many years. Well, I have several mentors. One of them was Harold Head. He had been banned in South Africa and he came via New York to Toronto and then he started a press called Khoisan Artists and he published my first book of poetry. So many histories there. I was so lucky to have that kind of richness because he had been banned in South Africa. He was anti-apartheid—he was a journalist and [it was] just rich already, right?</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Right.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> And he kind of walked me through my first book and at some point, we sat down. We talked about it and he said—and I knew then too—"You know what, maybe two of these poems will be any good in like twenty, thirty years, forty years." [<em>Laughs.</em>] But that's okay. I have to get through that and get over that, and then, like, write the poems after. But then there was this other friend of mine, Roger McTair, who took my third book of poems, which was a set of epigrams. And he would—he'd go through it as an editor and he [would say] to me, "Dionne, does the world need this line?"</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Wow. Oh.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Yeah. That's a big question.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> That's a very big question.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> And that's a question I ask my students too. I give them that—I give them that story and I say, "That's the question you ask your work."</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> Yeah. And it should be that big and that deep and that wide.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Exactly, right? Now, even if you come up short, that's fine. But you've asked the question.</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> You've asked the question, and you're addressing it, and you're thinking about it.</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> Exactly. And for some people, to ask them that question, it stops them. But it didn't stop me and I don't think it should stop anyone. What it should do is alert you to the room that you are in and what's required, and then how big you must make your ambition. So that's what he [said] and at first I said, "[<em>Tuts</em>] Of course, Roger! What do you mean?"</p>
<p><strong>CK:</strong> "Of course. I wrote this! The world needs that line!"</p>
<p><strong>DB:</strong> [<em>Laughs.</em>] And then I looked. Right? And then I looked. And then: every line has to satisfy to some degree, even to the degree of failure, that prescription. That one, I remember forever. I will remember that forever.</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6479-e27 m4zz-0 m4zz-4"><div class="x-row e6479-e28 m4zz-5 m4zz-6 m4zz-7 m4zz-8 m4zz-c m4zz-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6479-e29 m4zz-m m4zz-n"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10660 e6479-e30"><div class="x-section e10660-e1 m884-0"><div class="x-row e10660-e2 m884-1 m884-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10660-e3 m884-3 m884-4"><a class="x-image e10660-e4 m884-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/dionne-brand/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/dionne-brand-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Dionne Brand" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e10660-e5 m884-3 m884-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10660-e6 m884-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Dionne Brand</strong> was Toronto’s Poet Laureate from 2009 to 2012. In 2017, she was inducted into the Order of Canada. In 2018 she published both a new novel, Theory, and a genre-bending poetry collection, <em>The Blue Clerk</em>.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10660-e7 m884-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/dionne-brand/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10586 e6479-e31"><div class="x-section e10586-e1 m862-0"><div class="x-row e10586-e2 m862-1 m862-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10586-e3 m862-3 m862-4"><a class="x-image e10586-e4 m862-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/chelene-knight/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/chelene-knight-150x150.png" width="150" height="150" alt="Chelene Knight" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e10586-e5 m862-3 m862-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10586-e6 m862-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Chelene Knight</strong> is the author of the poetry collection Braided Skin and the memoir Dear Current Occupant, winner of the 2018 Vancouver Book Award. Her essays have appeared in multiple Canadian and American literary journals.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10586-e7 m862-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/chelene-knight/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e6479-e32 m4zz-m m4zz-n"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6479-e33 m4zz-0 m4zz-4"><div class="x-row e6479-e34 m4zz-5 m4zz-7 m4zz-8 m4zz-9 m4zz-d m4zz-j m4zz-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6479-e35 m4zz-m m4zz-n"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e6479-e36"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e6479-e37 m4zz-0 m4zz-4"><div class="x-row e6479-e38 m4zz-5 m4zz-8 m4zz-9 m4zz-d m4zz-e m4zz-j m4zz-l"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e6479-e39 m4zz-m m4zz-n"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e6479-e40"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/does-the-world-need-this-line/">Does the World Need This Line?</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Passing &#8216;Through the Land’</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/passing-through-the-land/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=passing-through-the-land</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 15 Dec 2019 21:13:26 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=5990</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 6, No. 4 / ConversationsPassing &#8216;Through the Land’Knowledges, introductions and labour in institutional shapeshiftingBy Tara Hogue, Ayumi Goto, Peter Morin and Zool&#160;SulemanAyumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land? Ayumi Goto, ArtistShare ArticleThis conversation took place at the Vancouver Art Gallery on July 18, 2018. It is a reflection upon the Vancouver Art Gallery (VAG) show ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/passing-through-the-land/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/passing-through-the-land/">Passing &#8216;Through the Land’</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e5990-e1 m4me-0 m4me-1 m4me-2"><div class="x-row e5990-e2 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-7 m4me-8 m4me-9 m4me-a m4me-b m4me-g m4me-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e3 m4me-q m4me-r m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e4 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-y m4me-z m4me-10 issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-6-number-4/">Vol. 6, No. 4</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e5990-e5 m4me-1b m4me-1c main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h1 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Passing &#8216;Through the Land’</h1><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">Knowledges, introductions and labour in institutional shapeshifting</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e6 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-13">By Tara Hogue, Ayumi Goto, Peter Morin and Zool&nbsp;Suleman</div></div><div class="x-col e5990-e7 m4me-t m4me-u"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e5990-e8 m4me-0 m4me-2 m4me-3"><div class="x-row e5990-e9 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-7 m4me-8 m4me-9 m4me-a m4me-g m4me-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e10 m4me-q m4me-r m4me-s m4me-t"><span class="x-image e5990-e11 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/goto-and-morin-06-1920x1280-1.jpg" width="960" height="640" alt="Passing &#039;through the land&#039;" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e12 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-15 m4me-16 image-caption"><p><em>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?</em><br />
<span>Ayumi Goto, Artist</span></p></div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=Passing+%26%238216%3BThrough+the+Land%E2%80%99', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Passing+%26%238216%3BThrough+the+Land%E2%80%99&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=Passing+%26%238216%3BThrough+the+Land%E2%80%99&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/passing-through-the-land/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e14 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><em>This conversation took place at the Vancouver Art Gallery on July 18, 2018. It is a reflection upon the Vancouver Art Gallery (VAG) show how do you carry the land? which took place July 14 to October 28, 2018, curated by Tarah Hogue, Senior Curatorial Fellow, Indigenous Art and featuring work by Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin with Corey Bulpitt, Roxanne Charles, Navarana Igloliorte, Cheryl L'Hirondelle, Haruko Okano and Juliane Okot Bitek.</p>

<p><em>The conversation refers to an article by Goto and Morin entitled, "Writing. First. Contact?," which was included in the collection of writings, Performing Utopias in Contemporary Americas (Edited by K. Beauchesne and A. Santos) (2017). It also refers to a conversation held the night before the interview at the Contemporary Art Gallery (CAG), Resonant Presence and Refusals, which featured Jeneen Frei Njootli, Ayumi Goto, Peter Morin and Olivia Whetung, as a part of the CAG solo  show featuring Jeneen Frei Njootli.</em></p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e15 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/goto-and-morin-opening-02-1920x1280-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land? Chief Bill Williams, Community Opening, July13, 2018 Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art Gallery" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e16 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-15 m4me-16 image-caption"><p><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?<br />
</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Chief Bill Williams, Community Opening, July13, 2018<br />
</span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art Gallery</span></p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e17 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p>"The year 2014. This Tahltan (male) body. That Japanese (female) body. Two. Movement together. To perform a first contact. The idea is that colonial literature defines a space for these bodies. A savage. A geisha. Not much movement. Not much space. And the birth of scars that reach down into our spirit bodies" – Writing. First. Contacts? (Goto/Morin) (2017)</p>

<p><strong>Zool Suleman:</strong> I wanted to start by thanking all of you for being so generous with your time today and engaging in this conversation. I have seen the show and I'm just overwhelmed by the possibilities that it explores. When I first saw the title; how do you carry the land? I was very intrigued by two things. One, obviously the specificity of the land. It's unclear which land though we can conjecture, and maybe we shouldn't, and, [two] this notion of "carry".</p>

<p>Normally we think of carrying physical things. We carry emotional things. This position of carrying something that looks very heavy and solid that we don't see as movable is a great frame that we kind of move into. From a curatorial perspective, what were you hoping to animate with that frame and with these artists?</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e18 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/goto-and-morin-opening-07-1920x1280-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Image" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e19 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-15 m4me-16 image-caption"><p><em>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?</em><br />
<span>Ayumi Goto, Artist</span></p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e5990-e20 m4me-1b m4me-1d"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Institution and Implication</h3></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e21 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>Tarah Hogue:</strong> Well, the title of the exhibition is a question that's meant to implicate the reader of the title. Coming into the Vancouver Art Gallery for my first exhibition and this fellowship position I was thinking about, as M&eacute;tis and Dutch-Canadian woman on territories that are not my own, how to engage with the presence of Indigenous Peoples on their territories as well as how to engage with the history of the site. The Vancouver Art Gallery is a former provincial courthouse. I was also thinking about all the exhibitions that have happened here, in particular, thinking about exhibitions around Indigenous arts and what kind of claims the gallery has participated in in the making of that art history. Moving from an artist-run center context, where I was working before coming into this space, involved a radical change in who would experience the work that Peter and Ayumi have made with the other artists. This was sort of my constellation of thoughts as we approached the conversations around the exhibition between the three of us.</p>

<p>The title is really meant to provoke people into thinking about this question deeply from their own perspectives and experiences. By asking the question it is meant to also hopefully engender a pause in approaching the exhibition. So, the title wall starts with a series of questions. How do we come to be in relationship to this place? How have I come to be in relationship to this place? How does artistic practice help us to parse that out and to think more deeply about our responsibilities to place?</p>

<p><strong>ZS:</strong> You used this word 'implicate' which I find fascinating. How do you think the institution has responded to the implication? What's your sense of that? You can only speak from your perspective, but you are also within it so there tends to be this kind of, "I'm in it, I'm not in it". It's a very difficult space and I appreciate it may be a difficult question which you can either defer or respond to. But I find that dialogue interesting because these institutional spaces that are opening up at long last. The kind of knowledges from which the institutions work and Indigenous curators and artists work are very different. This institution that you have been in and this show that you are doing here, do you have a sense of how that implication has been responded to?</p>

<p><strong>TH:</strong> I can only speak from my own perspective but the position that I'm in was created because of a recognition that the gallery needed to engage and think more deeply about its relationships with the Indigenous communities that surround this site. And to do so in a more sustained way. Curators who have worked at the gallery in the past have certainly developed relationships with certain Indigenous artists in BC in particular but, the institution, as so many exhibiting institutions, is really driven by the project timeline and so a more sustained look at what that relationship building process looks like or could look like is something that the gallery hasn't had an opportunity to pursue.</p>

<p>The drive of this exhibition is very much within that line of thinking, that line of questioning. We had such a tremendous show of support from the community at the opening. It was such a joyous event. It really set the tone for the exhibitions. Some people have said that it felt very different to be in this space than during other similar events in the past. Yeah, I think it's sort of at the beginning of &hellip; it's not like it's the very beginning because people have been doing good work here but it does feel like a new page I think for a lot of people.</p></div></div><div class="x-col e5990-e22 m4me-q m4me-r m4me-s m4me-t"></div></div></div><div class="x-row e5990-e23 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-7 m4me-9 m4me-a m4me-c m4me-g m4me-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e24 m4me-q m4me-s m4me-t m4me-v"><span class="x-image e5990-e25 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/goto-and-morin-041280x1920-1-683x1024-1.jpg" width="341" height="512" alt="Ayumi Goto geisha gyrl: yakyuu! Let’s go!!, 2017 documentation of performance Courtesy of the Artist Photo: Brendan Yandt" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e26 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-18 image-caption"><p>Ayumi Goto<br />
geisha gyrl: yakyuu! Let’s go!!, 2017<br />
documentation of performance<br />
Courtesy of the Artist<br />
Photo: Brendan Yandt</p></div></div><div class="x-col e5990-e27 m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e5990-e28 m4me-1b m4me-1d"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Passing and Introductions</h3></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e29 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> In the work that you [Ayumi and Peter] do and the paper that you and Peter wrote, Peter gets positioned as the Tahltan male body. What does that conjecture for you when you hear that?</p>

<p><strong>Ayumi Goto:</strong> A Tahltan male?</p>

<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Yes.</p>

<p><strong>AG:</strong> So many things actually. From what I have learned from Peter, Tahltan culture and nation is actually matriarchal. When I think about the role of the male in a matriarchy, it carries very differently than the male body in a patriarchy. I come from a strong female lineage (matriarchy). In the Japanese context, the inheritance of family names is politically and socially specific. If the women's family is from a higher class, then the man adopts the woman's name and the woman's social status and fortune.</p>

<p>In performing with Peter, I recognize Peter's male body in a matriarchal space from my cultural heritage and Peter's cultural heritage.</p>

<p>In our collaborations, we begin with a particular intention, or our own knowledge of what we intend to do and how we hope our ideas, or our actions are communicated. But then we can't address or be cognizant of all the different meanings that are marked onto our bodies. So I think the impetus behind writing First Contacts? was a response to &hellip; For me I thought that that performance [in 2014] went awry just because it wasn't introduced, the title wasn't even given, and many people didn't know that Peter is Indigenous. So, they thought I was like this Asian woman "cleaning" this white guy and I could feel this read of the performance in that very moment.</p>

<p>I could feel it and I was getting horrified by it and so I felt compelled for us to write this essay [in 2017] because it's so much more complicated than that. I think the ease with which we become habituated within the Canadian nationalized context of talking about political relations between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people, male versus female, different genders doesn't at all capture the knowledge that we try to compel with respect each other. It's complicated and there is no straightforward answer.</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e30 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/goto-and-morin-06-1920x1280-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land? Ayumi Goto, Artist" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e31 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-19 image-caption"><p><em>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?</em><br />
<span>Ayumi Goto, Artist</span></p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e32 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> It was interesting to see in the paper in another context, the description for Ayumi as a Japanese female body, but sometimes as a Japanese diasporic person. When you [Peter] hear that what does that kind of resonate for you given where you are located?</p>
<p><strong>Peter Morin:</strong> Ah, the tough question [laughter]. Well I think that that performance in [2014] in particular was really for me thinking that "Japanese woman body" is a description of not just her body as she moves within it and activates it, but also this sort of Canadian-imposed idea. That's like a very real thing and part of the work, as Ayumi was saying, that we have been undertaking is how people make her disappear in the performances. She just totally disappears and there are so many examples of how this happens.</p>

<p>Like ballet for example, the dude comes on for five seconds or whatever and it's just like he is the show, right? And you would hope that in performance you could like shutter those expectations but at the same time it doesn't happen. One of the ways that we had attempted to address that was to become more genders. So, we wore bodies as they are now and the specific genders that they are but inside of us we become both: male and female inside a male body, male and female inside a female body. But I think to speak more directly to your question, I think I feel responsible I guess.</p>
<p>I feel responsible for my friend, for her family to see them and I feel sadness actually when like folks don't fit into this sense of Canadian identity or nation or whatever. Like, if you come from a different place or you have a different story and how you don't get a chance to be that story because Canada doesn't really let you. I have a sense of sadness around that because I think a lot of folks are kind of like a miracle I guess.</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e33 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Goto-and-Morin-08-1920x1280-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land? Ayumi Goto, Artist" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e34 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-19 image-caption"><p><em>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?</em><br />
<span>Ayumi Goto, Artist</span></p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e35 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> It touches for me upon a conversation that was in the first issue [of Rungh magazine in 1992-1993]. This idea of "home as a mythical space". We construct these notions of home whether its geography or family or certain special placements whatever that may be, and then the nation state kind of comes in and fucks it up.</p>
<p>And for some people, power accrues to them in the way the system is set up and not only in nationalism but capitalism and all the –isms but then there are the –isms that don't work. Normally in the multicultural dialogue when people from other places or ethnicities describe themselves they insert the word "Canada" as in: South Asian-Canadian, Indian-Canadian, Tamil-Canadian.</p>
<p>But it was interesting to see that in the descriptors you chose for yourselves, there is a distinct evacuation of that word and it brings me to another place, from last night's conversation which I found quite generative. There was this comment, I think Ayumi was saying, this idea of "passing through the land" and also this idea of "those who arrived after". The question I kind of had around that is, is there a sense that those who arrived after pass through the land differently than those who were here and continue to be here?</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e36 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Goto-and-Morin-03-1200x800-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Ayumi Goto Rinrigaku, 2016 documentation of performance Courtesy of the Artist Photo: Yuula Benivolski" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e37 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-19 image-caption"><p>Ayumi Goto<br />
Rinrigaku, 2016<br />
documentation of performance<br />
Courtesy of the Artist Photo: Yuula Benivolski</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e38 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p>I prefer to use that language over a more common kind of academic language between Indigenous and settlers and just kind of reel the conversation around this idea of "passing" and how different people pass differently. Like a door that takes us into a space of possibilities because it's connected and yet there is action and so what happens between the connection and the action particularly given that you do performance art. Tarah, thoughts?</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e5990-e39 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-7 m4me-9 m4me-a m4me-c m4me-g m4me-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e40 m4me-q m4me-s m4me-t m4me-v"><span class="x-image e5990-e41 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Goto-and-Morin-Opening-08-1280x1920-1-683x1024-1.jpg" width="341" height="512" alt="Goto and Morin - Opening" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e42 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-18 image-caption"><p>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the&nbsp;land?<br />
Ayumi Goto, Artist; Peter Morin, Artist; Community Opening, July 13,&nbsp;2018<br />
Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art&nbsp;Gallery</p></div></div><div class="x-col e5990-e43 m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e44 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>TH:</strong> Well, I keep thinking about Sarah Ahmed's writing on academic institutions in how certain bodies pass through or do not pass through these spaces. She talks about institutions as being modes of attention and so, what is attended to is made present and what is not attended to can recede from view. But at the same time bodies who are marked as 'different' also come to be sort of like aberrations against the absent center that is whiteness.</p>
<p>Spaces accrue or allow for certain bodies to be in them in a naturalized, normative way where passing through is not something that is paid much attention to because those bodies are normalized in that space. That's not really necessarily speaking to my own sense of being part of Métis diaspora but just specifically thinking about being an institutional space. So, I will just say that for now.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Is it common to be in that space without being oppositional to whiteness? I have asked the other question, but I'm just saying as you think about this idea of passing through the land and those who arrived after, let's stick first of all to how you would respond to that first part of it and then we can deal with what Tarah was saying.</p>
<p><strong>AG:</strong> I started thinking a lot about passing through and listening to Cheryl L'Hirondelle giving talks and the way she would introduce herself. She would talk a lot about passing, that is, passing as a white person, and it really made an impression on me. I'm thinking about the institution where I am just about to finish my PhD which has been an extremely painful process and passing through is like trying to be as unobtrusive as possible, and trying to be invisible to do the work to subvert that normalization. If you make too much of a splash or are too loud or too aggressive or seen as making an obnoxious challenge, you are going to get cut down. You are going to get hurt and maybe hurt others as well in the process.</p>
<p>I think the idea of passing through then breaks down those kinds of classifications of political barriers that we create by saying Indigenous versus non-Indigenous, because we all have this experience of passing through. And it might be that point of having a conversation without feeling like it has to be an Us and Them or either/or. I like the ambivalence of the term because I think with passing through you can also pass through like a ghost and no one ever notices you and then you cannot be harmed, because no one ever notices you. So, it may make one more mindful of the kind of negative connotations of both how you act as well as how things are acted upon you by passing through.</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e45 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Goto-and-Morin-01-1920x1080-1-1024x576-1.jpg" width="1024" height="576" alt="Peter Morin and Ayumi Goto this is what happens when we perform the memory of the land, 2013 documentation of performance Courtesy of the artists Photo: Ashok Mathur" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e46 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-19 image-caption"><p>Peter Morin and Ayumi Goto<br />
<em>this is what happens when we perform the memory of the land</em>, 2013<br />
documentation of performance<br />
Courtesy of the artists<br />
Photo: Ashok Mathur</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e47 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> The ideas of presence and fragility and what happens between the space of presence and fragility and kind of where that takes us sometimes.</p>
<p><strong>AG:</strong> Yes.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> The nation state is pretty clear about this idea of presence and of the people they want to be present and how we think of this notion of fragility. It's almost like the coin only flips towards presence but not towards embodying fragility.</p>
<p><strong>AG:</strong> Yes. That's true.</p>
<p><strong>ZS:</strong> That's seen as a negative default position, right?</p>
<p><strong>AG:</strong> Yes.</p>
<p><strong>PM:</strong> I guess listening to Tarah and to you three gave me a notion of thinking about not passing but I guess the idea of not passing doesn't actually fit in with the idea of passing.</p>
<p><strong>TH:</strong> What about the idea of mobility in relationship to the idea of passing? Because you think a lot about how Tahltan knowledge is mobile on the land.</p>
<p><strong>PM:</strong> Yeah that's great. I think the conversation about borders and boundaries and things like that actually makes me feel very exhausted now. And thinking about what Ayumi is offering, this idea of passing through. We offer an opportunity for so much more than just the line and the identity and this is how we learn how to talk to each other with these tools that are designed by the nation state which are designed to privilege one person over the other.</p>
<p>Just thinking about what you are saying, about not just passing through, not just as a generative offering but actually it's something that reprioritizes how we can actually meet.. Like it's a really great connection to the provocation, how do you carry the land? For me, the question of land for Indigenous folks as it lives in my body is specifically tied to resource extraction as a result of colonization. Which then gets picked up, because in all our Indigenous knowledges and knowledges in general, which are not in the sense, the perceived center, are actually all extracted from everyone to redetermine the power of what we see at the center.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e5990-e48 m4me-1b m4me-1d"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Teaching, Learning and Possibilities</h3></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e49 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> There is, at times, a rigidity building around the classifications that the nation gives you: I'm Indigenous, I'm a person of colour, I'm a settler, I'm a descendant from chattel slavery. I mean, there are all these kinds of ways in which the way people understand their own knowledge and constructive identities, and then the state takes a stake in that. So, then these walls build up and the in the pushing and pulling between the walls sometimes, it is not very generous.</p>

<p>I hear a very generous, vulnerable talk that we are having as artists who make their art and as a curator who is in an institution and outside it. Why do you think this kind of vulnerability that we are sharing, scares people out there in the world of what they may call "real politics" or the world of art institutions ? What is it about these spaces that we are sharing, the exhibit for instance, is a gift and a sharing, but that generosity doesn't seem to exist in other spaces, what's that about? A false scarcity, or a historical dynamic, or a moment that we are in now?</p>

<p><strong>PM:</strong> When I think about my childhood growing up around old school elders and [&hellip;], and about what it actually means to pass over or through these spaces. That makes me reflect that experience. It's a similar kind of travelling, it's a similar kind of &hellip; I mean, people move for different reasons anyway. Like scarcity of food for example. There is a fear connected to that around survival. But there is a kind of way to see and be connected to those stories or how M&eacute;tis people were forcibly moved.</p>

<p>I think what you are talking about and what your question is about, are the problems of introductions. I would understand it as: we have inherited these particular tools in order to activate our relationship to that system that endeavors to overtake our possibilities. So, this is the tool that we have, I am this person, I am this, you are that. It's not about meeting but it actually is about us proving that the system works maybe a little bit.</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e50 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/goto-and-morin-opening-04-1920x1280-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land? Ayumi Goto, Artist, Community Opening, July 13, 2018 Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art Gallery" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e51 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-19 image-caption"><p>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?<br />
Ayumi Goto, Artist, Community Opening, July 13, 2018<br />
Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art Gallery</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e52 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> This  brings me to an interesting juncture. I'm going to start with Peter on this. You made a couple of very interesting comments at yesterday's panel. One was this idea of your mother and your family, your elders. Then you said something when we talked about this idea of being on the land and knowledge making and you said something like, "who teaches you to be a part of the world?" That sounds pretty simple, and yet it is so utterly profound when we think about who teaches us to be a part of the world, now.</p>

<p>There is a kind of an institutional reliance: the school does it or the counsellor does it or the police do it or the state does it but your question goes to a much deeper point.  Your comments link to this other point which I found, again, full of possibilities which is the idea that Indigenous spaces are more generative than the colonial spaces. So, this idea of who teaches us how to be a part of the world, and then indigenous spaces are more generative than colonial spaces.</p>

<p>Then I believe there is another comment you made where you said that there is this sense that this space of Indigenous knowledge making has global possibilities. I wanted to connect those ideas together about knowledge making, the possibilities of space in contradistinction to the kind of colonial space we are in. I just found those three comments very linked.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e5990-e53 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-7 m4me-9 m4me-a m4me-c m4me-g m4me-l"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e54 m4me-q m4me-s m4me-t m4me-v"><span class="x-image e5990-e55 m4me-1e m4me-1f"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Goto-and-Morin-05-1280x1920-1-683x1024-1.jpg" width="683" height="1024" alt="Peter Morin Cultural Graffiti in London, 2013 documentation of performance Courtesy of the Artist Photo: Dylan Robinson" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e56 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-1a image-caption"><p>Peter Morin<br />
<em>Cultural Graffiti in London</em>, 2013<br />
documentation of performance<br />
Courtesy of the Artist<br />
Photo: Dylan Robinson</p></div></div><div class="x-col e5990-e57 m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e58 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>PM:</strong> Well, I think the very first answer maybe is that we are all here together. I think that that blows my mind. It blows my mind. It's great. The system often is some straight, white guy in charge and all that stuff. There is no straight, white guy coming in here to tell us what to do and it's not that all those straight, white guys in power and privilege are bad or whatever. But who teaches you about how to be a part of the world? If this was working how it should have been working, all the folks who travel here would have learnt hən̓q̓əmin̓əm̓  [halkomelem] . They would have learned  the language of this place. There would be languages and that would be happening and a conceptual world-view of this place would be taught to everyone. That's part of the answer and imagine that beautiful possibility.</p></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e5990-e59 m4me-1b m4me-1d"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Generative Spaces, Labour and Institutional Shapeshifting</h3></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e60 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>ZS:</strong> Then there is this idea of the Indigenous spaces being more generative than the colonial spaces?
     
<strong>AG:</strong> Well, in part of my dissertation I made a strong argument to support the nationalization of all Indigenous languages in Canada. Coming from an English as a second language perspective, if English or French is your second language and you speak it poorly, you feel morally and politically and socially judged. It deeply affects your emotions, your capacity to express happiness and joy.</p>

<p>I think it will give us a strong Indigenous sense of cosmopolitanism and it gives a chance for people who otherwise feel so much pressure to belong in a particular way. Now there are multiple Indigenous languages and it really matters what land you are on to know how you might behave. Whereas right now it's like all of those interrelational intricacies and all the different cultures are just swept under and suppressed by the expectations of the nation state.</p>

<p><strong>PM:</strong> There are  so many examples of how the world has come here already, before settler colonialism. The Chinese boats, Japanese boats, Hawaiian, Asian, Samoan folks and there are so many particular stories about these places of connection. Like I had a friend who went to China and this was a while ago but he went for the Shanghai Olympics. Then he posted a picture of two tall poles carved by old school ancient Chinese folks but somehow that's happening over there and over here at the same time, but nobody really wants to open themselves up to the complications.</p>

<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Another space I wanted to go into is about institutions and doing the hard work, which came up yesterday. One of the artists that sat on the panel was saying that they are tired of doing the hard work and they are tired of being put in that place of having to explain. It was interesting to see your response to that Peter, which was kind of like, "you have to do the work," is the quote that I have. Educate others but you cannot give so much of yourself as to get exhausted. This idea of labour and the labour involved in institution shifting, is that labour getting easier at all?</p></div><span class="x-image e5990-e61 m4me-1e"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Goto-and-Morin-Opening-09-1920x1080-1-1024x683-1.jpg" width="1024" height="683" alt="Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land? Ayumi Goto, Artist; Peter Morin, Artist; Community Opening, July 13, 2018 Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art Gallery" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e62 m4me-w m4me-z m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-14 m4me-16 m4me-19 image-caption"><p><em>Ayumi Goto and Peter Morin: how do you carry the land?</em><br />
Ayumi Goto, Artist; Peter Morin, Artist; Community Opening, July 13, 2018<br />
Photo: Pardeep Singh, Vancouver Art Gallery</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e5990-e63 m4me-w m4me-x m4me-10 m4me-11 m4me-12 m4me-14 m4me-17"><p><strong>TH:</strong> No. I'm speaking from my own generational perspective; I can say that I was not part of the artists organizing in the '80s or '90s to shift institutions at that time. But I just think that things change. You always talk about colonialism as being a shapeshifter; Ayumi does, which it absolutely is, and there is no clear or single path to travel in order to do this work successfully.</p>

<p>I think about the way that the two of you approach your collaboration in terms of thinking very deeply about the specificity of your relationship, about each of your respective experiences. t really takes that much attention to the situation of the place that you are in, the histories that are there, the people that are working alongside you, to parse out how to effectively move forward. But, yes, we are in a global conversation. We are in a national conversation. As an Indigenous curator I'm a part of a very small cohort of folks who are dealing with similar issues within their institutions. We have these positions and are being called upon to respond to questions all the time, of all manner, that we may or may not have the answers for.</p>

<p>And there is a tension between--for me personally--wanting to be generous with the people that I work with and to help the institution think through these things, and then just being like totally overwhelmed and not knowing where to start. I think that it's a long game and institutions have to be willing to look at the long game and have to be also ready to actually think about what outcomes they are looking for. Although this is a process that we are going through and the process is so important, they have to think about the implications of what it is they are undertaking. </p>

<p><strong>PM:</strong> I mean, that's part of what I was saying last night too. We have work to do but the people in that room at the CAG [Contemporary Art Gallery]they have work to do as well. Personally, I have been in this situation before, to acknowledge the costs that Indigenous folks and people of colour folks actually, we have to work twice as hard in order to catch that Canadian, white person up before we can actually start doing the work. We are working twice as hard and we are getting paid half of what they are getting paid and we are doing their work for them. It's a very bad situation. We have got stuff to do. The conversation we are having right now is the conversation, you know?</p>

<p><strong>TH:</strong> Yes.</p>

<p><strong>AG:</strong> I find too that in the work that needs to be done, you do want to find those friends that you can count on. Whether they are sometimes visiting the institution that you are a part of, or they are outside, or they are alongside with you in the inside. The people who nurture you and then you take care of each other and no strings attached. No conditionals and it's like, we have to look out for each other and when you find those people your heart knows this deeply. Sometimes just to be able to talk to somebody or to develop a friendship amidst all the craziness is a moment of rest or that moment of just care. I think by centering a friendship, it's not just a singular friendship anymore; these friendships are mushrooming out and proliferating. &hellip; &hellip;</p>

<p><strong>ZS:</strong> Thank you to you all.</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e5990-e64 m4me-0 m4me-4"><div class="x-row e5990-e65 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-7 m4me-8 m4me-b m4me-d m4me-m"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e66 m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-10566 e5990-e67"><div class="x-section e10566-e1 m85i-0"><div class="x-row e10566-e2 m85i-1 m85i-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e10566-e3 m85i-3 m85i-4"><a class="x-image e10566-e4 m85i-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/ayumi-goto/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/ayumi-goto-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Ayumi Goto" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e10566-e5 m85i-3 m85i-5"><div class="x-text x-content e10566-e6 m85i-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Ayumi Goto</strong> is a performance apprentice, currently based in Toronto. Born in Canada, she sometimes draws upon her Japanese heritage and language to investigate notions of national culturalism, senses of belonging, and activism in her creative practice.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e10566-e7 m85i-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/ayumi-goto/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11316 e5990-e68"><div class="x-section e11316-e1 m8qc-0"><div class="x-row e11316-e2 m8qc-1 m8qc-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11316-e3 m8qc-3 m8qc-4"><a class="x-image e11316-e4 m8qc-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/tarah-hogue/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/tarah-hogue-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Tarah Hogue" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11316-e5 m8qc-3 m8qc-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11316-e6 m8qc-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><p><strong>Tarah Hogue</strong> is the inaugural Senior Curatorial Fellow, Indigenous Art at the Vancouver Art Gallery and is a Visiting Curator at the Institute of Modern Art in Mianjin Brisbane for 2018.</p></div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11316-e7 m8qc-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/tarah-hogue/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11997 e5990-e69"><div class="x-section e11997-e1 m999-0"><div class="x-row e11997-e2 m999-1 m999-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11997-e3 m999-3 m999-4"><a class="x-image e11997-e4 m999-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/peter-morin/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/peter-morin-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Peter Morin" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11997-e5 m999-3 m999-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11997-e6 m999-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Peter Morin</strong> is a Tahltan Nation artist, curator, and writer. In his artistic practice and curatorial work, Morin’s practice-based research investigates the impact zones that occur when indigenous cultural-based practices and western settler colonialism collide.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11997-e7 m999-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/peter-morin/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-11336 e5990-e70"><div class="x-section e11336-e2 m8qw-0"><div class="x-row e11336-e3 m8qw-1 m8qw-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e11336-e4 m8qw-3 m8qw-4"><a class="x-image e11336-e5 m8qw-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zool-suleman/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ZoolSulemanAugust2023-300x300.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Zool Suleman" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e11336-e6 m8qw-3 m8qw-5"><div class="x-text x-content e11336-e7 m8qw-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><strong>Zool Suleman</strong> is an advocate, writer, journalist, and cultural collaborator.</div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e11336-e8 m8qw-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/zool-suleman/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e5990-e71 m4me-s m4me-t"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e5990-e72 m4me-0 m4me-4"><div class="x-row e5990-e73 m4me-5 m4me-7 m4me-8 m4me-9 m4me-b m4me-e m4me-n m4me-o"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e74 m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e5990-e75"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e5990-e76 m4me-0 m4me-4"><div class="x-row e5990-e77 m4me-5 m4me-6 m4me-8 m4me-9 m4me-b m4me-e m4me-f m4me-n m4me-p"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e5990-e78 m4me-s m4me-t"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e5990-e79"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/passing-through-the-land/">Passing &#8216;Through the Land’</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>In the Margins</title>
		<link>https://rungh.thedev.ca/in-the-margins/?utm_source=rss&#038;utm_medium=rss&#038;utm_campaign=in-the-margins</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Rungh Editor]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 19 Mar 2019 13:45:33 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Conversations]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://rungh.org/?p=4365</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Vol. 6, No. 2 / ConversationsIn the MarginsAlternative arts spaces in Toronto and BangaloreBy Tara AtluriArtist: Sofy Yuditskaya Image: Lighting Installation entitled IRROYGBIVShare ArticleA night can only be told in song. Saturday nights of hazy lyrics and sharp beats in a city of endless ringtones, calls to prayer and calls to arms that mark our time as one of noise. The ... </p>
<div><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/in-the-margins/" class="more-link">Read More</a></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/in-the-margins/">In the Margins</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="cs-content" class="cs-content"><div class="x-section e4365-e1 m3d9-0 m3d9-1 m3d9-2"><div class="x-row e4365-e2 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-7 m3d9-8 m3d9-9 m3d9-a m3d9-f m3d9-g"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e3 m3d9-p m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e4 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-x m3d9-y m3d9-z issue-category-btn"><a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-6-number-2/">Vol. 6, No. 2</a> / <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/magazine/articles/conversations/">Conversations</a></div><div class="x-text x-text-headline e4365-e5 m3d9-1c main-title"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h2 class="x-text-content-text-primary">In the Margins</h2><span class="x-text-content-text-subheadline">Alternative arts spaces in Toronto and Bangalore</span></div></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e6 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-12">By Tara Atluri</div></div><div class="x-col e4365-e7 m3d9-r m3d9-s m3d9-t"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e4365-e8 m3d9-0 m3d9-2 m3d9-3"><div class="x-row e4365-e9 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-7 m3d9-9 m3d9-a m3d9-b m3d9-f m3d9-h"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e10 m3d9-r m3d9-s m3d9-t"></div><div class="x-col e4365-e11 m3d9-p m3d9-r m3d9-s m3d9-t"><span class="x-image e4365-e12 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/in-the-margins-banner-1920x1280-1.jpg" width="960" height="640" alt="Artist: Sofy Yuditskaya Image: Lighting Installation entitled IRROYGBIV" loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e13 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-14 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 image-caption">Artist: Sofy Yuditskaya Image: Lighting Installation entitled IRROYGBIV</div><div  class="x-entry-share" ><p>Share Article</p><div class="x-share-options"><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on Facebook" onclick="window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed&amp;t=In+the+Margins', 'popupFacebook', 'width=650, height=270, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-facebook-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xf082;"></i></a><a href="#share" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share" title="Share on X" onclick="window.open('https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=In+the+Margins&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Frungh.thedev.ca%2Fcategory%2Fconversations%2Ffeed', 'popupTwitter', 'width=500, height=370, resizable=0, toolbar=0, menubar=0, status=0, location=0, scrollbars=0'); return false;"><i class="x-icon-twitter-square" data-x-icon-b="&#xe61a;"></i></a><a href="mailto:?subject=In+the+Margins&amp;body=Hey, thought you might enjoy this! Check it out when you have a chance: https://rungh.thedev.ca/in-the-margins/" data-x-element="extra" data-x-params="{&quot;type&quot;:&quot;tooltip&quot;,&quot;trigger&quot;:&quot;hover&quot;,&quot;placement&quot;:&quot;bottom&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;&quot;,&quot;content&quot;:&quot;&quot;}" class="x-share email" title="Share via Email"><span><i class="x-icon-envelope-square" data-x-icon-s="&#xf199;"></i></span></a></div></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e15 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>A night can only be told in song. Saturday nights of hazy lyrics and sharp beats in a city of endless ringtones, calls to prayer and calls to arms that mark our time as one of noise. The city of Bangalore hums along to the tune of endless traffic. The space for music in a city like Bangalore is everywhere. It is here and there, in the pitter-patter song of a rural woman turned city maid cleaning a room, in a language I cannot place. The musical prose of the sound of a call to prayer marks the hour in an infinite time of faith. Despite burgeoning spaces of malls and private parties with guest lists as long as names missing from the voter registry, the city maintains a resilient D.I.Y spirit.</p>
  
<p>Across an expanse of oceans and cultural divides, the city of Toronto is haunted by the endless sound of construction. Condominiums and luxury homes are erected daily, with immigrant middle classes building swimming pools while the water advisory warnings on Indigenous reserves rise. The sound of the city is both dreamy and melancholic. A city of immigrants will string together anthems out of intangible hopes and the lament of endless labour. A city so young will sing of first loves and crafty ambition, a willful naiveté.</p>
  
<p>Walkin Studios is an artist run center and music venue in Bangalore. Unit 2 in Toronto is also an independent venue, recording studio, and creative hub. Worlds apart, these spaces meet in the margins of the mainstream.</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e16 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/walkin-studios-600x800-1.jpg" width="600" height="800" alt="Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 1." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e17 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-18 image-caption"><p>Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 1.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e18 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Vivek Chockalingam of Walkin Studios and Rosina Kazi from Unit 2 offer inspiring thoughts and anecdotes regarding the ways that artist run spaces throughout the world create new worlds of meaning, communion and political integrity. What unites these seemingly disparate creative worlds is the lack of cynicism that both spaces and their aspirations exude.</p>
<p>The guiding ethos of Walkin Studios is simple and yet ambitious in its unapologetic love of art. Vivek discusses their manifesto:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"Ultimately, we want the ethos to be about fostering creativity. We like to push boundaries, experiment, and not be afraid to be bold. We have worked on a manifesto that initiates a workflow in the space. It is fairly short and is as follows:</em></p>

<ol>
 	<li style="list-style-type: none;">
<ol>
 	<li style="list-style-type: none;">
<ol>
 	<li><em>We intend to be brave and bold, make a habit of loving fearlessness.</em></li>
 	<li><em>Making new experiences is a way of self-discovery. It engages the person with a process of action, emotion, thought and senses.</em></li>
 	<li><em>Experiments in environments, where free expression, collaboration, audience participation and rituals are emphasized.</em></li>
 	<li><em>We will be the forefront of experimenting, and unafraid to fail.</em></li>
 	<li><em>Connecting in a meaningful way is what makes people happy.</em></li>
 	<li><em>My favourite artwork is the next one I make…"</em></li>
</ol>
</li>
</ol>
</li>
</ol>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;">(Vivek Chockalingam, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e19 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/in-the-margins-unit2-1-600x400-1.png" width="600" height="400" alt="Unit 2, Toronto. Image 1." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e20 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-18 image-caption"><p>Unit 2, Toronto. Image 1.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e21 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>The mandate of Unit 2 in Toronto is similarly aspirational in its utopian thinking but focuses on the promotion of subaltern art, creating pockets of belonging for those exiled from the dominant imaginary. The mandate is as follows:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"We are QT2S/BIPOC (Queer / Trans, 2 Spirit and/or Black, Indigenous and People of Colour) and friends. This is a radical arts and community space dedicated to building community and building bridges! We are a DIT (do it together) space.' </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Spaces of cities are resplendent with the historical markers of many epochs comingling in an often chaotic and memorable assemblage. Michel Foucault once wrote, "[o]ur epoch is one in which space takes for us the form of relations among sites. In any case I believe that the anxiety of our era has to do fundamentally with space, no doubt a great deal more than with time." (Foucault, 1967)</p>
<p>The urban polis of an Indian city was once designed for the entry and exit of colonial powers whose aim was to extract cheap goods and labour from colonized people. Today, the postcolonial city is an open book, with many unfinished stories unfurling across half finished sidewalks.</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e22 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/walkin-studios-2-800x533-1.jpg" width="800" height="533" alt="Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 2. Memory Salad by Tara Goswami poster." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e23 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-19 image-caption"><p>Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 2. <em>Memory Salad</em> by Tara Goswami poster.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e24 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Spaces of art and creativity are often not prioritized in development goals, with imagination being seen as frivolous in comparison to practical concerns of basic infrastructure and economic justice. And yet, the doors of avant-garde culture open us to worlds of possibility. Spaces such as Walkin Studios in Bangalore, India evade the neoliberal logic of an India of burgeoning malls, and the colonial puritanism that lingers like the smell of bleach. Chockalingam states,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"Walkin Studios was initiated in 2015 with the collective effort from my colleagues of artists and designers. It was a slow growing concern that there are not enough creative practices and exhibitions in the city (Bangalore). No space pushed limits, and for inspiration some of us even travelled cities. This also gave insight into the gap in the art scene that was needed to be addressed.</em></p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>….<br />
To acquire a space for art is always difficult, as I mentioned earlier it does not have much value here. One must have funding and enough support to build something from scratch. The alternative that is happening in Bangalore is artists are opening up their homes and studios as cultural art spaces to gather and showcase. This is breaking many patterns and establishing a bottom up network of creative people."</em> (Vivek Chockalingam, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e25 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/in-the-margins-banner-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 3." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e26 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-19 image-caption"><p>Artist: Sofy Yuditskaya Image: Lighting Installation entitled&nbsp;IRROYGBIV.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e27 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Grassroots creativity waves its own flag, with artists in cities such as Toronto also collectively organizing and building their own life worlds. Unit 2 is an independent music venue and studio space in the city of Toronto, Canada run by Rosina Kazi and Nicholas Murr who are part of the band LAL. It functions not only as a place of pleasure but one that cultivates and sustains ethical communities. Kazi discusses the history of how Unit 2 was created,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"Unit 2 started over nine years ago. Nic and I grew tired of the Canadian / Toronto music industry and I personally found it difficult to find my place in it and wanted to do something different and more locally focused. So we had friends who had a space at 163 Sterling and luckily, we got into an amazing space that was built by a black photographer and her father I believe. It's also on the main floor and was small but accessible!" </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e4365-e28 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-7 m3d9-9 m3d9-a m3d9-b m3d9-f m3d9-i"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e29 m3d9-r m3d9-s m3d9-t"></div><div class="x-col e4365-e30 m3d9-r m3d9-t m3d9-u"><div class="x-content-area e4365-e31 m3d9-1e"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e4365-e32 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-7 m3d9-9 m3d9-a m3d9-b m3d9-f m3d9-j"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e33 m3d9-r m3d9-s m3d9-t"></div><div class="x-col e4365-e34 m3d9-p m3d9-r m3d9-s m3d9-t"><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e35 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Vivek discusses the relationship between market-based capitalism and art, a common theme that unites the struggles of artists from India to Canada. They state,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"Market based capitalism has made abundant platforms/venues for artists and musicians, but this has taken the art into an environment where selling other consumables becomes the primary objective of the platform/venue. This can only be justified, if the artist is paid well. There has been an influx in the independent art scene along with the growth of commercial events. Though the independent art scene is often temporary, they disappear and re-appear as they cannot sustain themselves (unless they are backed by Funding)." </em>(Vivek Chockalingam, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Discussing the negotiations that artists make between creating communal spaces and making a living wage Rosina Kazi states that they,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;">"<em>…don't see it (Unit 2) as a capitalist venture, but we have to recognize it is a business in some ways in order to be accountable. I hate brand culture, but I think we just need to re-imagine and question the language we use, versus always trying to sell something." </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Kazi states that Unit 2 is a D.I.T (Do it Together) space that negotiates an art market saturated by branding in an increasingly gentrified city such as Toronto.</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e36 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/unit-2-toronto-image-2.jpg" width="1024" height="1024" alt="Unit 2, Toronto. Image 2." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e37 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-1a image-caption"><p>Unit 2, Toronto. Image 2.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e38 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Jacques Ranciere discusses how art is a matter of the "…distribution of the sensible…" where aesthetic gestures are diffused across a range of sites to create visual common sense. (Ranciere, 2004) Art is always political as it involves using certain aesthetics to counter an edifice of transnational capitalist similitude often oriented towards conformity. Reflective of Ranciere's understanding of art as having the capacity to shift our sense of meaning in radical ways, Chockalingam asserts the political responsibility of the artist:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"Art spaces are bound to work on social justice inevitably. They have the responsibility of fostering conversations on all topics and critically analyze society." </em>(Vivek Chockalingam, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Kazi discusses the racism of the mainstream music and art industry in Turtle Island and the role that Unit 2 plays in sustaining social justice movements and art that critically engages with questions of colonialism. As Kazi states,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"I think we have a huge systemic issue in Canada when it comes to race, across the board, from education, to workplace, to government to the music industry. In the case of the Toronto music and arts scene, there are still a lot of old/ young cis white men at the helm, this is changing but it's too slow. This definitely needs to change! That's why we don't tell the media cuz we don't want it to be just white folks showing up and mainstream media is really geared towards middle class and up and white communities." </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Unit 2 functions as a liminal place of belonging for those whose embodiment marks them as targets of violence. Kazi states,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"As a brown, gender fluid, fat, radical person, I'm not embraced by the industry, but mostly cuz I refused to part of gender expectations and I don't kiss ass, especially white peoples asses and the arts industry has a lot to do with how well you ‘network' verses in the arts community that we are in where it's about cultivating and supporting real relationships." </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>In an arts industry often defined by contacts, those who are disconnected from the hipster family tree of cis-gender white men are often strange fruit, either made into spectacle or made invisible.</p></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e4365-e39 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-7 m3d9-9 m3d9-a m3d9-b m3d9-f m3d9-k"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e40 m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"><span class="x-image e4365-e41 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/in-the-margins-unit2-3-300x400-1.jpg" width="300" height="400" alt="Unit 2, Toronto. Image 3." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e42 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-1b image-caption"><p>Unit 2, Toronto. Image 3.</p></div></div><div class="x-col e4365-e43 m3d9-p m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e44 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>It has somehow become "uncool" to mention difference in many music and art scenes where a post-identity rhetoric seems to imagine away historically constituted oppression through empty platitudes of inclusion. Paradoxically, there is a fetishisation of otherness as spectacle. Vivek discusses how Walkin Studios understands identity politics, coupled with a critical analysis of the commodification of the pain of others. They state,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"We try to be open to anyone, from any gender/caste/class while selecting artists. Art based on these issues can tend to become sympathy seeking artworks, that beg for someone to cry on a topic. We try to be conscious of this, and seek artworks that elevate a viewer/listener. One must have learnt more in a positive way, become more conscious of how to think about issues in a constructive manner." </em>(Vivek Chockalingam, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Rosina discusses the lived pain of identity politics that materializes in rape culture and other forms of violence in creative and activist communities. The artist states,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"…its hard not to consider or be impacted by rape culture cuz it's everywhere, but we do talk to folks and now have more info online about our mandate and our want / aim to create safer places. When there is an accusation of assault by someone who's at a party (the assault occurred somewhere else), I will ask said person to leave…. Our space is generally known as a feminist space so most of us are aware either through our own experiences or our communities, that rape culture has no places at unit 2." </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>In the city of Bangalore, women are often subject to brutal forms of discipline for daring to traverse the city in search of libidinal enjoyment. While the old adage "a woman's place is in the home" seems antiquated, the absence of women in public space is especially pronounced in India where the numbers of non-cis gender men participating in the workface are disturbingly low.</p>
<p>Chockalingam discusses the 2017 New Year's Eve assaults on Brigade Road in Bangalore, where women were molested in public spaces of revelry. They state,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"Women have access to nightlife in the city, but majority would never go to one alone. Certainly artist run spaces are responsible for creating safe spaces, and to actually have deeper conversations about this. They are spaces that enquire about all kinds of social justice -at the same time have positive/constructive growth. The Brigade Road incident was one spark of the greater problem. Women have been suppressed in the Indian society for centuries now. This is mindset is engraved from the time one is born in India. This will not shift overnight, but we must make as many conversations, and correct people (regardless of a situation) to for this to happen sooner." </em>(Vivek Chockalingam, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e45 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/walkin-studios-bangalore-image-4-privacy-to-piracy-poster-800x370-1.jpg" width="800" height="370" alt="Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 4. Privacy to Piracy poster." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e46 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-19 image-caption"><p>Walkin Studios, Bangalore. Image 4. <em>Privacy to Piracy</em> poster.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e47 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Art and music can broach a space for translation, an embodied participation in something greater than oneself . Kazi discusses how building spaces where a cacophony of bodies and desires can meet is cathartic. Both Walkin Studios and Unit 2 are engaged in ongoing efforts to produce meaningful activist art and create spaces where people can authorize their own truths. Kazi states,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"So many shows have healed me at Unit 2. There is a grassroots / radical queer/trans/2s festival we are initiating called BRICKS AND GLITTER happening this July is super exciting…we wanted to provide a space for QT2SBIPOC people and friends, young and old, but def we wanted to let young folks know they can build something and retain control over their art and movements. So everything has really inspired me. It was def a big influence of our last album ‘find safety'!" </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>From Bangalore to Toronto, artists create the possibility for collective experience and a responsibility to others in shared space. The sway of crowds on enticing dance floors that criss cross across world maps erodes the fearful isolation that often plagues urban publics. As Rosina states,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"I do think dancing together and celebrating together is so needed. We often fight over ideas, instead of getting to know each other first, then fighting over ideas. Trust is very important, and we can't build trust just on having the right ‘language' and social cues. Toronto is segregated, mostly by race and class, and few spaces I know hold up the true diversity of Toronto." </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Disparate bodies dance contrapuntally in many make shift refuges, momentarily gathering solidarities in cities of exiles.</p></div><span class="x-image e4365-e48 m3d9-1d"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/unit-2-4-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Unit 2, Toronto. Image 5." loading="lazy"></span><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e49 m3d9-v m3d9-y m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-13 m3d9-15 m3d9-16 m3d9-19 image-caption"><p>Unit 2, Toronto. Image 5.</p></div><div class="x-text x-content e4365-e50 m3d9-v m3d9-w m3d9-z m3d9-10 m3d9-11 m3d9-13 m3d9-17"><p>Artists carve feeling out of street debris and turn empty rooms into lasting memories. Kazi centres the affective meaning of art as that which evades narrow minds and scales of judgment, offering space for human sensitivity. They state,</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"><em>"But really compassion, forgiveness, positivity, resilience is at the core of Unit 2, with the understanding that we are dealing with so much pain, suffering, oppression, some more then others, and we need to try to support each other or at least not come for one another in certain spaces, understand it's a colonial tactic to conquer and divide, and try to open up hearts and spirits to challenge our/your own shit and our/your place in the world. To really know our imaginations can set us free, if only for a moment…" </em>(Rosina Kazi, Unpublished Interview, 2018)</p>
<p>Breaking free from the prisons we choose to live in, artists from Bangalore to Toronto can guide us to places and spaces of stolen freedom that terrify with the possibility of tenderness beyond cynicism. On roofs, in corridors, in the heat of makeshift dance floors, guided by a cacophony of light and sound, we lose ourselves in the untranslatable prose of love.</p></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e4365-e51 m3d9-0 m3d9-4"><div class="x-row e4365-e52 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-7 m3d9-8 m3d9-c m3d9-l"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e53 m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-12550 e4365-e54"><div class="x-section e12550-e1 m9om-0"><div class="x-row e12550-e2 m9om-1 m9om-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e12550-e3 m9om-3 m9om-4"><a class="x-image e12550-e4 m9om-6" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/tara-atluri/"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/tara-atluri-bio-150x150.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Tara Atluri" loading="lazy"></a></div><div class="x-col e12550-e5 m9om-3 m9om-5"><div class="x-text x-content e12550-e6 m9om-7 rungh-artists-short-bio-text"><p><strong>Tara Atluri</strong> has a PhD in Sociology. She has written two books. The most recent, <em>Uncommitted Crimes: The Defiance of the Artistic Imagi/nation</em> discusses subaltern artists in and from Turtle Island (Canada) whose inspiring artwork serves as political critique.</p></div><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e12550-e7 m9om-8" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/artists/tara-atluri/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><i class="x-icon x-graphic-child x-graphic-icon x-graphic-primary" aria-hidden="true" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;"></i></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">More</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e4365-e55 m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e4365-e56 m3d9-0 m3d9-4"><div class="x-row e4365-e57 m3d9-5 m3d9-7 m3d9-8 m3d9-9 m3d9-d m3d9-m m3d9-n"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e58 m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8989 e4365-e59"><div class="x-section e8989-e2 m6xp-0"><div class="x-row e8989-e3 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-3 m6xp-4 m6xp-8"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e4 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-d"><div class="x-text x-text-headline e8989-e5 m6xp-j"><div class="x-text-content"><div class="x-text-content-text"><h3 class="x-text-content-text-primary">Explore More Rungh</h3></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-row e8989-e6 m6xp-1 m6xp-2 m6xp-5 m6xp-6 m6xp-9"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e7 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-f"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e8 m6xp-k m6xp-l m6xp-m" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/archives/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/fairplay-june-2017-800x450-1.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="Rungh Archive" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Archive</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Download PDFs of the print magazine since 1992. View the preserved website since 2017.</span></div></div></a></div><div class="x-col e8989-e9 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-g"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e10 m6xp-k m6xp-n redux-cta-button" tabindex="0" href="https://redux.rungh.org" target="_blank"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-logo-black-300x181.png" width="300" height="181" alt="Rungh Artists &amp; Contributors" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">A self-directed journey through the print magazine archive, using Rungh's digital network and discoverability tool Redux.</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Enter <i  class="x-icon x-icon-caret-right" data-x-icon-s="&#xf0da;" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></div></div></a><div class="x-row e8989-e11 m6xp-1 m6xp-4 m6xp-5 m6xp-7 m6xp-a"><div class="x-bg" aria-hidden="true"><div class="x-bg-layer-lower-color" style=" background-color: rgb(147, 15, 42);"></div><div class="x-bg-layer-upper-image" style=" background-image: url(https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/redux-r-frieze-white.png); background-repeat: repeat-x; background-position: center; background-size: 50px;"></div></div><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8989-e12 m6xp-b m6xp-e m6xp-h"></div></div></div></div><div class="x-col e8989-e13 m6xp-b m6xp-c m6xp-e m6xp-i"><a class="x-anchor x-anchor-button has-graphic e8989-e14 m6xp-k m6xp-m m6xp-o" tabindex="0" href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/volume-11-number-1/"><div class="x-anchor-content"><span class="x-graphic" aria-hidden="true"><span class="x-image x-graphic-child x-graphic-image x-graphic-primary"><img decoding="async" src="https://rungh.thedev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ExhibitionIAmMyMothersDaughter2023-CarouselImg05-1024x576.jpg" width="830" height="467" alt="Farheen Haq. Forgiveness single channel video still, 2022. Courtesy of the artist" loading="lazy"></span></span><div class="x-anchor-text"><span class="x-anchor-text-primary">Rungh Magazine</span><span class="x-anchor-text-secondary">Read the newest issue of Rungh Magazine: Vol.&nbsp;11&nbsp;No.&nbsp;1.</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="x-section e4365-e60 m3d9-0 m3d9-4"><div class="x-row e4365-e61 m3d9-5 m3d9-6 m3d9-8 m3d9-9 m3d9-d m3d9-e m3d9-m m3d9-o"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e4365-e62 m3d9-q m3d9-r m3d9-s"><div class="cs-content x-global-block x-global-block-8991 e4365-e63"><div class="x-section e8991-e1 m6xr-0"><div class="x-row x-container max width e8991-e2 m6xr-1 m6xr-2"><div class="x-row-inner"><div class="x-col e8991-e3 m6xr-3"><div class="x-content-area e8991-e4 m6xr-4"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div>
<p>The post <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca/in-the-margins/">In the Margins</a> appeared first on <a href="https://rungh.thedev.ca">Rungh Cultural Society</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
